Contents
Articles
- Prospects for Peace in Iraq, Mike Phipps
- Peace in Afghanistan?, Gabriel Carlyle
- Israel/Palestine: Is it Now or Never?, Tony Klug
- Nuclear Weapons – A Dying Religion, Bruce Kent
- Book Announcement: This Life on Earth
- How It Is, Cicely Herbert
- Radio Rockall: Bill's Bridges
- SOF Sermon: Peace on Earth, Stephen Mitchell
- Mayday Notes: Christmas
Reviews
- Give a Boy a Gun, David Paterson
- A Time to Speak Out and Visions of the Endgame, Michael Morton
- The Poetry of Phil Poole, Mary Michaels
Poetry
- The New Temple, Muhammed Iqbal
- Galaxy of Days, Daphne Gloag
Regulars and Occasionals
- SOF Sift: A Good Traveller, Richard Wood-Penn


Editorial
When I was ten I was sent to an odd little school in the wilds of Devon with just 30 girls (and several ponies). Like many of her generation, the headmistress never married because, we girls gathered, she had lost the man she loved in the Great War. So she had become a teacher and started her school, carrying it on all through the Second World War and into the 1950s, when I arrived. She was a formidable woman.
Though thoroughly English, she would terrify our country parents by rushing out to greet them gabbling at them in French, and every Christmas term every girl in the school had to learn to recite in French Luke’s story of the angels appearing to the shepherds to announce the birth of Jesus. Or il y avait, we called it, because that was how it began: Or il y avait dans ces contrées-là des bergers… Our headmistress was right: many things you learn by heart when young stay with you. Sixty years on, thinking in bed late at night about writing this Editorial, I found I could still remember it word for word with its tremendous climax of an army of angels appearing in the heavens and singing Peace on Earth: Et au même instant il y eut avec l’ange une multitude de l’armée céleste louant Dieu et disant: Gloire à Dieu dans les lieux très hauts, Paix sur la Terre et pour les hommes bienveillance. Sixty years on we still do not have peace on Earth but wars and weapons all over the place, particularly in the Middle East.
The child whose birth the angels announced is called Prince of Peace, and Emmanuel meaning ‘God with us’. In a sense this story of God coming down to Earth is about bringing home to us what has always been the case. God is nowhere else. ‘God’ has been used as a ‘supernaturalisation’ (a poetic trope akin to personification or metaphor) of beings and forces of Cosmos and Earth, from which we evolved, and forces in us, including the moral forces – some still in a rudimentary state – such as love and kindness. That baby, to whom the shepherds bow down, is the hero, the supreme representative of the ‘human form divine’, which has the potential to bring about a world of justice and peace. But it is up to us to make it happen, or as the young say nowadays, down to us.
The Divine Vision still was seen, Still was the Human Form Divine, Weeping in weak and mortal clay, O Jesus, still the Form was thine.
And thine the Human Face, and thine The Human Hands and Feet and Breath, Entering through the Gates of Birth And passing through the Gates of Death.
The story tells us that every child, born into any circumstances, however unpropitious, embodies ‘the human form divine’. Every child is a reason – logos – why peace on Earth is so urgent. And anyone who has given birth, attended a birth or seen a newborn baby feels something of that ‘great mystery’.
Jesus, whose birth the angels announced singing ‘Peace on Earth’, grew up to weep over Jerusalem’s lack of peace. ‘As a hen gathers her chicks’ he longed to gather it together. ‘And when he drew near and saw the city he wept over it, saying “Would that even today you knew the things that make for peace!” ’ (Lk 19:41). He entered the city and was executed as a subversive. He had taught: ‘Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called children of God.’ (Mt. 5:9) This Christmas issue of Sofia is called Peace on Earth? With a question mark. We sometimes feel so helpless about what we can do for peace. That sense of powerlessness became outrage when on February 15th 2003 the largest peace demonstration London had ever seen (and in many other cities) was completely ignored by our Government and quickly followed by an invasion called Shock and Awe.
The least we can do is keep ourselves informed and become part of that public opinion that demands and longs for peace. For this issue we have invited four peace campaigners to write about the areas in which they are active and the prospects there. Mike Phipps is an activist with Iraq Occupation Focus and co-editor of its fortnightly e-newsletter. Gabriel Carlyle is Afghanistan news editor for Peace News. He will be speaking about Afghanistan at the Peace News Winter Gathering in Nottingham, 15-17 January 2010.
Tony Klug has written extensively about the IsraeliPalestinian conflict for nearly 40 years, is a special advisor on the Middle East to the Oxford Research Group and vice chair of the Arab-Jewish Forum. Two works by him are reviewed in this issue by Michael Morton. Bruce Kent has been a leader and outstanding figure in the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament for decades. Sofia is grateful and proud to publish their contributions.
Perhaps some readers will be inspired to do more than just read (some will already be doing more). War is wasteful. We weep for all the thousands killed, maimed and made homeless in war zones and for our own soldiers – very young in some cases – who die, or come home without comrades or mutilated or driven mad. There is no supernatural agency to bring about peace on Earth. It is down to us. editorial Peace on Earth?
Sofia Editor: Dinah Livingstone, 10 St Martin’s Close London NW1 0HR editor@sofn.org.uk Dear Editor, In the Yorkshire Dales recently (August 26) I called upon Ruth Robinson. She’s confined to a wheelchair now, and the state of her lungs is such that she needs continuous oxygen. But she is being very well cared for by her family, and is in good spirits. ‘Don’t know why I’m bothering to hang on,’ she said cheerfully, reciting a lengthy list of SOF people to whom I must pass on her greetings. Which I hereby do. It was a necessarily brief but also rather inspiring visit.
Don Cupitt Cambridge letters Cartoon by Josh the only ones left with an independent nuclear weapons in Europe?
Not that ours are independent anyway. The ‘Moss Bros’ deterrent Harold Wilson once called ours. And how right he was. Do many people know that we actually borrow our Trident missiles from the United States, return them for repair and get another set in exchange.
How can we British help the world to move towards a global understanding that common security based on interdependence is the only security to be had? It is a good moment to ask that question. Our country is at a cross roads. We either spend billions, perhaps £75 billion, on replacing our Trident nuclear submarine fleet or we become the first of the major nuclear powers to give up nuclear weapon status. A choice has to be made. No nonsense please about 3 submarines instead of 4: that is a purely cosmetic device designed to placate old believers who find change too difficult.
To say ‘NO’ to Trident replacement would release massive sums of money which would ease our present economic crisis and enable a variety of humane and positive projects to go ahead .
Internationally we would be giving strong support to Obama at a time when he much needs it, and great encouragement to those participating in next May’s NPT review conference in New York.
Einstein was wrong. Old modes of thinking do change and we can help to speed up the process.
As the Final Report of the First United Nations Special Session on Disarmament in 1978 said: ‘Enduring international peace and security cannot be built on the accumulation of weaponry by military alliances nor be sustained by a precarious balance of deterrence or doctrines of strategic superiority.’ It is time to move to a religion of common humanity, global law, mutual security and social and environmental responsibility.
— Don Cupitt, Cambridge