MORE POETRY THAN TRUTH by Charles Plouviez "I wandered lonely as a cloud" is the opening line of one of the most popular poems in the English language.
It is also a downright lie.
As every Wordsworth student knows, the poet was not alone on the memorable occasion when he saw the daffodils at Ullswater, but walking with his sister.
Dorothy recounts the incident in her journal for Thursday 15th April 1802: "When we were in the woods beyond Gowbarrow Park we saw a few daffodils close to Om watorsido ... as we went along there were more and yet more and at last under the boughs of the trees, we saw that there was a long belt of them along the shore, about the breadth of a country turnpike road. I never saw daffodils so beautiful ... some rested their heads upon these stones as on a pillow for weariness and the rest tossed and reeled and danced and seemed as if they verily laughed with the wind that blew upon them over the lake, they looked so gay ever glancing ever changing." Wordsworth wrote his famous poem two years later, after reading Dorothy's journal ; the verbal parallels are too close to be coincidental. And he later said that the two finest lines in the poem had been contributed by his wife. So this hymn to the poet's powers of solitary recollection is in fact a family effort.
Yet we do not dismiss Wordsworth as no better than Baron Munchausen. We say that the "poetic truth" expressed by the verses is of more significance than the mundane business of getting the facts right.
Clearly, this word "truth" is a slippery customer.
The paradox of poetry and truth goes back at least to Plato, who resolved it deftly by crowning the poet with garlands, and then banishing him from his ideal
Republic. Yet the poet's dilemma differs from our own everyday experience only in degree. Crudely, we have no access to any "external reality" that is not mediated by our own innate structure and previous experience. Even scientific observation, we now recognise, may be crucially affected by the presence of the observer. And, pace Mrs Thatcher, the sum total of value-free historical facts is not truth but incoherence.
Homo sapiens is a pattern-making animal. Some of the patterns we make can, to express it roughly, be validated or falsified by their practical consequences : these are the realms of empiricism and science.
Others are the autonomous acts of our imagination or our will : these are the province of the arts, ethics and religion. There is no objective way to judge the quality of a sonnet, the effectiveness of a religious rite, or the universality of a moral law. We can only share our experiences as honestly and openly as possible, and either reach agreement or agree to differ.
Ay, but there's the rub. In the quiet surroundings of a university campus, we can meet and discuss such things with the urbanity of a high tableful of dons. In the hurly-burly of the world outside, it is not so easy.
Liberal toleration is a busted flush when the other side has the guns. And it is not toleration but downright cowardice to appear objective about something over which you care passionately : the abuse of a child, or the genocide of a people.
The governor of Strangeways Prison has said that he sees the hand of the devil in the recent revolt. But when, a few months earlier, a mob of Romanians made a similar mess of Ceausescu's palace, they were hailed as freedom fighters. I confess to finding it difficult to be tolerant about both judgements.
Let me say why. I respect and admire the Catholic faith tremendously, believing it to be one of the most profound and comprehensive symbolic systems that humans have achieved. But when it starts personifying evil, disregarding the individual acts and motivations of people whose behaviour is disapproved, it is taking an important step along the path that we know from history leads inexorably to the burning of books, and the burning of people. And there I draw the line.
Likewise, I find much in the principles and practices of Stalinist communism utterly repellent. But I cannot persuade myself that the people who have at last revolted against it throughout eastern Europe are all motivated by high ideals of personal freedom. The pictures of East Germans last year flocking through the Berlin Wall in order to go to discos did not lift my spirits.
This personal digression has a point. It is not any theory of knowledge, any theology or metaphysic which denotes what my fundamental beliefs really are, but the sum of my reactions to specific events.
Religion, by definition, must be for everyone that which is of fundamental concern - the a priori beliefs which determine the manner in which we pattern our experience, and consequently the way we behave.
We may have consciously and conscientiously acquired those beliefs, or they may be the result of our childhood conditioning or a hotchpotch of received ideas from books or newspapers, politicians or preachers. We are none of us entirety free to choose what we shall believe, but nor are we ever completely at the mercy of our past.
There is an idea going around in radical circles that we must all nowadays create our own religion. This seems to me as absurd as saying that we must all write our own epic. There are plenty of good ones around, far better than most of us can create for ourselves, so why not make use of them ? Far more important is that we should all take the trouble to find out what our real religion - our deepest concern - is : if it turns out to be sex, or money, or power, and we are happy with that, so be it. But the religious life consists in coming to recognise our fundamental concerns and modifying them towards whatever conscious ideal we want to achieve.
Viewed from this angle, toleration takes another shape. If religion is something that is being worked on, not just a set of passively accepted data, then I have to accept that other people may come to conclusions different from mine. My 'truth' may be subjective after all, but if it is valid for me, that is enough ; and at a pinch I may have to fight for it. But fighting to destroy other people's 'truths' is ultimately a futile strategy ; no body of ideas in the world has been destroyed by oppression. So toleration is not just a wishy-washy liberal idea, but a hard-eyed realization that that is the way things are. And we can welcome the poets back into our republic. Even Wordsworth.