POST-MODERN MORALITY Iris Murdoch calls it “a profound and _ passionate book, a bridge to continued Spirituality’. Don Cupitt finds it ‘‘fresh and wide-ranging, breaking with received ideas about objectivity, tradition and dogma’’. They are writing about Faith in Doubt, the new book by David Hart, Senior Anglican Chaplain to Loughborough University and a member of the Sea of Faith Network steering committee (Mowbray, £8.99 paperback). We shall be taking a closer look at it in our next issue, but here we reprint the Foreward written for it by the radical Bishop of Newark, USA, JOHN SPONG.
Citing Schleiermacher, Wesley, Bushnell, Barth and Martin Luther King Jr. as examples, the former head of Yale Divinity School in the United States, Dr Leander Keck, has suggested that the renewal of theology in the Christian church will come not from professional theologians but from preachers in the field. That is because it is the preacher who is driven to become a theologian in order to make sense out of his or her daily life and work.
Professional theologians, Keck suggests, will not be the source of renewal since they have the luxury of debating ideas instead of being forced to live those ideas out in a very practical world. Hierarchical religious figures will also not be the source of the church’s renewal, Keck asserts, because they cannot escape their distorting need to protect the institution that empowers them.
In many ways David A Hart, in this book, illustrates this principle. As the Senior Anglican Chaplain at Loughborough University, David lives and works within the confines and world view of that science- and technologyoriented centre. I have been privileged to be his guest for visits on that campus. I have seen in him a man whose humanity attracts students and faculty, administrators and staff into his orbit of influence. They come out of every conceivable religious background and out of no obvious religious background. Yet time and again, in their relationships with David Hart they receive that greatest of gifts, the validation of their humanity and the enhancement of their being. Those gifts are not just the accidental contributions of a great and sensitive man who happens to be an Anglican priest. They are rather the results that emerge when David Hart lives out his theological commitments in his workplace and through his relationships.
In preparation for his life’s work he has grounded his very being in the classical disciplines of his profession.
He has been shaped by the likes of John Macquarrie and Dennis Nineham of the Church of England, as well as by Cornel West and Tom Altizer from the American theological scene. But what these scholars gave him was not a fixed body of ‘‘revealed truth’’ but rather a point of view out of which he would grow, and the rare theological courage to journey beyond the fearful boundaries that many believers erect at the edges of their systems of faith. Like many other disturbers of institutional religious peace, including especially his mentor and friend, Don Cupitt of Emmanuel College, Cambridge, David Hart has walked beyond these faith edges into the churning sea of doubt, uncertainty and insecurity. He has faced honestly the limitations of human language that tend to mark the faith commitments of twentieth-century men and women. Yet he walks with the integrity of being both an honest believer and a critical, even doubting, thinker. Above all, he walks as a dedicated Christian. In the words of the Psalmist this man is secking a way ‘“‘to sing the Lord’s song in a strange land’’.
In this magnificent small book, David Hart shares his inward journey in a public way. Under the guise of examining various theological claims of yesterday, he looks at the authority patterns of the religious past that guarded the standard claims of orthodoxy and created security while impeding both human growth and human maturity. He seeks the meaning behind the religious words that flow far too easily from the lips of those with an unexamined faith tradition. He calls his readers into the exhilarating freedom that dares to ask the questions and to roam into issues and places where most religious thinkers refuse to go. The context of his life as a chaplain, dealing with real people and real concerns, is never lost.
His is the theology of a preacher who must communicate with ordinary people who raise ordinary questions as they try to make sense out of their lives each day. It is therefore an incredibly readable book.
There are few David Harts in organized religion in the world today. When we discover one of them in our midst we must encourage and support him or her, even while we celebrate the life of so special a person. For such people are pearls of great price upon which the Christian church must depend if it hopes to live with power and integrity in the twenty-first century.