SOF MAGAZINE 6, SUMMER 1991 ON THROWING STONES Eric S MacDonald In the last two issues of SOF Magazine Elizabeth Burns and Aileen La Tourette have been discussing the apparently thorny question of divorce and remarriage. I should like to add a few words to this discussion. I might as well begin by remarking that I am a divorced and remarried priest in the Anglican Church of Canada. Based on my own experience neither of these fluent and thoughtful persons have really addressed the question at all, although in her parting shot Aileen La Tourette seems to come closest to it. Both, however, seem to be looking at the question from a God's eye point of view. And the problem of trying to take a God's eye view is simply that there is no God 'out there' from whose vantage point we can view the world of human relationships.
That's what non-realism is about. So we have to be content with the more humble vantage point of human life.
When I was going through the process of marriagebreakdown, one of the things that offended me most deeply was that there is a superior vantage point from which a clear path could be seen through the complexity and immediacy of personal experience.
This is precisely where moral decisions are made, not in moments of cool reflection. All my Christian upbringing told me was that what was happening, as well as what I was more and more deciding to do, was utterly and objectively wrong ; and I suffered deeply the sense of guilt and betrayal which conflict between those deeply ingrained values and the actual course of my life had occasioned.
Now the Church in the past would have rejected both me and the course of action which, in deep personal turmoil, I found myself taking ; a course which was at once deliberate and inevitable. And out of that experience has come a profound sense of the inappropriateness of judging others. As I 'worked through' the events and the feelings, along with all the conscious thought and reasoning which churned within me, I came to grasp more and more fully the moral radicalism of Jesus. Leave aside for the moment Jesus' remarks about divorce and remarriage (supposing them to be correctly ascribed to him), there is no doubt, I think, that in almost no other case did Jesus 'lay down the law'. In other words, he is almost completely non-judgemental in morality.
Think for a moment of the woman caught in adultery.
Many commentators have reminded us that Jesus told the woman to "go and sin no more", with the suggestion that Jesus condemns the sin but not the sinner. But that's not what Jesus says, according to St John. He does not tell her that she has sinned ; he merely tells her to sin no more. I get no sense from the story that the woman is made to feel guilty for what she has done. All Jesus does is to remind her of the need to act responsibly in the future, whatever may have been the character of her act of adultery.
This act is understood to have arisen out of her life heretofore. It is meaningless to ascribe it an absolute moral character, as though the real complexity of human personalities and relationships count for nothing. Had Jesus acted any differently, would not this amount to throwing stones ?
In fact, this story and the sayings about divorce and remarriage sit uneasily together - the one so harsh, peremptory and absolute, the other so gentle, compassionate and situational. I think we have to question whether the divorce-remarriage sayings are actually words of Jesus. But even if they are, we may want, I think, to consider them as Jesus' response to a particular situation, or, perhaps, as simply wrong.
Why do we neglect this latter option all the time ?
Could it be that we still hanker after absolute revelation ?
The point that I am driving at, in a rather roundabout way no doubt, is simply this. Marriage, divorce and remarriage happen. Each time it happens we have a different situation, with different people, different circumstances, different dynamics. To dismiss one person's trauma - and the process of marriagebreakdown and divorce is almost always a trauma - as being merely for 'convenience' is not only shallow, but itself morally questionable. This much we can learn from Jesus. Here on this side of the Atlantic the native peoples have a saying : "Don't judge another man unless you've walked a mile in his moccasins." That, I think, is Jesus' point when he tells us not to judge. He is telling us that human circumstances and predicaments can be exceedingly complex, and that it is simply impossible to assess and weigh the factors entering into any given decision or action.
And it is all very well to suggest, as Aileen La Tourette does, that moral decision is somehow something done coolly and dispassionately, as though life could be cool and dispassionate. One of the points that Jesus seems to make against the Pharisees is that, while the Pharisees had indeed achieved cool reasonableness about the right and the good, this passionless reason had nothing to do with life. In connexion with the sayings about divorce and remarriage (again supposing the words to be those of Jesus), it is clear that Jesus is objecting that the law SOF MAGAZINE 6, SUMMER 1991 3 of Moses, as applied by the Jews of his day, was anti-life and served the purposes of those who applied it, rather than those it was applied to ; as moral law applied to situations must always do. Moral law is not, and indeed cannot be, law in a straightforward sense at all, for in morality we are dealing with the person as person - or rather, the person involved is dealing with her situation - and not simply the person as a term in relationships of conflict - where, indeed, law comes into play.
