From the Lap of the Gods … Into Our Own Hands

FROM THE LAP OF THE GODS ... INTO OUR OWN HANDS Joanna Clark Recently I have re-read the fascinating novel by Mary Renault called The King_Must Die. I do not know how accurate it is about early Greek and Minoan religious beliefs but it fits in well enough with what I have read of scholars' views of the beliefs of the Mediterranean peoples in pre-Biblical and Biblical times, such as the Canaanite beliefs and the ideas of the Phoenicians and Egyptians which existed alongside the Mosaic ones, to let me feel engrossed in the religious dimension of the story.

In the book the hero travels widely, meeting those who worship The Mother and honour women above men, while he himself feels more comfortable in lands where male gods dominate and men honour kings not queens. But wherever he travels he knows the gods are all around, controlling his and everyone's destiny, and even though his own gods are male he never dares ignore the gods and goddesses of the areas he enters. Nothing happens by chance : omens are to be seen in every oddity of nature and the gods must be appeased and pleased and their wishes considered before any mortal takes an action. Sacrifice and blood-spilling is the norm. Humans, or occasionally their animal substitutes, die in profusion. No major undertaking can be made without an offering, no wrong action can occur without a sacrifice of atonement and appeasement be offered. It is a frightening world, full of dangers and fears : it is a book just ripe for full colour film production.

Today I went to a 1662 Communion service, not my normal habit, and because my mind was full of Mary Renault's book I noticed how very much Cranmer's world was coloured by a Christian version of the same religious view.

God is to be appeased, pleased, persuaded. His wishes are to be considered before a man acts.

Sacrifice has been offered, so we are pretty well safe, but the repetition of the rite verbally is necessary to remind the god that all has been done as required, just in case he lets loose his vengeance on us. The world is still a frightening place, under the control of a powerful god, and no man is sure that a wrong action will go unnoticed and that something will not be required of him to pay for it.

Most of us do not live with such a world-view now.

The world is still frightening when AIDS has no known cure, redundancy can make you lose your home, the SOF Magazine 7, Autumn 1991 9 world's banking system can destroy your country's chances of development, nuclear power stations can leak dangerously into the surroundings and drunken drivers can kill pedestrians ; true we still have reason for fear. But we do not feel it is all in the laps of the gods : it is in the hands and wills of humans to rectify these dangers and injustices.

And what cannot be cured, so far, we want to learn to cope with as best as humanly possible. We do not seek to placate some god, we do not expect to have our burden lifted if we offer the appropriate sacrifice or token. Instead, as adult humans we hope to learn from our problems, for the sake of others and for our own development and personal growth.

So how can Christianity cope with this new type of outlook ? Jesus' death as a "propitiation for our sins" can no longer mean anything. He died, as so many still do, from human politics, cowardice, ignorance - and not from any vengeful god demanding a blood sacrifice. He died, as many have done, for a cause - and he may or may not have furthered his cause by his death : it certainly had repercussions beyond his expectations (as happens to all human actions, for we all have limited understanding of the effects of our actions in the future).

If all this makes Jesus 'just' a man, then the Christians have lost one of their credal positions, but they have gained a chance to be universally intelligible again : people the world over can benefit from having a generous, loving hero to follow. And a great barrier between Christianity and the other monotheistic religions has been lifted.

We live in such a small world now that to have unnecessary barriers is a great danger. To be committed to one way of looking at life, to follow one particular leader as the one who makes sense for you and yet, at the same time, to acknowledge that others will follow other leaders and interpret their lifeexperiences according to other views is not a loss but a gain.

If all those people who see life as having an extra dimension to it beyond the mere acquisition of property, possessions, pride, women, children, beauty or whatever it is drives them on, if those who see that there is a depth to life which puts meaning into it, if those people stopped insisting that their religion was the only true one - and instead helped those with no such dimension to life to gain one : then the world would be an enriched place. Christianity could become a world-enhancing religion if it gave up that very thing which it has centralised on for so long - the exclusive relationship between the man Jesus and 'God'.

