THE THING FROM THE CRYPT John Mann What is the nature of radical Christianity ? What is natural in it and what unnatural ? What is essential and what unessential ? What is living and what is dead ? Has its nature been hidden from itself ? Does it hide because it has mason to hide? If the object of theology is God, where does he lie in radical theology ? Can we search out his tomb and read what is inscribed in it ?
Historically, the nature of radical Christianity is a negative nature : it is defined by what it is not. It is non-realist and anti-supernaturalist, yet the way we understand this negativity determines the field of possibility within radical Christianity.
One way of appropriating this nothingness is to see the non-objectivity of God simply as atheism. Thus 'Religion' becomes eat when you're hungry, sleep when you're tired and the emptiness of God fails to register or evoke response. Another way is denial that anything essential has changed to affect the practice of Christianity : one can still attend church, have a vision of hope, and follow the story of Christ. Usually the result is a mixture between these two boundaries, where some practices are discontinued (as in atheism, eg prayer and Bible study) and others remain.
I would argue that such a practice of radical Christianity fails on two counts. Firstly, it only emerges as a result of disillusionment, thus the only potential radical Christians are those who are already Christians. Secondly, it fails to take seriously this event called the 'Death of God', the loss of objectivity, foundation, origin and transcendent meaning. In this unnatural form, radical Christianity translates the Death of God into a weak pluralism, a pragmatic mish-mash of atheism and Christianity. This hybrid Christianity seems more like a neo-gnosticism, where the adherents can say the creeds but privately hold the language to be figurative not factual.
At present radical Christianity has no nature, but it has some language, out of which may be constructed possibilities. To my mind a better presentation of radical Christianity would see the Death of God as a real event to be understood spiritually, that has to be 16 SOF Magazine 10, Summer 1992 to be experienced and ritualised. Don Cupitt's rewriting of the eucharist as a celebration of the dissemination of God into humanity contains a glimpse of this.
One way of presenting this idea is through Freud's theory of mourning, which I shall briefly explain.
When a loved one dies the libidinal investment placed in that person needs to be reallocated, the technical term is 'introjected'. This means that the fact of that person's death needs to be made known to all the different parts of the psyche, the death needs to be integrated. A successful period of mourning will integrate, or introject, the fact of the death into the self. However, an unsuccessful mourning does not disperse the fact of the death but keeps it hidden from the rest of the psyche. This is called 'incorporation' and produces various phenomena associated with an unsuccessful mourning, such as continuing to act as if the person were still alive, eg setting their place at the dinner table.
Nicholas Abraham and Maria Torok have developed this theory in their book The Wolf Man's Magic Words_ A Cryptanomy (University of Minnesota Press, 1986) in which they call the place in the psyche where the incorporated dead person now lives a "crypt" : dead, but living inside me.
There is a chance that radical Christianity has encrypted God, hidden his death except as a word-thing (we may speak of his death, there runs a secret passage from his crypt to the mouth). What would this mean ? That we have built a wall between theory and practice, that we may speak of the Death of God but not experience it, not enact it. Thus this contradiction (which signifies desire) yields repetition and paralysis. This lost nature, this buried nature, this hidden nature, cannot appear and grow in the rays of the sun until the fact of the death is known, is mourned, is introjected.
Nietzsche had a premonition that this fact would need to be religiously experienced. In his parable in The Gay Science (1882), the Madman, having announced that we have killed God, cries : "How shall we murderers of all murderers, console ourselves ? ... What festivals of atonement, what sacred games shall we need to invent ?" There was once some talk of erasing the name of God. Some said, "People no longer understand the word 'God', we must stop using it", others suggested using 'X' instead of God. If we have hidden the Death of God from ourselves, what now remains in this en-crypted space ? Derrida writes in the foreword to Abraham & Torok's book : "The Thing is to be thought out starting from the Crypt, the Thing as 'crypt effect'." This 'Thing' that remains of the Dead God, leaves its Crypt to haunt our discourse and ventriloquise our speech. The living-dead God-thing proceeds from the crypt, traumatising, paralysing, haunting. Those who reject spirituality and religious experience protest too much. They have glimpsed what is in there and fear to look. Yet unless we find the entrance to the Crypt, radical Christianity will remain traumatised and psychically exhausted. Those who urge us to concentrate on the 'outer' world ('inner' experience is unnatural, 'abnormal') will just make meat out of the soul.
Nothing will be created.
Radical Christians walk in a deserted city : the ruins of God. There is no nature here ... As yet they do not know its name, nor do they understand yet that it must become their home. New festivals, new writings, new buildings must be created. The sun also shines on those who mourn.
JOHN MANN is an analyst programmer in Suffolk.