16 – January 1994

Contents

Articles
Reviews
Front cover of Sofia issue 16 – January 1994
Back cover of Sofia issue 16

Editorial

WHAT'S OUR LINE?

It's a question we are asked increasingly often as our increased visibility (or notoriety) brings us to the attention of more and more people. "What is SoF's line?" on anything from women priests, disestablishment, hell and damnation, to Government policy on religious education, single mothers, family values, the free market, and the fitness of the Prince of Wales to be King Charles III. And "Where does SoF stand?" on abortion, euthanasia, gay sex, animal rights, ethical investment, green consumerism, Thorpe, saving whales, intervention in Bosnia, intervention in Somalia, pacifism, private enterprise, public enterprise, the primacy of the individual, the primacy of society, and the existence of Father Christmas.

Is SoF for the churches or against them, for Christianity or against it, for ecclesiastical reform or for turning the churches upside down? For mending them or learning to do without them? Do we bear an olive-branch or a sword? Are we for platitudes or plain speaking, comforting or discomforting, mollifying or challenging?

Are we intent on building Jerusalem, or on self-fulfilment? Are we in politics or are we not? What's our line, and where do we stand, on David Jenkins, Roy Jenkins, Don Cupitt, Don Duck?

I can't swear I've been asked every one of these questions since the Freeman saga made us, however briefly, objects of curiosity, but there's not many I've invented. And I fear many an honest enquirer has been baffled by the same answer given to each question: the Sea of Faith Network has no line beyond its statement of intent, which is "to explore and promote religious faith as a human creation".

Beyond that, all is almost infinite diversity. We are churchpeople and nonchurchpeople, supporters of women priests and opponents of all priests, Anglican mystics and Quaker atheists, religious humanists, secular humanists, post-humanists. We are Christians and we are "Heathen, Turk and Jew". We are, if not a broad church, a broad network.

And we are people who have given up the idea that we need to seek agreement on every contentious issue, since we understand that there is no one truth to be arrived at. We are not seekers after Truth. What's the point, if there is no Truth to find. We are certainly seekers after a greater understanding of ourselves, our neighbours and the world we live in, but that's different.

We do not try to hammer out an SoF "policy" on this, that or anything. We discuss, and we agree sometimes, disagree sometimes. We learn from each other and constantly adjust our own sights as we learn. In solidarity we shall support those of our fellow-members who come under attack for voicing their views, but that doesn't mean their views are Network policy.

There would be no point in exploring the implications of accepting religious faith as a human creation if we were all agreed on what those implications were: implications moral, political, practical, philosophical. We explore together precisely because we recognise how much we have to learn in our diversity.

And there would be no point in promoting creative, human-centred religion, and affirming religious language and symbolism as expressions of our human values and human spirit, if our feet were all in the same starting-block and our minds in the same mould.

We have no corporate policy, no creed beyond our common understanding that religion, like art and science, is made by human communities. We think that's a useful insight in a world which clings to dangerous tribal gods. It's an insight shared by humanists and anti-realist theologians, in churches, meeting-houses and the back rooms in pubs where the builders of secular Jerusalems gather. But a line? We leave that to pontiffs and pontificators. - DAVID BOULTON 'THIS IS MY STORY!' Everyone has a story to tell, a thought to share, a disagreement to voice, a question to ask, an idea to float, a kite to fly, an insight to share, a proposal to make - something to say. So why not tell it, share it, voice it, ask it, float it, fly it, share it, make it, say it, here?

You can do so in an article or a letter. It will help if you can type your contribution, but if you can't, please write clearly on one side of the paper only.

You'll find yourself sharing the next issue with Kulananda on "Truth in Buddhism", Mark Rivett on "Radical Christianity: Radical Therapy", John MacDonald Smith on "Interfaith Discussion", more on David Hart's Faith in Doubt - plus something on SoF and Michael Tippett's Third Symphony. Heretical we may be, but we are nothing if not catholic!