Anyone who, like me, has been teaching R.E. in English schools recently will know that we now teach all about the major religions that are practised in Britain. We teach about the way human beings express the depth and wealth they feel as they experience the various stages of our lives : a new baby is welcomed into families and communities with special ceremonies in all the world's religions ; reaching adulthood ? there are ceremonies for this ; finding a life-partner - there are universal rites of betrothal and marriage ; and, of course, the end of life is marked by all humans as something of importance.

If Christianity wants to continue to have relevance to modern people it must face these common human facts. The world is no longer governed by gods of fate or even a God of Justice and Love : now we live in a world in which human psychological development is the key to understanding. Our new 'theology' must have a human face : human needs, human values need recognising now. We do not want to bow low before some King of Heaven, or Lord Jesus, served by a priestly hierarchy (of mainly male acolytes) : what we value now is the participation of equals in a world for which we are responsible and co-creators of.

Just as in the past Christianity used the language and thought-forms of the people, so now it must do the same. Our language is now of community, universality, development, co-operative ventures, personal relationships ; our language is very rich and getting richer as psychology teaches us more about ourselves. If only the church could be brave enough to use it instead of the old hierarchical, externallyreferred terms it offers now, then people would return to the church, for there is clearly a great need in human beings to find meaning for our lives.

It is a pity that the church offers 'meaning' that is incomprehensible to most people. (Who now can understand the idea that we are to be 'saved' ? From what ? Who wants 'eternal' life ? Is this quantity or quality ? What is a 'king' or 'lord', other than something to take photos of for profit ? Why pray out loud, when people have been taught to 'read in their heads' ever since infant school and they know the value of silence ? What is God creating, since the world has been evolving itself for so long ? Why is Jesus the only son, when all humans know themselves to be unique and valuable ? Why is it more important to be male, when we all know that the mother has great influence on human development ?) All questions have answers, of course ; but why set them up in the first place ? The churches' insistence on the value of tradition to the exclusion, almost, of the new values and knowledge is damaging.

Theology must take into account, of course, the inheritance of the past, for we are all made of our pasts ; but it must also take into account the present experiences of people because it is in the present that people seek religious answers - and they are not getting them from Christianity as it is now offered by the mainstream churches. (The answers that some are getting from fundamentalist, sectarian groups are not going to be the answers for many people.) If the mainline churches are to be of use to most people they must alter the way they speak and even think.

When I was taking communion to people in hospital 10 SOF Magazine 7, Autumn 1991 last week I was spoken to by an eighty year old, lively woman with a broken arm. Her daughter had died as a teenager, her daughter-in-law had died in her early thirties, her grand-daughter had died as a child from leukaemia, but she herself was strong and healthy and was enjoying the third year of her second marriage to a widower, a friend of many years of her dead first husband. She did not want to question God, nor to blame God for the untimely deaths : she was not living in a religious time-warp as the church services would have her do, she just wanted to talk about the need to come to terms with what is tough and rejoice in what is good.

She could see perfectly well the neutrality of life - it is neither kind nor unkind, there is no Being controlling destiny, "weighing our merits and pardoning our offenses". What there is is a deep human need to understand what has happened to each one of us and learn from our experiences. We are not on a journey to somewhere outside, but we are on a journey of self-discovery and personal growth within.

The integrated, whole person, who recognises her own merits and offenses and can live with them, usefully and constructively for the benefit of others and for the peace of her own mind - that is the person who has reached 'God'.

Volcanic eruptions, electricity, nuclear power, none of them are good or bad : they are neutral forces which we may use well or badly. We can die if we live near active volcanoes, or reap the benefit of the rich soil when all is calm ; we can torture people with electricity or use it for life-saving machines. We all know nowadays that we live in a world of neutral forces, and that it is humans who must take responsibility for how we use them. We have no need of supernatural persons and we do not personify the forces of nature any longer.

