Religious Experience: Don Cupitt and Loyal Rue Answer Some Questions Posed by John Mann

AUTUMN 1990 PAGE 9 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE Earlier this year Don Cupitt and Loyal Rue answered some questions for us posed by John Mann 1. Have you ever had an overwhelming reVibus experience, for example that everything is one, or that you are known and loved?

D_O_n_CUpitt : Yes, I have described two vivid religious experiences, both of which occurred when I was about 20, in Taking_Leave of God, pages 30ff.

However I think that there are many reasons for being cautious about religious experiences. John Stuart Mill says very shrewdly that "Mankind are always predisposed to believe that any subjective feeling, not otherwise accounted for, is a revelation of some objective reality" (Utilitarianism, V). Yes, indeed. And this reminds me to point out that in your question you use the expression "experience ... that". By itself 'an experience' is just a fleeting psychological state, like a mood or a feeling. What makes such a state informative, so that it can tell us about how things are in another world, or something ? And since people's experiences are obviously shaped by the religious tradition they already belong to, what happens when my 'experience-that' conflicts with (for example) a Hindu's 'experience-that' ?

My conclusion is that we need to be critical about our own religious experiences, and we need to be aware of the extent to which we ourselves produce them.

They don't usually give us quite new information.

Rather they crystallize the way in which, perhaps unconsciously, we are already coming to think.

Dostoyevsky sets us a good example here. He was well aware that his own vivid religious experiences were natural phenomena connected with the onset of epilepsy. He did not deceive himself. Nevertheless he regarded the experiences as interesting and important, and drew on them in his writing.

Similarly with us. Religious experiences are natural psychological phenomena, often connected with stress, mental illness, drugs etc. They can easily be induced artificially. Yet those that arise within us spontaneously may indeed mark important turningpoints in our religious lives. They are worth reflecting on.

Loyal Rue : Have I had an overwhelming religious experience ? Yes. Once. And it was at a moment in my life when I was highly vulnerable emotionally. I was about 20 years old, living far away from my family, and completely unattached to any sort of social network or to any sort of life goal. I was alone and drifting. It happened that my uncle (an evangelical pastor) came to see me, sensed that I was without substance in my life, and took the appropriate evangelical measures. He convinced me that I wasn't alone and that my life did have a goal etc.

All of this culminated in the two of us on our knees etc. etc. The short of it is that I felt somehow 'rescued'. It was a profound experience for me - I felt known, loved, unworried, well-oriented. That was then. Now, as a theological non-realist, I think that I am unsuited for this type of experience. My whole cognitive network has been rewired and there are no longer any circuits for that particular form of experience. Moreover, I am not without social support and vocational direction, as I was then. 2. How iin,cortant is religious experience to you 7 Do you use any techniques to achieve an afteied stale of00/7SCA9USROSS, such as mecetiatkm Don Cupitt : No, I don't seek out the unusual psychological states that I suspect you have in mind.

But I do often get an intense charge, a heightened sense of life, from art, from landscape, and from language. That is a sort of religious experience.

You ask if I "use any techniques ...". I think I'd answer that the divine is not to be found in abnormal or supernatural or queer states of consciousness.

Rather the divine is to be found in that enhanced sense of joy in life that any of us experience while in our ordinary-everyday consciousness. I felt it this morning when I saw the Spring flowers, bobbing in the wind and burning radiant in the strong sunlight.

Loyal__Rue : How important is religious experience for me ? For me it is very important that I get off by myself from time to time to confront nature without the conventions of civilization constantly intruding. Perhaps you will call this "communing with nature". I never feel any earth-shattering experience or an PAGE 10 AUTUMN 1990 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE altered state of mind (unless relative serenity would qualify). I make no attempt to achieve these little escapes on any regular basis. When life clutters, I find a way.

I especially love music and literature. Is there anything religious about this ? I would say not, although I do suppose that my love for music and literature is not entirely unrelated to having been raised a Lutheran. I am not a serious student of music and literature, but I find they are increasingly important. Perhaps it is the case that these forms move in as the sex drive begins to wane. But I don't think I'd label them 'religious' any more than I would so label sex. Actually, I seem to have gone off the habit of using 'religious' as a category for any particular dimensions in my life. 3 Do you have any strong emotional feelings towards Jesus CouV you say, for examok; that you loved him more than anyone else in the work" 7 Don_Cupitt : There isn't one person there any more.

When we read the Gospels today, we find four very different Jesuses. But I especially like, as I've often said, the parables, the reversal-sayings, the Jesus of Luke, the Jesus of Rembrandt, the Jesus of Stanley Spencer and the Jesus who just symbolises the needy fellow-human and the persecuted Jew.