See page 2 opposite for details of how to contribute.

Surely these two addresses were an essential part of the conference, and even if there was some disappointment (which I share) about one or both of them in not really engaging with Sea of Faith concerns, to give them such short shrift, for whatever reason, does seem a little biased. I feel it gives a limited and one-sided impression of the conference (especially for those members who weren't present) and also restricts the magazine report's usefulness in any discussion on the conference in local SoF groups or elsewhere. - Priscilla Morton, 34 Streatley Road, London NW6 7LS. [All four main speakers were invited to submit texts or summaries of their talks. Don Cupitt and Kulananda did so, Hugh Dawes and Karen Armstrong did not. (Hugh was heavily involved in the Freeman affair). Karen's talk was a summary of her "History of God" which we had in any case reviewed and summarised at length in our previous issue. We hope this explanation acquits us of deliberate bias or discourtesy. The importance of the Dawes and Armstrong talks was recognised in our reports under the general title "Workshops and Talkshops" when we stated specifically that they were plenary sessions. - EDITOR] Drop-out Unluckily, a line or two dropped out of the first paragraph of my piece in Sea of Faith 15, leaving readers confused. The gist of it all was of course that because we lack any overall vision of the human condition we are "sad hearts in the supermarket", overwhelmed by the abundance of modern culture.

— Priscilla Morton, London

For all his brave words about the end of realism and the end of ecclesiastical Christianity, does one detect that Don Cupitt's heart is not totally happy with the situation when he writes, "Whose is this god-like intelligence that roams across the billions of light-years?" Despite his search for a "natural theology and a natural religion", the supernatural seems to intrude. He announces the end of the old metaphysics and hopes that a new world of "unifying metaphors" will somehow take its place, and not only that, he hopes that people will drop their faiths and their hopes from those faiths, and go to that "unified field on which the religious life can be lived". Yet still his heart hangs on to the "who" as do the hearts of millions of Catholics in South America or Muslims in the East, who would pay little attention to any "new sort of natural religion".

We have therefore a sort of nostalgic yearning for an object of faith in the new scientific world, around which would presumably be gathered another Church, with a "minimal creed", which would go out and evangelise the world to be followed by the establishment of the Kingdom. We would do all this through language, or to quote, "We are world and the world is all ours. We made it, for we finish it as we appropriate it through language". One can imagine dinosaurs having this world-view, so physically powerful must they have seemed to themselves. The Minoans might have taken a similar view of their permanence before being obliterated.

Perhaps the beginning of the religious life is the quality of humility, and these words are hardly humble. Any view of the Universe must be from a point of awe, and there seems no awe here. With the probability of geological and climatic change, our tenure on this planet on a long-term basis is very questionable. We are hardly likely to be the ultimate in evolution. The statement that we have somehow created what we have seems arrogant in the extreme.

It is very hard also to take Don Cupitt's words in his penultimate paragraph: "that has led us to develop around ourselves such a prodigiously rich and beautiful world as we now have". The great "We" is dominant again, blind to the terrible destruction of natural life everywhere, caused by human activities.

It is ironic that the propounder of a "natural theology and a natural religion" should apparently be so unaware of the situation in the natural world.

I would suggest that instead of seeking a new religion, other than for our own private motivation, we go on trying to get people of different faiths to get on with each other. It is no use saying that "old-style realistic systematic theology... is no longer attempted by anyone". This may be so but millions believe in it.

It is fun for us to ponder how we can combine religious insights with ethics and science and care for the world, and privately translate "God" in our own ways, but God is a very precise reality for millions, precise enough to die for. - WJ Milne, Woodbine, Brackenfield, Derby DE55 6AR.

— W.J. Milne, Derby

SoF and the SoFF Don Cupitt, in his article entitled "After the Church", seemed to reflect a general morosity shared by others writing in Sea of Faith 15. "Minimalism" and "the ending of the Church" sound like the best wares on offer. I suggest that there are ways of looking far more positively at that which the Network can offer.

