Church Times £16.99. Order on-line at 20% discount from www.canongate.net 22 fare wel by DAVID BOULTON I found it oddly difficult to type the two words above. I have been editing this magazine for the best part of a decade, and it's going to be a wrench to let it go. But all good things come to an end, and for the good of what I fondly but metaphorically call my soul, and for the good of the Network, I must now pass the baton on to someone else.
The next issue, No. 51, January 2002, will be my last.
I've been looking at No. 11, October 1992 - my first. In my editorial I wrote that only six months earlier I had never heard of the Network, though I had been hugely influenced by Don Cupitt's books and TV series. I had joined after seeing an ad in The Friend, and had offered to help with the magazine when its founding editor, Clive Richards, announced his retirement. Clive had replied by return to say the steering committee - none of whom I had ever met, or knew me - had appointed me editor and would I please get on with it.
I have become convinced that today's Network needs a style of editorship to which lam not best suited In that first editorial I admitted that I wondered what the hell I'd joined. I feared the worst: "a network of neurotic Doubters Anonymous, a depository of hand-wringing exbelievers and whinging vicars who had lost their faith but were damned if they were also going to lose their stipends".
But what I had found was "an intellectually lively and emotionally engaged bunch of contributors exploring modern ideas in an undogmatic and anti-dogmatic fashion... Some proclaimed that God was dead, History was dead and they weren't feeling too well themselves. But... in accents recognisably Quaker, Anglican, Unitarian, Humanist, they joyfully and creatively articulated their own core values and sense of purpose".
I was writing for 370 readers - a membership which had just doubled in the previous three months. Over the coming years the Network would continue to grow to its current 750-odd plus 400 non-member magazine subscribers, giving birth on the way to sister networks in New Zealand and Australia and associated organisations in Canada and the USA.
Yet many of our preoccupations have remained the same.
I concluded that first editorial by asking, "What, if anything, should SoF be doing, as distinct from saying? What can we affirm? How can we promote our ideas?" I guess I've never stopped banging on about these very things - though more recently I've dared to offer some answers, irritating a few of you in the process!
Other articles in my first issue agonised about the reality or non-reality of God, the value or otherwise of Godlanguage, and the distinction between atheism and Cupitt's nonrealism. Letters complained about there being too many church-goers and not enough humanists in the Network, experimental rituals, "a sense of anti-rationalism", too much theological jargon, and a call for the Network to "move forward". Cupitt himself described the Network as "radical Christians, post-Christians, religious humanists and seekers [who] may be seen as harbingers of the long-awaited New Reformation" - but he urged that, after three years existence, it was time for the Network to "deliver". Yes folks, that was nearly ten years ago!
There are a number of reasons why I have told the 2001 steering committee that I want to stand down. For a start, nearly ten years is enough, for me and for readers alike! I have poured a great deal of energy and enthusiasm into the magazine, and perhaps it's time that some of it was redirected. I have my first grandchild to play with. I continue to be involved in broadcasting regulation, now in the throes of government reorganisation. And I have promises to keep, in the shape of books to be written. I need more time than the magazine allows me.
There is another reason, too, which is not so easy to write about. I can best sum it up by saying I have become convinced that today's Network needs a style of editorship to which I am not best suited.
As the Network has grown in numbers, so it has also become more diverse in outlook. As my back-references to magazine No.11 show, residual theism and non-theism, realism and nonrealism, churchgoing and taking leave of the church, have always rubbed shoulders in this funny old fellowship of ours. But it has become increasingly clear that the price of this friendly coexistence has been a stagnation in our much-vaunted aim of exploring religious faith as a human creation. We draw back from robust exploration because we do not want to hurt or offend each other. So our understandable reluctance to be divisive, to stir controversy, to create factions or provoke splits, silences us. It gives those who do not wish to explore, a veto over the explorations of those who do.
No less serious, it also renders stillborn our aim of promoting any coherent SoF view. We cannot promote nonrealism without being criticised by our own critical realists, cannot advocate "religious humanism" without accusations of factionalism. We cannot say the gods are human creations and projections without falling foul of those among us who cling to a sliver of metaphysical transcendence. We cannot offend the churches without a chiding from our members who have formed their own autonomous "Sea of Faith in the Churches" network. We realists, cannot advocate "religious humanism" without accusations of factionalism. We cannot say the gods are human creations and projections without falling foul of those among us who cling to a sliver of metaphysical transcendence.
