A Philosophical Fragment

PAGE 18 SPRING 1991 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE A PHILOSOPHICAL FRAGMENT introduced by Neville Morley The Greek philosopher Cypidon is less well known than his near-contemporary Socrates. He survives in just a few fragmentary (and largely uncomplimentary) anecdotes, and is generally accorded little more than a minor footnote in the history of thought. The reasons for this are fairly obvious - he tended to lose arguments on a regular basis, not a good advertisement for a practising philosopher. The success and reputation of Socrates, however dubious the logic which achieved them, bought his place in Western Civilisation's roll of honour. Failure with integrity is perhaps more morally purifying, a philosophical acceptance of the transience of human fame can be a psychological necessity as much as an intellectual stance.

As usual with Greek philosophical dialogues, the scene is a small tavern in one corner of the Athenian agora. Cypidon has just finished answering Gaian, a devoutly earnest young aristocrat, who had apparently asked a question about the existence of the gods. Some commentators suggest that this fragment might be a continuation of Cypidon's lost 'Galan Dialogue' on the same subject, said by contemporary sources to be something of a tour de force - even if, inevitably, it failed to convince Gaian himself. Simon, may perhaps be the Athenian cobbler in whose shop Socrates sometimes used to hold forth.

Cyp:... and so I must answer, yes and no. Or rather, no and yes.

Gai: In other words, no.

Cyp: Gaian, you are too hasty. True, I do not believe that they live, flesh and blood, as you and I, but they do have a most fearsome and undeniable existence in the minds of men.

Gai: That hardly seems like existence to me.

Cyp: It is enough to give them supreme power over us. 'Truth' is merely a word, is it not ? An idea, a thought, and yet it is powerful. So too the gods.

Gai: I don't accept that.

Cyp: Ah. I was afraid of that. On what grounds, my friend ?

Gai: Because I believe that the gods have ordained truth, and justice, and only an atheist, a mocker of the gods, could dare to call them 'mere words' !

Sim: For heaven's sake, hasn't he just explained that the gods don't exist ?

Gai: The gods consider him to be mistaken.

Cyp: Ah. Well, it all depends on one's selection of presuppositions ...

Sim: Some people wouldn't recognise a logical conclusion if it swallowed them. What I don't understand, learned Cypidon, is why you continue to attend the civic sacrifices, if they are no more than human ceremonies ?

Cyp: I'm glad you asked me that. Surely no-one would deny that the sacrifice is an important part of the city's life, the expression of our community, the foundation of our law and morality ? Does that change, merely because there isn't actually anyone up there to accept our offering ?

Sim: Well ... Bit pointless, isn't it ? Unproductive waste of time and money ? Religion is one big exercise in social indoctrination, after all, so once we've ditched the mumbo jumbo surely it's time to dump the whole structure ?

Gai: The structure is there because the gods have ordained it ! [The main dialogue ends here. The second fragment may form an epilogue.] Cyp: We do indeed live in a world of paradoxes. The gods do not exist and yet they should not be ignored. We must abandon our faith so that we can return to it again. Why don't I seem to be convincing anyone ? It would seem that it is easier to pass from belief to unbelief, or even vice versa, curious though that may seem, than to accept what seems to me to be the best of both worlds. If so, would my energies be better spent making Simon a second Gaian, or Gaian another Simon ? Or just have another drink ?

Introduced by Neville Morley.