Dishonest to God – On Keeping Religion out of Politics by Mary Warnock. Continuum (London 2010). Hbk. 166 pages. £16.99.
There is much in this little book to interest and please readers of Sofia. ‘Religion, it hardly needs to be said, is a construct, like morality itself, of the human imagination’ (p.128).
Mary Warnock is a philosopher who has been much involved in the affairs of the world as a fellow of St Hugh’s College, Oxford, Head Mistress of Oxford High School, Mistress of Girton College, Cambridge, chair person of a number of government committees and latterly as a member of the House of Lords. She belongs to that tradition of philosophers, like Bertrand Russell, who take a leading role in public affairs. The aim of her book is to separate morality from religion especially with regard to the enactment of new laws through the political process, at the same time reflecting upon the positive value of religion in modern society.
The first two chapters discuss in some detail the legislative processes in recent times in which the laws concerning the abolition of the death penalty, homosexuality, abortion, in vitro fertilisation and stem cell research were changed, invariably in a liberalising direction. Observing the participation of the bishops in the House of Lords and representatives of other religions she noticed that once they had made their ‘faith’ declaration, such as ‘Life is Sacred …’ they then used arguments about the practical effects of the proposed change without any further reference to its religious implications. The former Archbishop of York, John Hapgood, in the debate on limiting research on the human embryo to the first 14 days after fertilisation stated that Christian theology had no quarrel with the idea that the beginning of human life was a process rather than an event. Mary Warnock tells us that in that debate an aging cross-bench peer said to her that Christians could have nothing to do with these matters. She said, ‘What about the Archbishop of York?’ to which he replied, ‘He’s not a Christian!’ In the following chapters she discusses the gradual separation of morality from religion and argues that the development of morality is a human activity depending upon society’s innate sense of fairness, compassion and imagination. She explains the philosophical background of this with reference to the writings of Don Cupitt and others.
She concludes with the assertion that while parliamentary democracy has its faults, we must do ‘all we can to fend off the forces of theocracy’ (p.166).
There are two areas of critical comment. Here and there in this book Mary Warnock reflects an understanding, shared by many, that faith is a set of absolute propositions to which some people give intellectual assent and on which they base all their moral beliefs and attitudes. Mary Warnock clearly thinks that many politicians and religious people hold to this definition of faith. This is a serious problem because, for example, it gives rise to some fanatical opposition to ‘faith’ schools. Such a position does not do justice to the meaning of faith. According to the Gospels faith is an act of the will, a decision to live and behave in a certain way, according to the teachings of Jesus. Slavish obedience to doctrinal orthodoxy cannot be regarded as the mark of true Christian discipleship. So the woman who touched Jesus’s garment to be healed of her disease is told, ‘Woman, your faith has made you well’ (Mt 29: 22).
Again, it seems to me, Mary Warnock does not deal adequately with the moral teaching of the Bible. While it may be true that much of it is no longer comprehensible to us in the 21st century, I would like to have seen a more nuanced understanding. Certainly the Bible teaches some moral principles to which few would object – love your neighbour etc – and what it does without equivocation is to call us to obedience to the moral law. Surely we regard that as true even if the content of the law is understood to be a human creation. Those who have to make careful arrangements to deal with minorities could learn a thing or two from St Paul, who deals with the issue of the weak consciences of those who cannot accept the freedom of Christians to eat what they like. (See 1 Cor chapter 8). I recommend this interesting and well-produced* little book. * I could find only one editorial error. On page 163 there is a reference to canon Lucy Winker. This, of course, should read Canon Lucy Winkett.
The Venerable David S. Lee is a retired cleric of the Church in Wales.
Paperback edition due October 2011 at £10.99.