The Difference Between Me and Graham Shaw

THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ME AND GRAHAM SHAW by Anne Ashworth. "It's all very well for you!" I remember complaining to Graham Shaw over lunch at SOF I.

He had been explaining why, in his Anglican view, radicals need not concern themselves with the meaning of the words used in liturgy. 'We in the Free Churches, " I continued, "have - at least until now - assumed that we meant what we were saying." "Oh bless you, children 1" cried Graham, laughing uproariously - perhaps to mitigate the patronising effect of that priestly-patriarchal exclamation.

But the matter cannot be so lightly dismissed.

Conducting worship in United Reformed Churches most Sundays, I am all too aware of a weight of responsibility. In our liberal and word-oriented tradition, we take words seriously. Congregations expect that a leader of worship will have chosen, composed, devised and arranged all the words used in a service with care and deliberation. And you can use a lot of words in an hour, as every broadcaster knows.

I chose, and continue to choose, the URC as the only denomination liberal enough to be tolerable. No creeds, no catechism, no Wesley's doctrines, no salvation cliches : room to think. Fine. But now, having gradually abandoned realism, I struggle with a new paradox. Anglicans may not need to mean what they say, but in our tradition integrity still demands that we should. So it is now actually more difficult to be a radical in the supposedly liberated URC than in the apparently creed-bound catholic traditions.

How long will I remain ? How long can I go on articulating a congregation's needs by prayers which address a 'You' ? How much longer must intellect and honesty perform unbecoming gymnastics as I sing most of our hymns ? I am perilously near the edge of the precipice. How honest am I even with myself, in my struggle with the God-shaped blank ? - a pain which still requires religious aspirin.

There are cogent reasons for staying with the church, as Don Cupitt and Loyal Rue have explained. The wider world needs the lobbying power of such a community, and radicals need a vehicle. Besides, where else can the individual find nourishment ? Pub, club or association may be convivial and supportive, but cannot engage with the deeper levels of experience or set out to confront the ultimate questions. And the Christ story still functions. It focuses on basic experience : birth, death, love, suffering, joy, moral conflict. It provides picture and narrative to mirror and make sense of life. As Charles Plouviez put in the spring magazine : "the symbolism of the Incarnation ... both articulates the value of every single human life and relieves us from the mental prison of solipsism." Another church then ? Hardly. I'm a word woman. I don't want Catholic candles or Salvationist brass bands or Quaker silence ; nor even, as in the Church of England, other people's word patterns. Besides, the URC has fine minds, including better brains than mine. It has creative, exploring people committed to some of the most worthwhile campaigns of modern Christian concern.

So, at least for the foreseeable future, I shall go on working for the URC. How can I at least make it tolerable for myself to conduct worship ? And can I somehow help those, never identified but perhaps hidden in any congregation, who are also moving towards a non-realist position ?

First, let us be clear about the aims and functions of public worship in the Free Church tradition, and consider how far these are acceptable to a radical view.

To worship God ? For that we can substitute "To affirm and celebrate life".

To urge to mission ? Let us say, to raise consciousness of the needs of the world and promote altruistic attitudes and effort.

To bring Christ to the soul ? We can rephrase this as enabling people to find inspiration, comfort, courage, liberation, challenge.

To be the body of Christ ? To promote kofrlome, a sense of community in love - that needs little reinterpretation.

With these four functions in mind, and the happy freedom of a URC preacher to select material and arrange it appropriately, a wealth of opportunity becomes apparent. Some biblical material is required; but a little Bible reading goes a long way. I can be very selective, choosing anything from Genesis to Revelation. Other readings can be drawn from other faiths, other literatures, last week's newspapers, the scientists, the novelists or the poets. Themes like SUMMER 1990 PAGE 5 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE Justice, Peace and the Integrity of Creation need no dogmatic theology.

But what about those prayers ? Ah yes, there's the rub. As Clive Richards plainly Indicated in the spring magazine, "Praise and appeals for mercy are misplaced in the absence of a Creator on whom all depends. Attitudes of submission to a non-existent authority are an affront to human dignity ... Prayer is too often solely confused with petitionary activity which is clearly redundant for the radical." Nevertheless, he went on : "On the corporate level, prayer can be used to articulate community concerns and hopes." Most URC services call for two main prayers (more at communion services) as well as shorter items like dedications and benedictions. The language of realism is unavoidable, but its impact can be lessened.

The first prayer, often leading into the Lord's Prayer, is invocatory. We have to address someone. 'Almighty God' is nonsense. 'Holy Father', even if you waive the mythology, is patriarchal. 'Lord Jesus' is silly. I compromise by addressing the Holy Spirit, who at least is decently vague and amorphous. The myth or model in my own mind - and occasionally unpacked in sermons - is either of universal energy (something like Shelley's Power which energised wind and waterfall, intellect and moral force), or of God as the totality of human aspiration. The prayer of invocation can be used to celebrate life, paying lip-service to the 'thanksgiving' mode.

The second prayer, primarily for intercession, may be easier to handle. One can sometimes evade the 'You' formulation by a bidding along the lines of "Let us think about, concentrating all our loving concern ..." At the least, such intercessions function as consciousness raising for the congregation. And indeed it is not impossible that in some cases natural empathetic causes do operate, so that corporate concentration is sometimes efficacious. I have known some completely non-religious people who do not scoff at intercession or its analogues, poets' spells.

As for communion services, I find that worshippers are often pleased and stimulated when I deviate from the expected. They appreciate the power and the poetry of an expanding symbolism. Bread - the 'body of Christ' - can be liturgically described as symbolising and celebrating all physical matter ; broken bread betokens a suffering world. Wine is both the cup of suffering and the cup of celebration ; the wine of life.

But it's not easy. I grow weary of offering new wine in old wineskins, weary of compromise, weary of battling with my conscience. I still don't know how long I'll balance on the high-wire. Anyone got a safety net ?

Anne Ashworth lives in Blackpool and is engaged in editorial work and other activities in the United Reform Church; an accredited lay preacher.