Children in the Way

SOF Magazine 7, Autumn 1991 7 CHILDREN IN THE WAY Penny Mawdsley A few years ago many churches obtained a challenging video, Children_in_ttle_Way, which demonstrated that Christian communities often marginalise children.

Dismissed as 'the Church of Tomorrow' they are suffered reluctantly as an awkward and potentially disruptive element in 'the Church of Today'. Children in the Way emphasised that children are of vital importance to 'the Church of Today' and they should be appropriately catered for in all areas of church life.

Since then we have had the MARC Europe census figures and have learned that of the 1000 people per week who have left British churches in the last decade 300 have been teenagers and 400, children.

Apart from an article by David Garratt, A Radical's approach to the Religious Education of Primaty SchooLChildren (SOF Mag 1, Spring 1990), which deals specifically with the school situation post the '88 Act, there appears to be nothing in SOF literature addressing the problems for the Radical Christian adult in his or her dialogue with children outside the school setting. As parents and grandparents, for example, we want to supply 'honest answers' to children's often profound questions.

The questions which I am prompted to raise for the SOF network are from the point of view of the regular Sunday School Teacher. Many radical churchgoers, I guess, have managed to steer clear of a Sunday School teaching commitment. I am not so lucky. In a weak moment I accepted the challenge to join our Sunday School rota.

In the liberal Anglo-Catholic church which I attend leaders prepared to make a regular commitment to the young people of our congregation are thin on the ground. An otherwise diverse group of women have some characteristics in common : they are energetic, well-meaning motherly types with evangelistic leanings. I am the only trained teacher among them. I suspect that our situation is not an uncommon one.

We all share a common belief that there is a need, in our particular situation, to withdraw the children from most of a long and, for them, boring and largely meaningless service. Our vicar stoutly defends the centrality of an ASB Rite 'A' Parish Eucharist which, despite continued tactful encouragement to be more adventurous, he persists in conducting in an unvaried and unimaginative style. We are concerned to provide the children in our care (for such a short time on the Sundays when they actually turn up - irregular attendance is a continuing problem) with some Bible knowledge and some Christian teaching of a basic and traditional type.

In some recent 'market research' we undertook amongst our congregation we discovered that parents have definite expectations of Sunday School. These include not merely the ethical - teaching them 'right' from 'wrong' - but also a desire that we should be plugging those informational gaps in their children's religious knowledge left when school R.E. ceased to be confessional or even neo-confessional (as in the 60s when, although now child-centred, R.E. was still firmly set in a Christian context) and it became an educational rather than a religious field of activity.

At time when parents are being encouraged by the Government to see their children as educational 'consumers' and teachers are having to view themselves as more directly accountable to parents, Sunday Schools are under increasing pressure not merely to keep the children suitably occupied in a Christian context while their elders are at prayer - or even to implement a programme specifically designed to promote children's knowledge of the Scriptures - but consciously to foster potential committed adult Christians who will one day confidently confess a traditional faith. What was once considered the task of the school Scripture teacher has now become the task of the local Faith Community, and most particularly of those concerned directly with the spiritual nurture of young people within it. This is especially so in the Decade of Evangelism.

Not only is there pressure on Sunday School teachers to 'produce the goods' from within the Church, but now the Government has added the weight of its voice to the argument. No longer should we accept that recent anti-social behaviour by young people is a result of 45 years of the 'Nanny State'.

Such behaviour is now to be seen as Sin, and the Churches must act as scapegoat. They have been ineffective in halting the apparent spread of such behaviour.

Since their inception, at the end of the 18th Century, Sunday Schools have changed their brief many times.

Robert Raikes (1735-1811) was concerned about illiterate children roaming the streets of Gloucester on a Sunday. Children should be taught to read so that they would keep out of mischief and would become acquainted with the Scriptures and thereby claim the grace of Salvation. Sunday Schools have not only been religiously motivated. They were, from the outset, politically motivated : pious Christian children, it was hoped, would become law-abiding, submissive and conforming adults who would not question the status quo. Revolution could be avoided.

Margaret Powell describes in her entertaining book 8 SOF Magazine 7, Autumn 1991 Life Below Stairs how Sunday Schools were viewed by the working classes at the turn of this century.

Children were packed off to Sunday School so that parents could enjoy some much-needed privacy and 'quality time' together.

Sunday Schools have moved forward. Over the last two decades much material has been produced which is up-to-date and attractively packaged. All sorts of inspired activities have been devised to attract children, especially those of primary age, but, for the Radical teacher at least, the use of it begs many questions.

Is it still appropriate to accept that primary school children can only perform, in Piaget's terminology, "concrete operations", where everything must relate to their own solid experience ? Must we accept that young children are only capable of an uncritical faith ?

The American child psychologist Jerome Bruner believed that "any subject can be taught effectively in some intellectually honest form to any child at any stage of development ... It is a matter of hie/iv a courteous trans/a/AO'.

Professor Russell Stannard, author of The TiMe_and Space of Uncle Albert and Blackiioles and_Uncle Albert (both Faber pbks., £2.50 each), has shown that Einstein's Theory of Relativity can be presented to sub-teenage children in an attractive and understandable way. If we as Radical members of the Faith Community maintain that there are absorbing theological matters which are potentially worthwhile, useful and interesting to young people before we have lost the same to the claims of the secular and materialist world outside, perhaps we should consider finding a "courteous translation" for our concerns and presenting them to children in such an attractive and challenging way that we gain (and hopefully retain) their interest in and contact with the Church from an intellectual standpoint.

For many children probably even the most attractively packaged critical religious knowledge programme would be too cerebral and we would lose such children's allegiance. However, the repeated churning out of 'safe' Bible stories and the singing of banal choruses, albeit with catchy tunes, do not appear to retain children's interest for long either. Are we to sit back and wait for our ex-pupils to be taken up during their vulnerable teens or early adulthood by the thrusting and confident fundamentalist charismatic evangelical arm of the Church, and thereafter be discouraged from applying critical thought to the religious dimension of their lives ?

PENNY MAWDSLEY is a housewife and ex-teacher, currently pursuing an M.Ed. at Liverpool.