New Wine – Old Wine Skins

NEW WINE - OLD WINE SKINS by Martin Roberts. I must say how much I appreciated John Mann's first article in the Spring edition of Sea of Faith Magazine to the effect that radical theology has not yet cashed itself into a concrete spirituality, in some sort of institutional form. This is certainly the most vexed and exhausting question for many of us who have long since lived with the philosophical and social expressions of radical theology. Arguably it is the most important issue to face if the Christian church is to have any type of reform from within. I wish to explore critically some of the issues involved here and make radical theology face the issue of institutional religion more rigorously.

Let me throw out a provocative statement : if the church, as it is presently, doesn't reform itself and eventually dies, or becomes a complete ghetto, or ii radicals move out, then sooner or later radical theology and religious thought generally will itself die out. It will then be replaced by various 'consciousness raising' groups, social causes and the like. I am not decrying the latter, but simply pointing out that you really cannot divorce theory and practice, or radical theology and the institutional practice of religion.

Without some sort of church there cannot be radical theology and an identifiable religious vision of life to which it gives rise.

Personally speaking, I do not believe that radicals can indefinitely go on using traditional liturgies etc, in such a way that they privately or publically pull the plug out of their 'realist' formulations, without inducing psychological tensions and intellectual double-think to breaking point. It is ultimately the old business of new wine in old wine skins.

The plot thickens at this point. Let's start all over again, from scratch, and construct a radical church based on and proclaiming the liberating 'memory of Jesus', freed from the corruption of church history and Greek metaphysics. A nice dream perhaps but certainly no more than that. Any cognizance of contemporary New Testament scholarship will make it clear that it is impossible to cut through the complexities and assumptions both of biblical texts and of scholars to even get started on anything like a 'new quest for the historical Jesus'. Whatever we come up with tells us more about ourselves and our priorities (or about the 'Christ of faith', as Tillich puts it) than it does about the man Jesus who is supposedly graspable as an attractive liberator 'behind' a covering of church dogma. When we clear the muddy waters of church history and dogma what we see reflected is our own face.

So where do we go from here ? Any graspable and institutional radical Christian spirituality must find its identity somehow in the Christ-event. It subsists in the telling of that story. Apart from this focus it is only possible to express a natural religiosity or general feeling about life which (though fine in itself) is by definition (or lack of it) incapable of an /Asa/lions/ expression. And yet this very requirement, so fundamental to the possibility of an institutional expression, is lacking. Just what is the story and how do we tell it intelligibly ?

All we have to go on is complex and ambiguous witness in the New Testament but even these experiences tell us more about the first Christians than they do about Jesus. And whatever knowledge of Jesus comes to us through their experience of him, is of the same order as our knowledge of them. For we are still up against Jesus' assumptions, limitations and general world-view so that the significance of whatever we find attractive in him has to be radically reinterpreted (possibly out of all recognition and continuity) to become in any way relevant to our late 20th Century world-views. If this is so, it is difficult to see how the biblical tradition can contribute to or challenge our own contemporary experience of life.

All we can do is identify the differences. Where are the points of contact and continuity between them ?

All I can see is discontinuity and critique (or deconstruction - Derrida).

Maybe we could try to reform the church in terms of impressionistic, free-floating symbols and images which come out of our own life experience and seem to resonate with certain biblical images and stories.

But the connections are too arbitrary and the continuity too selective. On this reckoning, radical thinking could (and should) extend this impressionistic approach to other religious traditions, but that would hardly make it a serious expression of contemporary Buddhism or Hinduism. The same applies to the relation with traditional Christianity.

So some hard thinking needs to be done here and it is precisely the pracliae of religion, or what is to constitute the institutional expression of religion, that sharpens up the issue and brings it to a head.

Maybe the way ahead is more radical than radicals think. There needs to be a radical church but in what can it consist ? If this cannot be clarified then radical theology as such will die out. And if the latter happens it will signal the end of religion - perhaps, ironically, the completion of the history of religions.

MARTIN ROBERTS is a team rector and polytechnic chaplain in Leicester.