This is the point made, I daresay, in Ms La Tourette's remark about growing up, but her idea of maturity seems skewed in the direction of rationality, as though the mature person is simply the one who makes rational choices. And this is not it at all, I suspect. At the very limit of experience, as for instance in the midst of marital breakdown, there is not, I have found, much room for untarnished reason.
Reason, both practical and moral, might say one thing, whilst one's heart and soul is stridently crying out its passionate negation of all that reason can say and at the same time, from the point of view of an observer, the actions of the person in the throes of deep personal struggle may seem self-destructive, irrational, possibly even immature, certainly deserving moral censure.
So we should not judge. It's really as simple as that.
That doesn't mean that nothing can be said about morality, but morality is much more like painting a picture than trying to stay out of trouble. Of course, the good and harm that is done by one's actions must be weighed ; and, no doubt, the law will be engaged at many points where the harm to another is measurable and open to recompense. But the fact that harm is done does not mean that harm could have been avoided in the situation as it is.
In most cases of marriage-breakdown, for instance, it may be true that if the course of the marriage had been different than in fact it had been, then the breakdown would not necessarily have occurred. If one partner had been more thoughtful or sensitive : if the other had not had the particular problems that led to such and such an expression in interpersonal relationship ; if the interaction between them had begun on another footing which did not lay the groundwork for later resentment ; if the personalities of each had not developed over the years in quite the way they had ; if well, one could go on. The point is that the present moment is the sum of all these factors. Reconciliation might still be possible, but then again it might not be. On what basis is someone, from the outside, to judge whether reconciliation ought to be possible ? Where, 0 Rationalists, is this cool, objective measure, and who dares to apply it ? Only the persons in the situation can say for sure, and even they may differ.
And the question of children is a red herring. For some reason unknown to me, and most others involved in the very confused and confusing business of marriage-breakdown and divorce, the presence of children is considered to be a decisive argument against divorce. Graham Shaw, for instance, is willing to admit the legitimacy of the divorce of the childless, but not of couples with children. However, to those involved in the process of marriage-breakdown, the presence of children is, if not irrelevant, a subsidiary question. The knowing remarks about children preferring the devil they know to the devil they don't, even if based on unquestionable research data, are not compelling. Women sometimes feel more comfortable with violent spouses than with the prospect of facing the world alone for the first time. It is not a compelling reason to stay.
Certainly, children will be a factor in decisions about divorce but they do not materially alter the considerations for or against divorce, which have more to do with the possibility of life with Mrs X or Mr X or, mark you, the enhanced possibility of life with Mr Z or Ms Z.
And the latter choice is sometimes made, certainly, on a shallow basis, but if it begins shallowly, it's almost certain not to end that way if the persons involved are halfway sensitive to their own feelings.
The assumption behind the contrary supposition is simply that divorce is usually entered into for superficial reasons and, therefore, the existence of children will (ought to) provide a counterweight to typically shallow moral reasoning engaged in by people contemplating divorce - an intolerably arrogant position, as Jesus was quick to point out about throwing stones at adulterers.
In other words, it seems to me that the two writers who have indulged themselves in speculation about divorce have not, themselves, indulged in it, and if they had, perhaps their ruminations would have led them deeper, until, when they hit rock bottom, they would have recognized the futility of doing this sort of reasoning from on high. People are involved, as Jesus, to his credit, realized more often than we seem able to ; people with deep needs and feelings, with fears and expectations, and histories. And what is hid in those histories : ah ! that's what we so often miss when we look at them, stone in hand, seeing that they are men and women as other men and women, forgetting that they look at themselves from inside.
SOF MAGAZINE 6, SUMMER 1991 19 CONTRIBUTORS ERIC MACDONALD attended SOF III from his home in Canada where he is a parish priest in Mulgrave, Nova Scotia.