Am I making this clear ? Invisible persons and objects of faith have all been dissolved away by our modern critical and historical ways of thinking. But we still have the whole rich tradition that we have received.

Different bits of it may mean a great deal to us, as I for example admire Spencer's images of Christ in Cookham.

Loyal_Rue : Strong feelings towards Jesus ? Not really. When I was a kid I thought of Jesus as a god and friend. Now he's an obscure historical figure.

Socrates, Buddha, Gandhi, Jeremiah, Augustine, Jesus - all objects of historical curiosity, but none of them appropriately thought of as an object of love. 4. Are there any parts of the Bible that are pailicular4/ meaningful to you, that grasp you and direct you 7 Don_Cupin : I love the Hebrew Bible, especially I and II Samuel, I and II Kings, Amos, Hosea, Isaiah, Jeremiah and the Psalms. Some books I find boring and disagreeable : Esther and Daniel, for example.

Loyal Rue : Bible ? A fascinating literary tradition generated by a remarkable historical community. It no longer "grasps" or "directs" me. 5 What effect does a church serves have on you 7 What feelings does it evoke 7 What are your thoughts during the hymns, prayer and communion 7 Don Cupitt: In the College Chapel we maintain the daily round of services. They help me to stay with the Church and keep in touch with the Christian tradition.

I like the Communion Service, which I see as symbolising God's continual dying into humanity. So at the beginning of the service, when I am celebrating, I bow to the Altar ; and at the end I bow to the people. God has been dispersed into the people of God. Tom Altizer has recently written that "the Christian God is unique among deities in the history of religions because it is most fully itself in its own death". I like that : our God, the Christian God, is defined by the way he dies into his people, a self-giving which the Eucharist enacts. God is most himself in his own self-loss.

You see, 'Christianity' is not just a religion, one more of the 'religions'. It also the end of religion, the transcendence of religion. Christianity is also a critique of 'religion', and a liberation from religion.

Loyal Rue : Church service ? Usually I can take it or leave it. I go to church regularly, but out of familial duty more than anything else. I like to hear a good organ played well, and I like to join in some of the good old rousing Christian hymns. What are the feelings ? I'm not exactly sure, though it may have something to do with being a part of a long tradition.

The only church services that genuinely move me (get ready for this ...) are funeral services. Again I'm not sure why. It could have to do with the emoton of a final farewell, though I think it has more to do with the fact that a funeral service gets me to think of a loved one in a way that I've never thought of him/her before. There's something deeply moving about that - but I'm not about to say that this is the sort of service I long to attend. Prayers and communion I'm completely indifferent about. 6 How /MX/ ant do you think it is to have a irVibus experience ? Should a person actively fry to have one 7 Don Cupitt : No. I take a purely naturalistic view of the self and psychology. I think it is a mistake to AUTUMN 1990 PAGE 11 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE suppose that after supernatural causes have disappeared from the natural world, we can continue to contact the supernatural via our supposed inner psychological world. I believe we should identify the religious with the normal and everyday. God is the ordinary world of life (and death). God is normal consciousness. Religious experience is the ordinary experience of being turned on or delighted.

Looking for experiences is not the point. In a famous experiment W H Pahnke (1966) found that psilocybin, administered to theological students before their Good Friday service, produced vivid, lasting and beneficial experiences. If 'experiences' are what we want, the psilocybin ought to be distributed to the congregation at every communion service. But nobody is suggesting that, surely ? Religion is about the imaginative and ethical transformation of the life-world. It is not just about subjective psychological states. By themselves such states are unimportant.

Put it another way. Suppose a pill could give sexual satisfaction. Which would you rather have : complete happiness with a pill - or moderate happiness with a real person ?

Loyal Rue : This is a really tough one. No-one who has had a 'religious' experience is likely to discount its importance. Is the experience of being loved important ? Yes, I suppose so. Should we actively seek such an experience ? I suppose we do seek love without being explicitly aware of doing so.

Here's what I think : It is important to find our bearings in the world, and this we all ought to seek.

There are lots of ways to do this, and when we succeed there is usually some form of confirming experience that comes along. To seek the experience for its own sake strikes me as a bit artificial. I'll just leave this question with a variant on Matthew 6:33 - "seek ye first to make a home in the world, and all these things will be added unto you".

DON CUPITT is lecturer in the Philosophy of Religion in the University of Cambridge and Dean of Emmanuel College. He is also a member of the SOF Steering Committee.

LOYAL RUE was a speaker at SOF II. He is Associate Professor, Dept of Religion and Philosophy, Luther College, Decorah, Iowa, USA.

JOHN MANN lives in Suffolk and is an analyst programmer.

Questions posed by John Mann.