Down by the River

And pray this prayer of ex-Father Tom Pemberton: “I think we must remake You. If we are to remake ourselves, we must remake You, Lord. We need a place to stand...” a TIM WOODCOCK reflects on Channel Four’s daily coverage of the biggest religious show on earth down by the river The Kumbh Mela: if you weren't aware of it before, you will be by now. 70 million people, half a million tents, 35 impromptu police stations and 8000 turd pickers go to make up the oldest and biggest religious festival in the world. It happens every 12 years and Hindus and other searchers flock to bathe in the purifying waters of the Ganges.

The sheer scale of the event is mind-blowing, and then add to this the exoticism: fortune-telling parrots, conjurors, the fug of drugs, bizarre feats of endurance, the material poverty, the spiritual richness. And, for the first time, TV crews in large numbers. Every weekday evening C4 has been showing a 10-minute programme on the events of the day.

I’m not an expert in this area but I don’t think there has ever been anything like this in religious broadcasting before. In televisual terms it is closer to 4 Go To Glastonbury than Songs of Praise. The bite-size programmes have been a joy to watch - both entertaining and informative. They are presented as “soft news”: people rather than issues; interviews and incidents; just a sprinkling of commentary.

And it makes great television.

Some have accused the Western media of voyeurism, broadcasting this phenomenon in all its weirdness with no understanding of what is going on. But India is one of the “,..fortune-telling parrots, conjurors, the fug of drugs, bizarre feats of endurance, the material poverty, the spiritual richness...” perhaps I mean indiscriminating. Within Hinduism, it seems, anyone can invent their own god or kind of devotion. There is no orthodoxy.

And you think how restrained and cerebral faith in the West has become.

There is a wonderful poem by Neil Rollinson, in A Spillage of Mercury, I think, that wrestles with this, with the strangeness, the attractiveness of this spirituality:

I like the monkey God, the God for toothache, the God for anything you like. Not the One God, the Thou shalt not God.

Sadhus contort themselves on the river bank.

Ever seen the Pope tie himself into a sheepshank? Or push a knotted handkerchief up one nostril while pulling it out of the other? Can the Archbishop of Canterbury syphon a glassful of water up his urethra then piss it out again?

No.

Rollinson idealises the spiritual traditions of India.

They are so much more “embodied” than our own. But Rollinson sheds no light on how those traditions could enliven our own. Perhaps they can’t: the Pope is not a Sadhu, he has no inclination to tie himself in to a sheepshank. Even if he did it wouldn’t indicate spiritual merit.

Sophisticated Christians regard most extraordinary places on earth, even without the filter of the media. C4, which brought us Eurotrash, Big Brother and other dubious pleasures, have not treated it like a freakshow. Their “take” on it all is neutral and respectful, if occasionally bemused.

For sure, they picked out extraordinary characters from the cast of 70 million - for instance Bhola Giri, who has held his arm in the air for twelve years, and Hathi Giri who will have his penis “broken” as part of a religious ceremony. And they have picked out storylines (will the Ganges be seriously eroded? Will the police intervene to keep the crowds under control?). But this is the usual way of making documentaries. You need characters, and storylines are necessary to make sense of such a massive event.

By revelling in the sights and sounds, the programmemakers missed the chance to interrogate pilgrims on their beliefs. So you sit in your armchair in Britain and see a clip of the Kumbh Mela and what do you think? You think how chaotic and mad it is. And how utterly inclusive - or World party!

Images from the Kumbh Mela devotion suspiciously these days. Christianity is a faith that has been shaped by reason - despite its often unreasonable and irrational claims - and the superstitions of earlier times have been replaced by a web of complex theological ideas. For better or worse, I’m not sure.

The absurdity of some of the goings-on at the Mela is a tacit acknowledgement of the irrational basis of faith: if religion is a human construct, let’s at least have an exuberant one. Bathing in the Ganges has a Christian counterpart - the waters of baptism - but I get the impression that SoFers wouldn't find it helpful in forging a post-Christian, post-modern version of faith. Is it because baptism needs a dogmatic explanation? Or because it represents popularist revivals? Or because dry intellectualism is threatened by the Water of Life?