We cannot offend the churches without a chiding from our members who have formed their own autonomous "Sea of Faith in the Churches" network. We cannot even assume that Network members start from a wholly naturalistic position: supernaturalism, in its newer guises of "Otherness", "the numinous", "the paranormal", or a colourful variety of new age spiritualities, rises up to cloud the clarity of the modern, rational approach - the "reasonable faith" which I believe Cupitt and the Network's founders hoped to promote, and which remains my ideal.
The result is that we are in danger of rendering ourselves impotent. One of the side-duties of the SOF editor is to act as Network spokesperson to the media. It's a thankless task. What do we have to say worth saying on current controversies? Church schools: for or against? We don't know. Everyone else has a view, particularly in relation to the sad, sick picture of sectarian education we got during the summer from the Ardoyne Road, Belfast, in every morning paper and every evening news bulletin:
What about Blair's declared interest in learning from mon, women and men committed to promoting a naturalistic view of religion and exploring the implications of such a view, but an open forum for exploring religious questions in general and promoting nothing in particular.
But we cannot be both. We cannot be what our constitution says we are - a network of people in sympathy with the specific aims of exploring and promoting religious faith as a human creation - and a chatroom for religious seekers of all persuasions or none.
So if I am right in deducing that a significant number of members and readers don't really feel comfortable with a Network and a magazine which at least aspires to a coherent sense of what it wants to say and how it wants to say it, and who don't identify with the clearly-expressed view that religion is wholly human, its gods wholly (but gloriously) imaginary, its value wholly utilitarian, and who therefore have no hypothesis to explore and no distinctive view to promote, then that's one more reason for a change of editorship. I have worked hard to ensure that all positions within the Network are reflected in the magazine's pages - Christian, humanist, Buddhist, Pagan, nonrealist, critical-realist, theist, atheist - but my editorial voice has become identified with a specific viewpoint: that of the theological nonrealist, the religious humanist. This, however, is now only one viewpoint among many in the Network, and it is better that a new editor, less identified with one We are in danger of rendering ourselves _ interpretation of our mission statement impotent...What do we have to say worth saying on current controversies? than I am, should take over and perhaps reposition the magazine accordingly.
But note: I write "fare well", not SA LS AS SEEN: ASE ES a ARTE "farewell"! I expect to continue as an Bush's strategy of diminishing state welfare provision and pushing more of it on to the "faith communities"? What about religious representation in the House of Lords?
What about the host of macro-ethical issues which everyone seems to have a view on - except SoF? The National Secular Society is in there, as is the Rationalist Press Association and the British Humanist Association and the various religious institutions... but we can say nothing, because we, who have been exploring and promoting religious faith as a human creation for twelve years, still have nothing coherent that we can say together.
Ah, [hear some of you say, that's because we are a network, not a campaign or lobby; a collection of autonomous individuals, not a society. We are an open forum for discussion and mutual support. We have no collective axe to grind. Our explorations are not supposed to lead us to common conclusions or "closure", as the academics call it. We must not ask "What can we say?” but "What can I say?". As for promotion, what we promote is... er... the exploration.
Yes, I understand that that is how many of us in the Network have come to see ourselves. Not as a body of active and dedicated member of the Sea of Faith Network, submitting occasional articles to the new editor for his/her acceptance or rejection, and arguing as best I can for a post-Christian religious humanism which is passionate and active in the creation of the New Jerusalem, the republic of heaven. I want to share with my friends in the churches and Quaker meetings the liberating discovery that an understanding of religious faith as wholly human and naturalistic immeasurably enhances, not weakens, our best efforts at curbing the weakness and raising what little good there may be in us.
And I want to share with my fellow humanists the conviction that the poetry of religious culture at its brightest and best is among humanity's great glories rather than one long mistake. And you'll understand that I want to be free to speak with my own voice, not the common denominator of many voices of the Network.
So I'll still be around. Do fare well!
Sorry both BEACHCOMBER and SEAFARER have been elbowed aside in this issue. They'll be back (with their swansongs) in January. Meanwhile the editorial team wish all readers as peaceful a Christmas and new year as we have the strength to work for.