Rebuilding the Ruins

Leslie Griffiths is a former President of the Methodist Conference by MICHAEL LEWIS If you like sermons, you'll love this. I mean that as serious praise. If on a day-glo poster outside a church you see advertised a series of talks or sermons on The Liberating Dramas of Scripture, Original Sin, Hell, Justification, Resurrection, Use and Abuse of the Bible, and The Church, you'll want to check the preacher's name carefully before walking in. Sermons often bore and platitudinize. Sometimes they exploit and tyrannize. But ah! the beauty and the converting power of a sermon that expounds, explores, proclaims without bullying, reminds, compares, expands, occasionally teases, more than once in a while perplexes or disconcerts, and in the end moves deeply.

Bishop Richard Holloway has writen a book whose central section, Rebuilding the Ruins, is effectively a series of such sermons. And sermons they are, with asides like "I saw a little piece in the papers the other day". What they are not is the “He believes in Jesus.

Does he believe in God?” vacuous, trendy outpourings of Peter Simple's Dr SpacelyTrellis, though there is enough here to cause him, or Richard Ingrams, apoplexy. If every now and then Holloway's facility with language and allusion tempts him to cleverness (in an aside on notions of samsara and karma he speculates on a dung-beetle whose previous lower existence was as Governor of Texas), this book and its chapters are rooted in the dynamic of the living tradition of Christianity and in encounter with what he takes to be the radical core of the life, words, and actions of Jesus of Nazareth.

Again and again he engages with scripture, which he quotes at length, inviting his readers to savour it and be confronted by it. Passion and compassion drive him, as he believes they drove Jesus. In the final section, What is Left of Christianity, he tries "to reclaim three revolutionary elements from what is left of the Spirit of Jesus": the subversion of power; pity, transformation, and hope; and forgiveness. Out of these may emerge "a usable ethic for our own time’.

The writing, the preaching here is eloquent and heartfelt.

An ethic - and a theology. Instead of the "routinization of charisma" (Weber) to which he believes the institution called the ruins Church and its "officials" inevitably cleave, there may and must be a theology not of death, mortality, ransom, and endemic anxiety but of world-loving life. Its keynotes will be attention, repentance, and remaking.

There is anger in Doubts and Loves, anger at the Church.

The bishop hated the tone of the plenary debate at the 1998 Lambeth Conference on aspects of human sexuality, not because he ephemerally supported a politically correct cause but on the grounds that that tone and many assertions made simply did not square with the Jesus whom he so passionately seeks and strives to follow; that subverting, pitying, transforming, hope-giving, and forgiving Jesus.

Holloway is angry, too, about what Christians still affirm, deny, and ignore about women. But as well as anger he notes an uncomfortable paradox (or is it contradiction?) about the Church, set out by Fr. Raymond Brown, the Johannizie scholar.

It is that, especially in the Fourth Gospel, "the world" is inherently resistant to the approach of God, and yet "we have only heard of Jesus through an institution that has not experienced worldlessness for a very long time".

He believes in Jesus. Does he believe in God? "I find the needle on my own dial," he says, "trembles mid-way between non-realism (God is a human invention) and critical realism (there is a mystery out there, but we are inextricably involved in its interpretation, and never get it with complete purity)".

In a Guardian interview he says that he is not an atheist but that "T think that we may have yet to discover the true God".

All these assertions will disappoint or scandalize some one way, some the other. In the same interview he identifies himself as "a weirdly anomalous public intellectual on the edges of Christianity and lots of other things". He may be selling himself short. The Jesus he follows and the sometimes revealed, sometimes hidden God he yearns to know seem to me not far removed from the core of faith transmitted to those with ears to hear and hearts to feel, even today, even through the grossly imperfect medium of the Church.

These are tough, driven, provocative sermons or talks of high quality. You can't get everything there is to be said about anything into one sermon, nor should you try. I cheer much of it, dissent from some of it, am intrigued by all of it, and rather think I'll remember the message as well as the illustrations.