The nadir point for me came when it carried a feature article by Richard Dawkins who suggested, in the immediate aftermath of the World Trade Centre atrocities, “a liberal and humane apologetic for the bewildering times we're living in” that young men imbued with religion (especially a belief in an afterlife) were pre-programmed to become human guided missiles ready to take part in suicide attacks.
Preposterous but not untypical either of the fundamentalism of the author of the piece or of this great newspaper's stance to questions of faith.
All the more surprising, therefore, to find a couple of religious leaders being given the full monty over the last few months, each getting a full two-page spread in the Saturday Review. What's more, the tone and temper of both of these long profiles was uncritical in the extreme; so much so that you'd be forgiven for believing that the subjects of this treatment were unblemished heroes, the very model of two modern ecclesiasticals. And who were they? Richard Chartres, the suave Bishop of London and obviously the Guardian's man to succeed George Carey at Canterbury, was one; and Richard Holloway, ex-Primus of the Episcopalian Church of Scotland, the other. Two such different Richards. I'm sure each of them will have been surprised (will they have been pleased?) to be given such lavish treatment alongside the other.
Holloway's new book represents his latest effort to establish a liberal and humane apologetic for the bewildering times we're living in. Rather than face people with the stark requirement either to accept Christianity or reject it, he wonders whether there isn't "a third way," an approach that avoids the Scylla of "diluted fundamentalism" and the Charybdis of "watered-down scepticism". He turns to Thomas Kuhn's Structures of Scientific Revolutions for his methodology. We're living in a time of crisis, he argues, when one paradigm is being anifesto for modern replaced by another. Hans Kung has argued this at greate length and with more conviction in several of his later books but Holloway seems to snap up this and other illconsidered trifles with the voracity of a contemporary Autolycus as he spells out his oh-soreasonable apologia.
His own dial, he tells us, referring to his thoughts about the status of God, "trembles midway between non-realism (God is a human invention) and critical realism (there is a mystery out there, but we are inextricably involved in its interpretation and never get it with complete purity)". This is a very fine point indeed and I didn't find it altogether helpful, it was too subtle by far, to help me in my struggle with th: great questions of faith. He establishes this finely tuned position as if it could be solely the result of thinking through the relationship between "the world's independent existence" and his own perception of it. He offers no hint of a third, a social, dimension to this conundrum. My own efforts to make sense of what is beyond me, for example, have often been greatly aided by my conversation with others involved in the same search. Their perception often enriches mine, at times it checks some of the runaway tendencies of my thinking or adds significantly to its capital.
As always, Holloway has lots of bons mots. He adapt a phrase by Emily Dickenson to remind us how "the (im)possibility of God nibbles at the soul" in order to make the point that there's no cheap dismissal of the question of God. And he quotes Lionel Blue to point up the frightening reminder that things we invent can only too easily become our masters. "In Judaism," he tells us (quoting the good rabbi), "this takes the form of obsessive compulsive neurosis; in Christianity it becomes sado-masochism; and in Islam, it is megalomania". Now that's worth thinking hard about n'est-ce pas? The capacity of religion to turn its adepts mad!
Again and again, Holloway suggests that it's orthopraxis rather than orthodoxy [sic] that really counts. Dogma's out. It's not things we believe about Jesus but our imitation of him that really matters. I've no problem with that as a general approach to the Christian life but does this mean a dumbed down theology? Is that why he can give a definition of the resurrection far more relativised than anything David Jenkins got into hot water for: "The people who had deserted Jesus in fear and fled from his dying, somewhere found the courage to proclaim the meaning of his life, and that transformation, that turnaround, is what we mean by resurrection." That doesn't leave us even a bone or two to do some conjuring tricks with.
It's the last section which rescues this book, four chapters (70 pages) which attempt to construct a Christian manifesto for modern believers. We are to honour the outsider; we are to be a community of hope; we will deal with our past and love will conquer the world. It's here that Holloway's pellucid prose takes wings and he enables us to meet a Jesus whose compassion and anger demand obedience and discipleship. My spirit soared as I sped through these last chapters. And for that I'm immensely grateful.