In Praise of Loving Kindness

Michael Lewis is Anglican Bishop of Middleton JENI PARSONS finds in Karen Armstrong's new book a challenge to those who cannot bear too much reality - as well as to "the fundamentalisms of nonrealism" in praise of loving-kindness Buddha by Karen Armstrong (Weidenfeld and Nicolson) Another book on the Buddha, Siddhatta Gotama, may seem superfluous especially when one realises how little factual information can be gathered about him, but Karen Armstrong writes so elegantly that it is a pleasure to read her prose on this shadowy but hugely significant figure of history.

She begins with a consideration of the cultural, social and technological changes that were occurring at the time he lived in the fifth or sixth century BCE and how religious feeling and thinking was intertwined with the change. She does not restrict herself to a dry commentary on the evidence, or its paucity, but brings her human experience into juxtaposition with both facts and theories of what is termed Buddhism. Perhaps at times she strays well beyond the evidence, but this is a book of the heart and it will refresh the heart that ponders the human questions of meaning and divinity, humanity and a changing society.

The Buddha of Armstrong's description encourages anyone who follows the teaching to pay attention to their own experience and to follow that rather than the experience of another. A disciple must test everything and especially the teaching of their Master. It is this empiricism that is so attractive to many Western people who look for a spirituality that accords with their own experience and who eschew a supernaturalism that seems so alien.

Yet as Armstrong says, "the Buddha is also a challenge, because he is more radical than most of us".

For the Buddha focuses on pain and suffering as the common experience of humanity, and uses this fundamental recognition as the beginning of wisdom.

Such knowledge leads to a renunciation of self, both in his teaching and his life, and Armstrong rightly questions whether Westerners can really live with so much reality and so much self-abandonment.

The search for a spirituality that offers enlightenment is in itself a paradox and Armstrong brings this in each of her chapters for she is not afraid to point to both the attractive elements for Westerners of the Bud way and those that will be harder tc accommodate. She draws helpful parallels with Christian teaching to illuminate what would otherwise b« hard to grasp and thereby she point the radical nature of the religious se in both traditions.

If some readers of this book are | search out the Buddhist teaching at greater depth for themselves then o will return to Christian scripture wi new insight into a perhaps more familiar tradition. * can only be beneficial and is a mark of Armstrong's achievement in writing this book, for she has taken a tradition and enabled us to find in it a mirror in whi: see some human truths from which we may otherwi: prefer to insulate ourselves.

Yet perhaps the most radical challenge to Western nonrealists will be the Buddha's focus on method thi leads to enlightenment rather than any theory. It see to me that there is abroad the notion amongst nonrei that it is a doctrine of "not-believing" that is the core wisdom rather than any political action that embrace others. Yet the Buddha offered a simple combinatior morality, meditation and wisdom that brought an en "the craving, hatred and ignorance that hold humani thrall”.