There lies more faith in honest doubt, Believe me, than in half the creeds Alfred Lord Tennyson, ‘‘In Memoriam” (1850) Review A DIFFERENT FAITH Anne Ashworth Anthony Freeman's God in Us: A Case for Christian Humanism (SCM, £5.95 paperback) made Sea of Faith a talking point in the pulpit, the press and the pub. You read all about the fuss it caused in the last issue. Now read the review.
There have been many pleas in the Network for a book which would state our case directly and briefly, without referring to philosophers an enquirer has probably not read: a book to clarify our thinking and to offer to those who will never read Cupitt. Here it is, it's arguments set out with a fresh, simple clarity. In only 87 pages Anthony Freeman makes a case for a Christianity stripped of all supernatural pretensions, taking us swiftly through radical reinterpretations of God, Saviour, Spirit, prayer, tradition and church. Less convincingly, he presents his reasons for remaining in the church, indeed in the Church of England.
The book therefore merits applause and thanks. This reviewer will refrain from wholehearted adulation, as will be apparent, but first let us survey the real strengths of God in Us.
Freeman's demolition of the arguments for God from design and revelation is swift and total. All so-called knowledge of God is human at the point of delivery, and we cannot get beyond or behind that.
The church has had its own vested interests, as the author points out, in pretending to an exclusive and unchanging message from Above; but there is no such message. Freeman demonstrates how, for instance, ideas of Jesus as saviour have differed. They varied even between the New Testament writers, and have altered since as world-views and life-experiences have changed. First, people looked for salvation from death; later, from sin and damnation. These are no longer prevalent anxieties. Today it is rather aimlessness and lack of values which bedevil us. It is part of Freeman's project to show that Christian humanism can supply the very values which could be our latterday salvation. He shows too how the loss of Jesus' uniqueness will be a positive gain, a contribution to world peace.
One of the best chapters in the book is that on the Holy Spirit: "the holy human spirit". The legend of Pentecost suggests that God would thereafter reside within humanity, as Jeremiah and Jesus had hoped. A church, intermediary between heaven and earth, should have been redundant; yet ironically Whit is regarded as the birthday of the church. We need, Freeman argues, a view of "spirit" which does away with the supernatural, avoids the dangers of special charismatic powers, and removes that self-denigrating cringing which ascribes all goodness to God, all weakness to ourselves. Away with that devaluation of human life which cries "There is no health in us!" or "Life is a vale of tears!" Humanism, whether Christian or not, affirms that the only possible source of goodness is within ourselves. The universe is not moral and we need spend no anxiety on whether life is fair to us. Justice is our own human notion, and it is we who must implement it. Yes, human beings are wicked; but it is they - we - who have developed the very notion of good and evil. It is we who have aspired to truth, love, peace and beauty. A heartening thought. No wonder Anthony Freeman's "conversion", at a Sea of Faith conference, brought "a glorious sense of freedom and joy".
Freeman remains a Christian humanist, asserting that our highest values derive from Christianity, though naturally he is selective in the values he retains. Within Christian history, as he points out, values have changed. Present-day western Christians subscribe to ideals of democracy and human rights, aspirations directly opposed to the hierarchical and despotic language of creed and scripture.
Many streams run into the Sea of Faith, we say. If we have 500 members there are probably 500 viewpoints, and it is proper to declare that mine differs from Anthony Freeman's. Inevitably non-Anglicans will bring their own perspectives to the book. For me, then, and perhaps for others, the author seems on less solid ground when it comes to prayer. As an Anglican priest, he admits to using for public prayer "familiar ancient texts where one is hardly conscious of the words at all". Such words, he says, "help me to feel that I belong". Many of us would retort that it is precisely such words which convince us that we don't.
There is a paradox here. Anthony Freeman is, as God in Us demonstrates, a master of plain words. Yet when it comes to prayer he takes refuge in obfuscation, even after admitting that prayer is actually talking to ourselves. He sets out a 1662 prayer for the monarch, insisting that in spite of the altogether objectionable sentiments he could if required use it as "an expression of hope for the well-being of our whole country". Surely there are better ways of expressing such hopes!
It is true that language is always being stretched, but there comes a point where stretching becomes distortion, and distortion a betrayal of common communication. To use words in this way suggests a wild dissociation from reality.
Perhaps Anthony Freeman rejoices in that dissociation. His book opens, amusingly enough, with a comparison between his congregation using the 1662 prayer book and the Sealed Knot Society replaying battles of the Civil War. But it won't do. Those muddy mail-clad actors know they are playing let's pretend; the church mostly does not. Later in the book the author compares the worship of an idol-maker who knows that he has himself fashioned his wooden image with the unwitting idolatry of constructing a god in merely human words. Does he or does he not wish Christians to know what they are saying and doing?
Disarmingly, Anthony Freeman openly inserts into his book the very questions and tests by which he expects it to be judged. Has he cut off the branch he is sitting on? How much reinterpreting can we do and still claim that it is the same faith? Though resolutely clinging to the label "Christian", he is bold enough to insist that his is not just "a different interpretation of the same essential core, but a different faith". His claim to stand within the tradition therefore has to rest on the changefulness of that tradition.
It seems a slender thread to hang a life on, and one's heart goes out to this courageous priest. Some of us, nevertheless, would feel that a more accurate description of Freeman's humanism would be "post-Christian", and that his reasons for staying within the church are less than adequate.
Such cavils aside, God in Us is welcome and timely. I for one am already recommending it to people. Sea of Faith is indebted to Anthony, as Anthony is indebted to the Network.
Anne Ashworth is convenor of North-West SoF and Reviews Editor of the URC journal Reform.