A History of Christianity by Diarmaid MacCulloch

Warning: this is a ‘bible’ of a book! Weighing in at over one thousand, tightly printed, pages it’s definitely not for the ordinary coffee table. My initial reaction was, do we need yet another History of Christianity? I have, for example, Paul Johnson’s and Bamber Gascoyne’s substantial works on the shelf. Having said that, one has only to dip into this work to realise this is different. One is swept along by the marvellously lucid text which bears a formidable scholarship with a lightness of touch and even humour.

One thing that makes this work immediately, and initially curiously, different is the subtitle: The First Three Thousand Years. Hasn’t MacCulloch got his dates wrong here? The answer is no, for he sees Christianity as a product of its ancestry in the Classical and Biblical world: in the beginning was the logos, and this is a Greek word and concept. Beginning with Homer rather than Luke makes much clear about both Christianity’s fundamental concepts and institutions.

Like any living organism it has shown ‘a remarkable capacity to mutate’, to adapt and assimilate: though traditionalists always try to deny this.

MacCulloch sees its twofold ancestry as one of the reasons for Christianity’s instability, which underlies both the dynamism and conflicts of its history.

Another reason is the early tripartite split between three cultural worlds, those of Greek and Latin and also of its Oriental origins. He explores equally the stories of these three worlds, between which there was little overlap for a thousand years, noting that the ‘extraordinary accident of the irruption of Islam’ was the chief reason for Christianity turning in another direction. In our own time we are witnessing the finale of Christianity in the Middle East as resurgent Islamic fundamentalists vow to ‘put the sword to the neck of all unbelievers’ who still inhabit these lands. Though MacCulloch notes that for most of its existence Christianity has been the most intolerant of world faiths, doing its best to eliminate all competitors, it is sobering to think that Jihad/Crusade still has a stronger resonance with many than ecumenism/ fraternity.

As this history is presented as ‘a personal view’ one may wonder at MacCulloch’s own position in the spectrum of belief. It is presented as that of ‘a candid friend’, who appreciates the seriousness of a religious mentality – he grew up in a vicarage – but who remains puzzled at ‘how something so apparently crazy can be so captivating to millions’. He makes no pronouncement as to whether Christianity, or indeed any religious belief, is ‘true’, remaining respectful but critical. As to the key event at the heart of Christianity, the story of Easter Resurrection, he writes that ‘this is not a matter which historians can authenticate; it is a different sort of truth.’ In this he reveals his stance as fundamentally one of liberal Protestantism, and indeed he writes at his best and most authoritatively on the protestant era – the subject of his previously award winning book, Reformation.

The history culminates in the ‘Culture Wars’ of the present, which have led Christianity into new, uncharted territory resulting from the collapse of Christendom – that ‘fifteen-hundred-year-old adventure’ of alliance between emperors and bishops – which was one of the casualties of the First World War: A War That Killed Christendom. What replaced it was epitomised by ‘the fugitive observations’ of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, indicating the beginnings of a radically new, deracinated era. Despite the consequent turbulence, the emergence of charismatic and traditionalist movements has indicated that ‘old time religion is not quite so old-time as it seems’ – though history is probably the last thing on their minds.

Ironically, whilst MacCulloch’s liberalism is for the Church the halfway house to extinction, intolerant fundamentalism is now resurgent. Which leaves him pondering the future of Christianity in relation to secularism. He concludes that, even for those who see the Christian story as just that – a series of stories – its great quality is the ability to excite ‘the experience of wonder: the ability to listen and contemplate’. Without these qualities humanity has no future.

Each section of this work is almost a book in itself, enabling one to easily dip in for reference, and perhaps that is the way most people will read this book. Even so, despite its monumental scope there will always be room for more, or queries as to interpretations and emphases, a deeper delving for connections and causes. But, in the end, keeping the momentum of the narrative flowing is MacCulloch’s great achievement.

The history of Christianity is not a particularly edifying one, even if the lives of some of its practitioners are. Rather, it is the story of man (and invariably it is about men) fallible and flawed, pursuing ambitions all the more dangerous for their utopian and apocalyptic intent. MacCulloch’s narrative is testimony to all of this. If not exactly for the coffee table, his work would grace any library shelf. Indeed, no library will be complete without it.

Dominic Kirkham is an interested follower of SOF. He now works for a Home Improvement Agency providing services for older people.