No more does the sun god ride his chariot across the heavens, the storm gods stir the clouds or the stars control our destinies. Why then should we listen to stories of the devil tempting Jesus, the star leading wise men over the desert to him, or hear him address his "Father in heaven" ? The churches have spent a great deal of time de-mythologising this, teaching people that it is all poetic talk, and helping people to interpret and apply the Bible's words to our modern situation.

We could do something different. We could admit that all of this was written for people in a different time, with a three-tiered universe, full of scary, uncontrollable principalities and powers. We could lose our 300 year old attachment to the written word and we could return to the flexibility of an earlier age when traditions were handed on orally and could be adapted as appropriate for speaker and listener alike.

We could recognise the power of the present.

We could re-write the Gospel ! We could say that the good news is that all humans are sons and daughters of 'God'. That is, that each one of us has potential on conception of becoming fully-human, and therefore each one of us has value.

To be fully-human is to be a person who does not act 'inhumanely', who does not live as though only his or her outward appearance was all that mattered, who does not ignore the needs of those around him. To be fully-human is to seek to encourage others to reach their potential too - it is supremely, to act as part of a community, to share its language, its traditions, its culture, its beliefs. No human can remain a full human when isolated : we learn who we are by seeing ourselves in relationship to others. If the church could so direct its followers to share this intense valuing of one another, to worship the that-within and not the that-without, it would have some real good news for this warlike race.

Then Jesus, along with other great leaders, can become of use to us - he does indeed become "the first of many brothers" (and sisters) and we can all make some use out of the traditional stories. He becomes an example, which a semi-divine being cannot be, who can genuinely be an inspiration.

Because he is not unique and therefore removed from the rest of us, because he is 'merely' a human like the rest of us, where he goes we can follow. That is good news, way beyond the present supernatural stuff the church gives out now.

What Good News do people need nowadays ? They do not need rescuing from a powerful exterior being who kills the wicked, or out of loving kindness (I) will accept a willing substitute. They do not need rescuing from an after-death judgement day. They do not need rescuing from a sinful body, lured to evil by bodily lusts and passions, (particularly women's). They do not need to be given a life hereafter to make up for this appalling one here 'below'.

What people need now is to be valued and esteemed.

Each person's self-worth needs honouring. The good news for us is that we can do this for one another, and that it has been the slow evolution of life, particularly mammals, and above all humans, towards this goal. The good news is that being born, living and dying is all part of a life process, in which we have a tiny but vital part to play.

Just as a healthy cell in a body seems unnoticeable, but the moment it becomes cancerous and damages the rest it becomes obvious - so it is with each of us.

Our healthy, appropriate continuation is vital for the good of the whole body. To support one another in our inter-dependent existence is our aim. We are of the world, we share its health and are made sick by its sickness. The good news is that responsible actions by responsible beings will enable our part of the universe to continue well for some time yet.

Humans are beginning to come of age and to share, consciously, in the creation of their part of the universe. There is no need for the church to pretend any longer that daddy is in charge. But there is a need for the church to give us all the chance to grow and become responsible human beings.

SOF Magazine 7, Autumn 1991 11 Finally, there is the good news that there is a spiritual dimension to humans (which is, possibly, unique among our fellow mammals). And while this spiritual dimension is, of course, expressed in art, music and poetry it is, should be, most clearly expressed by religious practices.

Let each child draw around his own hand, then write inside the outline the three things he likes best about himself, then talk to a friend about why these things matter, why her three things matter, and the different shapes of their hands - and you are beginning the religious practices of self-awareness and response to the uniqueness of others. Get a group of teenagers to act out a row, then bring them to a minute of silent thinking about the situations they set up, and finally ask them to try the situations again, noting what change the minute of silent thinking brought - and you are beginning the human religious journey into the uses of meditation to look at life tranquilly and thoughtfully.

These are truly religious exercises, but they are using language and actions of today, not expecting people to learn a special ancient language first before they can experience their religious response to living. The churches must wake up to the new knowledge that the sciences are bringing us, particularly psychology, if they wish to remain forces for good in the coming century.

JOANNA CLARK is a theology graduate, a secondary school teacher of R.E., a Reader in the Church of England and lives on the border of London with Kent.