I left organised religion some twenty years ago, and wandered as a concerned atheist, drawing much of my moral framework from socialist and humanist sources. I came across Cupitt first from television, later from reading most of his books. For me, coming at it as I did from the atheist side of the arena, the message was a mere straw of faith, a last thing to hang on to as I abandoned the creed. Instead it was a way back to a church and belief, a revolutionary expansion of my ontology to include the previously forbidden God-word. Here was an exciting addition to a moral shield, not a minimalist paring down from a threadbare creed.

I missed the Sea of Faith conference in 1993. Why? Because some mischance had programmed it at the same time as the Yearly Meeting of the Quakers. For yes, I have become a member of the Society of Friends. Here is an environment where the idea of a God made by humans is not strange, and it is one where it is both a linguistic construction and one to be made by our acts in our daily lives. Ordinary life is the arena where the metaphors are tested, where there is not just God to realise, but demons to combat, Heavens to strive for and Hells and Purgatories to evade.

I therefore feel joyful that there are frameworks for human-founded theism to compete with the wars and the games arcades of materialism. We need God as an ally, if only a linguistic one, and Cupitt has helped us to find it. So please, less pessimism about the bickering with the old Church, and more optimism that the first post-modern grounds for using the God metaphor have been established, for all to stand on. - Jeremy Lester, 70 Rue Philippe le Bon, 1040 Brussels, Belgium.

— Jeremy Lester, Brussels

No lack of new thinking Surely Clive Richards understates when he says SoF is lacking in innovative and substantive thinking (Sea of Faith 14)? Given the books of Cupitt, Geering, Dawes, Freeman and Hart, and the outcome of six Conferences, and the content of 15 magazines - not to mention the living inheritance of Honest to God and other renewal movements of the past - I discern plentiful new thinking. I feel Adam Thomson is right when he says "it is now time to deliver" (Sea of Faith 15).

Adam offers some suggestions for action. May I offer two more? First, I think we should admit to ourselves that a Cambridge (or Loughborough, or Leicester?) Movement has actually started in the Anglican Church - a contrasting counterpart to the Oxford Movement which Newman dated from Keble's Assize Sermon of 1833 on "National Apostasy". And no, Adam, this is not English parochialism, it is happening in New Zealand and all over. It is happening, so a practical choice for us is whether we watch it passively or foment it actively. I suggest the latter.

Secondly, since SoF's themes apply to all faiths, we should take part in, for example, debate in Islam (as Michael Stewart urges us in Sea of Faith 14). Salman Rushdie, in The Satanic Verses, does an SoF job, skilfully portraying Islam, in its origins on Mount Hira and in Mecca, as a human creation. Could he, or someone likeminded, develop this theme at a Conference?

I used the word "offer" above. I shan't be at all upset if the answer is No. - John Challenor, 8 Fairwood Road, Cardiff CF5 3QJ.

— John Challenor, Cardiff

Evolutionary faith I wonder whether other members are totally satisfied with the description "exploring and promoting religious faith as a human creation"? Would "exploring faith as evolving religious expression" be more suitable for a network concerned with spiritual emancipation? - Elizabeth Reid, Grace Cottage, Abbotsford Road, North Berwick, East Lothian EH39 5DB.

— Elizabeth Reid, North Berwick

Extrasensory link?

The 1993 SoF Conference, a new and stimulating experience for me, led me to wonder how many SoF members believe in prayer. It seems to me that religious faith requires this and that if such a belief is justifiable, then surely we must possess some kind of latent telepathic faculty.

