The Sea of Faith in New Zealand

In the spring of 1981 I was feeling beleaguered.

Taking Leave of God had appeared the previous October, and had caused much controversy. Certain people wanted me out. I was feeling distinctly short of friends, so it was a great pleasure to hear from the New Zealand theologian Lloyd Geering. He was in Britain on leave, had read and liked my book, and wanted to meet.

I knew of Lloyd Geering as the veteran of a famous heresy trial of the 1960s, and as the author of God in the New World (1968). An Old Testament scholar and a Presbyterian minister, he had been from 1962 the Principal of the Theological Hall at Knox College, Dunedin. He became influenced by the radical theology movement, and was influenced by the Death-of-God theologians and by John Robinson.

Views he expressed about the Resurrection, and then about life after death, caused a furore. In the summer of 1967 Robert Wardlaw and Robert Blaikie formally laid charges of heresy against Lloyd Geering in the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church. He defended himself ably and with composure, and was cleared.

But in 1970 controversy flared up again. Lloyd is a non-realist about God, holding that talk of God does not refer to a being, but is a symbolic way of speaking of the mystery of life and of expressing one's gratitude to life. The General Assembly dissociated itself from these views. Lloyd's position as Principal of the Church's premier theological training establishment was clearly becoming untenable. The University at Wellington in effect bailed him out by creating a Chair in Religious Studies for him, and he left Dunedin. But he did not leave either the ministry or the public eye : Lloyd Geering has continued to this day as a conspicuous public figure in New Zealand, and has turned out perhaps the most durable of the Sixties radicals.

So in 1981 it was good to talk with Lloyd, who gave me much encouragement. Preoccupied with my own troubles, I did not know that he was himself under some pressure at that time. I read his book Faiffs New Age (1980), with its Nietzschean conclusion, and got a valuable stimulus from it.

Since 1980 Lloyd and I have remained in touch, and he has been a defender of my ideas in New Zealand.

A lecture-tour was planned in 1989, but it only finally took place this summer, 1991. We worked our way down from North to South : Auckland, Hamilton, Wellington, Dunedin, Christchurch. Audiences were surprisingly large - larger than they would have been in Britain. No doubt the main reason for this is that Lloyd Geering, though now in his seventies, is still a very vigorous speaker and writer with a considerable following. He must have advertised our arrival. But in any case New Zealand has a long and distinguished liberal tradition : it was, for example, a generation ahead of Britain in giving votes to women and in its welfare legislation.

No church is established in New Zealand, and there is no religious instruction in schools. The three largest denominations are the Anglicans, the Roman Catholics and the Presbyterians, but as in Britain there are few church leaders with the ability to say anything interesting about religion in public. The only one I met was the admirable woman Anglican Bishop of Dunedin, Penny Jamieson. She is an impressive figure.

Others seemed to be keeping away, and Bishop John Spong of Newark, New Jersey, who was lecturing around New Zealand, told us he had had somewhat similar treatment. The public remain fascinated by religious ideas, and people want to know about current theological controversies. But church leaders everywhere seem to find it inexpedient to get involved.

In Wellington, there was a Sea of Faith Conference with contributions from Lloyd Geering and from Scott Cowdell of Brisbane, as well as from me. Those attending signed a petition asking for the transmission of the TV series, which after seven years has still not been shown. Indeed, it may now be too late to show it, because its language is not always 'inclusive' - non-sexist English is now obligatory in New Zealand, in church as elsewhere.

The most advanced church we attended, apart from St Andrew-on-the-Terrace, Wellington, was in another Presbyterian parish, St Ninian's, Riccarton. A former student of mine, Clive Pearson, is the minister and there is a substantial congregation. Pearson has worked harder than anyone else I have come across to modernize the language of worship. His hymnbook is wholly new. Here is the beginning of a hymn by Colin Gibson that we sang :

He came singing love,
and he lived singing love ;
he died, singing love.
He arose in silence.
For the love to go on
we must make it our song :
you and I be the singers.

Colin Gibson is, I am told, the Professor of English at Otago. He also writes his own tunes.

SOF Magazine 7, Autumn 1991 3 New Zealand is going through a somewhat difficult period. For a generation it has been in slow relative economic decline. The good race relations on which the country has traditionally prided itself are currently threatened by high unemployment and big cuts in various State benefits. But despite these distractions we were very warmly welcomed.

By the way, the Lloyd Geering festschrift, Faith in an Age of Turmoil (1990), edited by James Veitch, is published by Oriental University Press, 38 Kennington Lane, London, SE11 4LS. I hope we may yet see Lloyd and Elaine Geering in Britain.

On returning home I learned that an NZ TV station has purchased the Sea of Faith series. So perhaps it will be shown. But I don't know if I will ever see that superb landscape again.

COMING UP IN THE NEXT ISSUE * a contribution to modern spirituality on the question of mortality * and a Cynic in the Network asks : "Do faith/ action disjunctions matter ?" SOF Magazine 7, Autumn 1991 19 CONTRIBUTORS DON CUPITT is Lecturer in the Philosophy of Religion in the University of Cambridge and Dean of Emmanuel College.