Only Human: Our Ten Hypotheses Revisited

Not 10 Commandments, not 10 Suggestions, not 10 Articles of Faith. Just 10 hypothetical propositions offering a personal and provisional account of “what we are for”

In the July 2000 issue of SOF, I launched a debate on “what are we for?”. We all knew what Sea of Faith was against, what it did not believe, but we were open to the criticism that we were often much less clear about what we could affirm. To get the debate going, I proposed “10 Hypotheses” - broad propositions which might be said to articulate a mainstream “Sea of Faith” view. I made it clear that I was not proposing a Sea of Faith creed or a set of articles of faith to which SoF members might be expected to “sign up”. The intention was to stimulate debate, and debate is more likely to take off when there's something to get your teeth into - when, in fact, there are clear propositions to test and evaluate.

The 10 Hypotheses have attracted a lot of attention. They have been reprinted in other magazines and taken up in other forums than Sea of Faith, as well as provoking lively discussions in local SoF groups. As I reported in an up-date in the November issue, many SOF readers have responded to the invitation to comment on the hypotheses and propose specific amendments to improve them. More suggestions have come in since November. It is now time to pull the threads together.

Which is more easily said than done! Some of the amendments received would make the propositions more specifically nonrealist or humanist in tone, others would airbrush nonrealism out altogether. Some want more God-language, some want less. Some want to add, others to subtract. (I quoted a number of such amendments in the November up-date). The problem would be formidable if the intention were to produce an agreed and “official” SoF Statement, but of course it is not. These propositions began and end as nothing more than a stimulus to debate and reflection. They have no status whatever, other than as my personal contribution, so the amendments and revisions which I have taken on board are those which seem to me to clarify and improve what remains a personal statement - and a qualified, provisional one at that! My thanks to all who wrote in, but particularly, in addition to those I named in November, to Bruce Nightingale and Rachel Jenkins, who have given me valuable lessons in crisp and clear expression.

So here is the “Revised Version” of the 10 Hypotheses: my best effort, with a little help from my friends, at producing a personal and provisional view of what SoF is for, from which I invite you to take what you find useful, leave what you find useless, and add what for you may be missing.

What SoF Is For: Ten Hypotheses About Religious Faith

No set of statements about religious faith will ever tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. This naturally holds good for the hypotheses that follow.

All religions, faiths, systems and varieties of religious or spiritual faith and practice are human constructs: part of the wondrous complex of exploration and experience, imagination, accumulated knowledge, creativity and reflective consciousness which we call culture. We may speak of the divine, the transcendent and the ultimate, but we do so in the understanding that these are human concepts. Human communities created them. Human communities made it all.

We live in a natural world, which is made intelligible to us through the signs and symbols of language. We may speak of the supernatural, but we do so in the understanding that this too is a human concept, the product of human imagination, story-telling and myth-making.

As religion is the product of the creative impulse, so too are its gods and goddesses, angels and devils. They are human creations, made by human communities, reflecting our rich variety of histories, languages and cultures. “All deities reside in the human breast” (Blake). This is no less true of the god of the great monotheist traditions, the god named God. The Creator God is our creation, the Fear God our projection, the Saviour God our own solution to our own inadequacies and alienation. Heaven is the best we can imagine, hell the worst, and both are here and now.

Sacred scriptures and the stories and songs which are expressions of them have provided sense, meaning and purpose, have helped us see visions and dream dreams; but they are fallible and subject to criticism and reinterpretation. To belittle them impoverishes our heritage, but to elevate them into eternal truth is dangerous.

Our faith is “religious” in the depth of its seriousness and the sincerity of its commitment; but it is also “secular” in the literal sense of its being of this world and for this age. In a world where the supernatural is natural and the divine is human, the sacred and the secular are one. As we secularize our faith, so we also sacralize our lives. That is our commitment.

We choose to believe and have faith in the values of “mercy, pity, peace and love”, and things which are “true, honest, just, pure, lovely, and of good report”. The worship of God as an inspiration and symbol affirms these values as expressions of the human spirit.

True religion is incomplete and delusory unless it is concerned with injustice and suffering, particularly among the powerless and hungry. False religion invokes a crude supernaturalism to validate authority, sanctify power, provoke fear and superstition, foster division and disobedience, and fool the gullible. It offers heaven as compensation for earthly woes or reward for obedience, and threatens hell for making God a tyrant, and religion itself the instrument of tyranny.

The life of faith is a life of change, growth, renewal: a life of exploration and experimentation, of making new discoveries and discarding old ones when they fail us. It is a life on the ocean wave, not one that seeks the seclusion of a safe harbour. It is for the finder, for those who would make meaning and purpose rather than buy them off the peg. It demands hope, charity, and a sense of humour.

We lay no claim to eternal truth. But we cherish the best in our heritage of faith, tradition and practice as we cherish the best in our music, poetry, the arts, the sciences, and everything that gives imaginative expression to the wholly human spirit.

We, because we made it, can refashion it to meet our changing needs, understandings and experience. To explore and develop religious faith as a human creation, a human recreation, a human responsibility, and as a source of delight to ourselves and as an affirmation of our sense of responsibility for the welfare of our living world: this is our challenge and our adventure.