The hypothesis that I would like to suggest is that there is an extrasensory link, of which we are normally quite unaware, whereby human beings and perhaps animals are in communication with, and possess the means of influencing, one another at a subconscious level, irrespective of distance. Although science has not, so far, detected the actual means of such communication, there is a credible case for suggesting its possible existence. As I have already said, if prayer really "works", reason demands that something of the sort must obtain. Apart from the act of prayer in which so many religious communities believe and participate, there are other so-far unexplained occurrences, such as animal instinct, faith healing, radionics, hypnotism and so-called paranormal phenomena which might relate to a subconscious interpersonal relationship of this kind.

Furthermore, if indeed there is such a relationship, then there must exist a worldwide network of communication, largely unperceived and unused, but potentially of great power. If we talk of "god within", it is not difficult to conceive of the word "god" being redefined as the sum total of the spiritual force for good within mankind, linked by this vast network.

For an engineer like myself, trained in the sciences and searching for a faith that I can accept as rational and intelligible, the foregoing concepts (which involve a spiritual force for evil as well as for good, let it be said) provide an acceptable foundation - Hugh Tracy, Orchard House, Claverton, Bath BA2 7BG.

— Hugh Tracy, Bath

To join or not to join Being totally confused over my potential relationship with SoF and having made numerous contradicting decisions over whether to renew my membership, one possible solution arose: to present my beliefs to the magazine and see what response may arise.

I fully agree that all religions are the creation of (wo)man's mind, that we make the images, the traditions, the rules etc. to suit our own culture or needs, or even to suit those who may be in power at the time. Also the traditional presentation of God from a Christian point of view is wholly incompatible with the modern world. So what is the problem? Why is this crazy person confused about SoF?

Well, despite all the above, I still know that Jesus was fully the Son of God, that Krishna was the divine incarnation and that His mother did indeed see the universe inside His mouth, that Buddha really did obtain unity with the Universal Spirit (Atma) under the banyan tree. I believe that although the creeds and regulations of religion are of man's creation (and are therefore flawed) there was a divine spark at the beginning of each one. This spark is beyond man's understanding and description but is actually the true essence of nature, ie natural, and as such not really supernatural.

Is it too much of a co-incidence that the Hindu myth of the Adi Shakti (the will of God, the female aspect, the Holy Ghost) desiring to show Shiva (the male aspect, the Creator, the witness) how perfect and glorious He is by producing a perfect mirror for Him to see Himself in, is so similar to the Jewish Kabbalistic mystical tale of the Almighty withdrawing from a region to create a perfect mirror to see Himself? The mirror is not yet finished and will not be until we can reflect His majesty in ourselves.

So can I believe such things and still remain part of SoF, or would I be too far from the basic theme to co-exist? I hope I can, as there appear to be no other groups with which I can interact. Any response would be most welcome. - Howard Wheeler, 141 Meersbrook Park Road, Sheffield S8 9FP.

— Howard Wheeler, Sheffield

New ideas in liturgy I write to ask if any of your members have been exploring new ideas in liturgy and spirituality. I am not a non-realist, believing that God is outside me as well as within me, but I am involved in teaching RE to teenagers in a new style, the spirituality or experiential approach. This tries to find themes in ordinary life, and in their inner lives, that deal with "the spiritual" whether or not we talk about God. I have used stilling exercises widely and creative work such as role-play, designing mandalas, masks, and dream exploration. I am currently interested in the Body Shop as a modern centre of spirituality - green awareness, animal rights, human rights, new styles of business enterprise, tribal wisdom, etc.

As a priest I am also interested in liturgy and worship. Don Cupitt has spoken about learning from the creative arts and seeing glimpses of the sacred. Where is the imagination and inspiration in seeking to use rituals and modern words to evoke a sense of the spiritual? Even more, can this be done outside the Church for people of no particular belief, without being sloppy, fuzzy "New Age" eccentricity? I would like to hear any ideas or experiments - yet most radicals seem to be very traditional in their worship. - Kevin O'Donnell, Holly Grove, 74 Fernbank Road, North Ascot SL5 8HE.

— Kevin O'Donnell, North Ascot