Eternal Life: A New Vision by John Selby Spong

Eternal Life: A New Vision by John Selby Spong. HarperOne (New York 2010). Pbk. 288 pages. £6.99.

Compared to the titles of some of his previous books such as Resurrection: Myth or Reality and The Sins of Scripture one might at first glance think that with a title of Eternal Life: A New Vision, Jack Spong has softened in old age. However you are quickly disabused of this by the subtitle of Beyond Religion, Beyond Theism, beyond Heaven and Hell. Also there is no holding back with chapter headings such as, ‘The Tools of Religious Manipulation’ and ‘Putting Away Childish Things: The Death of Religion’.

Jack’s first words are: ‘This may well be my final book’ but then he qualifies this with, ‘this is indeed my fifth final book’. We now know that a further final book will be published in the spring on The Gospel of John. He refers to his experience that ‘the subject of the next book is always opened to me by the study done in preparation for the present book.’ And ‘this book on life after death drove me deeply and in a new way into the Fourth Gospel’.

Jack Spong is now approaching 80 and although he has written his autobiography he has used his own life and experiences in this book to give a context and to illustrate some of the points he wishes to make. The death of his father when Jack was only twelve clearly had a dramatic impact upon him. He describes comforters coming to the family and that, ‘many of them seemed compelled to describe how happy my father was now that he was no longer sick. The word “heaven” also entered the conversation frequently, being referred to as a place of ultimate bliss. It was, people said, the highest destiny for which one’s life could hope, for there the presence of God could be constantly enjoyed. Something about this was amiss, however, even in my young mind, for if we really believed that, why were we so sad?’ His father’s illness gave him the chance to taste and experience a very different kind of religion from that in which he was raised when his Aunt Laurie took him to another church. This provided the impetus to his long religious journey from Biblical Fundamentalism to his statement that, ‘Christianity is for me no longer about an invasive deity; it is about a fully human one in whom God becomes profoundly present and inherently visible.’ Much of the book will seem to cover ground that Jack Spong has written about before, such as his attack on organised Christianity and its practices. He is greatly concerned with our relationship with God and in particular our desire to flatter God. He illustrates this in the way we address God and the hymns we sing, the posture and demeanour of people in church and that we are encouraged liturgically to say dreadful things about ourselves in a tactic to win favour.

In moving forward in this way it is not surprising that later he states, ‘There is no supernatural God who lives above the sky or beyond the universe. There is no supernatural God who can be understood as animating spirit, Earth mother, masculine tribal deity or external monotheistic being. There is no parental deity watching over us from whom we can expect help.

There is no deity whom we can flatter into acting favourably or manipulate be being good. There are no record books and no heavenly judge keeping them to serve as the basis on which human beings will be rewarded or punished.’ So after all this it may be found surprising that the last chapter of the book is entitled, ‘I Believe in Life Beyond Death.’ The key to this, I believe, is in his chapter on, ‘The Approach of the Mystics’. In this chapter he identifies his own present view of religion and Christianity with that of the mystics and specifically, Meister Eckhart.

He sees himself as being like the mystics in moving beyond the boundaries that are imposed by organised religion. This is why he sees that the mystics ‘might turn out to be the means through which the essence of yesterday’s religion can be transformed into tomorrow’s spiritual understanding’.

I now look forward to the next final book where he sees John’s Gospel through a mystical lens.

Philip Feakin is a Day Chaplain at Southwark Cathedral and a keen, but fallible, student of New Testament Greek. He is a member of SOF.