This article originally appeared in Rapport, a magazine published by CancerCare in Lancaster. It raises important questions about the use and expression of belief. The author began his own battle with cancer in 1984 and has been a volunteer helper with CancerCare since then. In so much literature about illness and, perhaps, particularly when people write about cancer patients, there is an assumption of a belief in God. This is not necessarily so and the purpose of my writing is to make a plea for tolerance and understanding of the humanist viewpoint - a plea for Christian tolerance towards those who do not necessarily accept the certainties which religion seems to offer. This is not a plea for reducing discussion between those who believe and those who do not. Far from it, for lively informed debate is helpful to all views of what life is about and is to be welcomed. It is merely a plea for certainties which cannot be proved - by either side - to be avoided at times of stress, grief and uncertainty.
It may seem churlish to write this article when prayers are being said for me in local churches ; prayers which are greatly appreciated. But I feel something must be written to remind people that we don't all have the same beliefs, or lack of beliefs. Failure to recognise this can cause unnecessary misunderstandings, difficulties and hurt.
Two examples of hurtful experiences - one mine and one overheard - illustrate what can happen. I SOF Magazine 10, Summer 1992 17 recovered from my first cancer attack after coming close to death : after my recovery I was berated by Christian acquaintance for my lack of belief in God when it was obvious that the prayers offered in her church had persuaded God to spare me. (I believe I had the right to be deeply grateful for her prayers - and I was ! - but I also believe she had no right to expect me to believe in her God.) I believed that I had been saved by a skilful surgeon, devoted nursing staff and a dedicated wife, who more than anybody, saved me from death.
I was helped enormously by the prayers of Anglicans, Catholics, Methodists, Brethren and others in their churches (I am blessed with a very wide range of ex-professional colleagues and friends) not because I believed their prayers reached a God, but because of my passionate belief in the ability of human beings to communicate their feelings to each other : an actual transfer of energy - positive thinking if you like - and I was therefore aware of, and grateful for, the power of their 'prayers' to help me. To have so many friends in so many denominations - as well as fellow humanists - concerned with my well-being was, indeed, a source of great comfort and something of which I was aware even at the darkest moments.
The other instance, overheard, concerned a humanist friend of mine who had just heard of the death of a much loved friend. A well-meaning Christian weighed in with words of comfort which merely added anger to my friend's grief. Assumptions about a belief in a life after death and God meeting the dead person at the Gates of Heaven did not provide the appropriate support and understanding that was needed at that moment. Sensitivity at times of grief is so important.
I think I ought to add a third instance, but this time illustrating the insensitivity of this humanist. Some years ago I was sitting at a table at the Kendal CancerCare Drop-In and in the course of conversation commented that I had no belief in an after-life.
The reaction of one man was immediate : his only reason for living was the sure knowledge that he would meet his late wife in Heaven when the time for his death arrived. I knew I had unnecessarily offended and hurt him. I had been insensitive to his needs. So perhaps my title ought to have been simply "A Plea For Tolerance". But then, I particularly wanted to encourage Christians to read this.
Perhaps I ought to record at this stage my complete belief in what Jesus teaches us about how we should treat each other and about what kind of behaviour at all levels might lead to a saner and happier world. In that sense I have always tried to lead a 'Christian' life, although not always successfully, but there is so much I cannot accept or believe in. In simple terms, I lack 'faith', an indispensable item, it seems to me, to be a Christian. And Christians should remember that faith has to be accepted - without much thought by some, but only after deep and sometimes agonized thought by others ; in the same way some humanists come to their views too easily - others agonize. I have thought a great deal before reaching my present views.
In my young days I was a choir boy in the Church of England, later a Congregationalist Sunday School Teacher and a visitor to the Unitarian Church.
Wartime experience turned me away from organised religion and 'faith'. Despite my lack of faith, I've always taken a great interest in religion(s) and have had endless discussions with people of all religions and none. John Robinson's Hones' to God in the Sixties gave me hope that some of the unacceptable aspects of faith could be discarded. Further encouragement came to me through the very sensible reservations expressed by the Bishop of Durham although the somewhat un-Christian response of some church members saddened me. More recently I have been fascinated and greatly encouraged by the views of Don Cupitt and the group of Christians who seem to move much closer to my point of view - demythologising God and seeing Him in everyone and everything. No God in Heaven : no After-life.
I respect, and in some ways envy, the faith of my many Christian friends who gain so much from their religion and the certainty of their beliefs. Please understand that humanists can have just as deep a concern about their fellows as Christians, even if they lack 'faith', and that they are sometimes hurt by insensitive assumptions made by others.
I must include a message for my fellow cancer sufferers who cannot accept 'faith' and are puzzled and often worried by the tenor of much that reaches them through visitors and articles they read. You have as much right not to believe as other cancer sufferers have the right to believe. Believers and non-believers alike need as much help, support, comfort and understanding as possible. The help, so deeply appreciated by those of us unfortunate enough to be facing cancer, should not depend on a belief in God or even a suggestion that somehow without that belief we are in some way second class citizens. We can so often be made to feel guilty at probably the most vulnerable time in our lives. There is no reason whatsoever to feel guilty.
Finally, I have to tell you that when I was so desperately ill five years ago I gained wonderful support from the then vicar of Kendal who not only made a point of always visiting me when he was in the hospital, but visited me regularly at home until I was on the mend - all this when he knew that I was a humanist. That is Christianity - and tolerance.
GLYN HARRIS was a Head Teacher in London in the 1960s and for nine years wrote and broadcast the Music Movement and Mime programme for BBC Schools' Radio. In 1969 he moved to Westmorland as Adviser to Schools, retiring in 1982 as Senior Inspector for Schools in South Cumbria.