WHAT IS THERE TO READ BESIDES CUPITT ? (1) by Anne Ashworth What is there to read besides Cupitt ? That was the question the editor posed to me. Perhaps I had better make it clear that I am neither philosopher, theologian nor scientist - simply a librarian and reviews editor (for "Reform", the URC monthly). I write as a lay person, for other 'general readers'. Here goes then, out of my necessarily limited knowledge.
If the question means "Is anyone else writing like Cupitt ?", I have to say at once that I know of no-one else exploring that particular frontier. So I will interpret the challenge as "Can you suggest other kinds of books for Sea of Faith readers ?". I'll try.
Shall we begin with a survey of our precursors in radical theology ? There were more of them than I realised when I read Keith Clements'_Lovers _of discord: _twentieth century. theologicaLamtroyersies in EngiancL(SPCK 1988). From 'Essays and Reviews' in 1860, through the 'Down Grade Controversy' of the late 1880s and the 'New Theology' of the new century, Clements goes on to the 'Modern Churchmen', 'Soundings', 'Honest to God' and the 'Death of God' theologians. Perhaps we are not as newfangled as we imagined ?
And now back to ancient history. How was this great christological edifice, which we so urgently need to demolish, erected in the first place ? I know of no clearer guide than Thomas Sheehan in The first coming : how _the kingdom oL God became Christianity (Thorsons Crucible 1986). Sheehan clarifies the process of deification. In stage one, when the followers were Palestinian Jews, Jesus was the future Son of Man to be revealed at the Parousia or Second Coming. In stage two, that of Hellenistic Jewish Christians, Jesus' future glory changes to the present tense - and stems from progressively earlier moments, viz. his resurrection, his baptism, his conception. In stage three, Gentile Christians glorify him into the past tense, as pre-existent co-eternal divinity.
On the subject of New Testament studies - you have never read a book on St. Paul like Graham Shaw's In The cosLof_aulhority : manipulation and freedom in the N_ew Testament (SCM 1983), Shaw performs an unforgettable hatchet job on the epistolary apostle.
Read it for its shock value, as entertainment. Then go on to the later sections on Mark, and on the problems of authority and freedom in churchmanship today. "Is all religious authority of its nature oppressive ?" the author asks at the outset. On the way, almost as PAGE 12 AUTUMN 1990 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE asides, he denies the resurrection and the supernatural ; states that "the uncritical reading of the New Testament ... is directly responsible for many of the horrors of Christian history" ; and finally admits that as a priest of the Church of England he has probably sawn off the branch on which he was sitting.
Nevertheless, Shaw insists that his purpose was not to write "a series of spectacular denials" but to commend the positive values of freedom and reconciliation.
Another Anglican priest whose book will make your hair stand to attention is Richard MacKenna. God_for nothingLisreligion ba_d_for _you 2 (Souvenir Press 1984) is not a scholarly treatise like the three already mentioned. It is a hard hitting, straight questioning book of almost unbearable honesty by a London curate who will not allow the comfortable cottonwool of Christian devotion to obscure human realities. His villains, like Shaw's, are the clergy. His theology is less radical, perhaps. It consists of a "basic trust in Being", tempered by an acknowledgement that we are given, as it were, a page of microdots in which some of us manage to discern shape and meaning.
MacKenna's recipe for the church of the future is worth considering. He calls for an attitude of care and openness to creation ; for acceptance of the insights of other faiths ; for freedom for doubt and disbelief ; and above all, for a community which gets on with the job of loving people and getting broken up in the process. Taking down God_for nothing for the purposes of this article, I found myself wasting - no, using I - a whole weekend compulsively rereading it from cover to cover.
Many in Sea of Faith have looked to the psychological disciplines to assist our quest. Some have recommended Christopher Bryant's books (all published by Darton Longman Todd), but I personally have been disappointed. At secondhand, therefore, I can only offer a book I have not myself encountered. It is Religious experience by W. Proudfoot (Univ. of California Press 1985). Published at £20.95, this is evidently a substantial volume. Proudfoot argues that religious experience is open to alternative explanations, and the book is commended in particular to those interested in other faiths and their experience. (Nearer home, a reader edited by Michael Jacobs called Faith oLfear_? (DLT pbk 1987) may be of use to those interested in the relationship between religion and psychology and also the question of faith and pastoral counselling - Editor.) Psychology is not the only science having an interface with religion. Such meeting points may be crucial for our further understanding. Some last ditch Christianity, as well as some dewy-eyed Creation Spirituality, has looked to the new physics for support. There remains an open area of debate here. Stephen Hawking concludes his acclaimed A 12rief history_af time (Bantam 1988) with a suggestion that if a Great Universal Theory emerges we may know the mind of God. The phrase is rhetorical, and Hawking has no theological intention. Those who, like me, read the book twice but remain baffled may benefit more from Paul Davies' Go_cLand_the new_p_Lysics (Dent 1983).
Here Davies not only outlines the new physics for lay readers but seriously engages with those who hope to find God there. Systematically and sympathetically he demonstrates reasons for these hopes but is obliged to refute them. He leaves, perhaps, a chink for a last possible God-of-the-gaps, but it is hardly more than the Cheshire Cat's grin. More positively, Davies dwells on the importance of mind and the possible evolution of supermind. He warns against the trap of 'nothing buttery', in which all phenomena are reduced to 'nothing but ...' their constituent particles ; and acknowledges that there are other levels of language which have validity.
When James Lovelock published his Gaia (Oxford 1979) he was surprised to find it taken up by religious seekers. In his later The ages oLGaia (Oxford 1988), Lovelock devotes a chapter to "God and Gaia". Gaia - a Greek personification of the earth - is not in Lovelock's theory a goddess. "In no way do I see Gaia as a sentient being, a surrogate god," the author insists. Gaia denotes the earth as a self-regulating organism. Nevertheless Lovelock agrees that "Gaia is a religious as well as a scientific concept", for "God and Gaia, theology and science, are not separate but a single way of thought". The Gaia concept may well help to inspire that reverence for earth towards which religions old and new are now groping.
And finally, the feminists. After listening to Ann Loades and Daphne Hampson, what should Sea of Faith people read ? The pioneer was perhaps the most radical in her theology - but Mary Daly's Beyond God the Father (The Womens Press 1983 ; US publication 1973) is admittedly almost unreadable. Of the many books from Christian feminists, we may usefully select one on theology and one on the movement. They are, respectively, Rosemary Radford Ruether's Sexism and_goditalk : towards a feminist theology (SCM 1983) and Sara Maitland's A_ma.a_of the ne_w_ootaty_t_woMen_and_Christianity_(Routledge 1983). For more varied viewpoints, including some radical and post-Christian feminists, try the book with the shocking cover ! It is Sand God some variaties_o_f_wo_men's religious experience, edited by Linda Hurlcombe (Routledge 1987). i guarantee there will be something in it to engage you, to enrage you.
I have reached sex, and broken into rhyme. That must be enough for one bookshelf.
ANNE ASHWORTH lives in Blackpool. She is engaged in editorial and other activities in the United Perform Church in which she is also an accredited lay preacher.