A Cynic in the Network: Do Faith/Action Disjunctions Matter?

Stephen Warnes Diogenes the Cynic is reputed to have masturbated in public, as an expression of ... what ? His 'cynical' attitude to life ? His disdain for convention ?

Diogenes held worldly goods, including human repute, to be of no account. (In the quest for virtue, it is of very little help that one is held in repute among people.) He sought to be free from desire of the external goods that are the gift of fortune and are therefore precarious.

The Cynics of ancient Greece - among whom Diogenes was a leader - proposed that individuals should eschew what is independent of the will, or of our own efforts. "Only subjective goods - virtue, or contentment through resignation - are secure, and these alone, therefore, will be valued by the wise man." (Bertrand Russell, History oLWestern Philosophy. p 255) The principal question which I ask in this piece, and to which I can only give my own personal answer, is this :

Is it a form of moral and/or intellectual masturbation (sleight of hand !?) to say one thing and do another, regardless of disjunctions between the saying and the doing ?

I work as a parish priest in the Church of England ; and in that capacity I engage in liturgical performances, exercise pastoral care, perform certain administrative functions, and (the nub of the matter as far as the argument of this article is concerned) I preach and teach. In the parish, I neither preach nor teach the non-realist opinions which draw me to the Sea of Faith Network.

The people in the parish are satisfied if, through the style of liturgical performance and effectiveness of the pastoral care, they are able to feel 'an ache in the right place'. Church superiors are happy if, with the satisfaction of the parishioners and the efficiency of the administration, quietness abounds, and finance with it ! The Cynic is satisfied if the contentment of parish and diocese do not distract from the personal quest for creative human freedom.

This argument is consistent with the Cynic distinction between external goods which are the gift of fortune, and therefore precarious, and the subjective goods (virtue which holds worldly goods of no account) which alone are secure and therefore to be valued by the wise.

External or worldly goods such as ecclesiastical preferment or some 'party' appointment (e.g. a school governorship), are certainly precarious gifts of fortune.

Public conformism might attract the offer of these delights ; but the Cynic holds them of no account and seeks to be free of any desire for them. It is the desire for these attractions that enslaves because it instils an anxiety or fear that one may not attain them.

Bertrand Russell says of Cynicism that it was a doctrine "to appeal to weary men, in whom disappointment had destroyed natural zest. And it was certainly not a doctrine calculated to promote ... any useful activity except one of protest against powerful evil." (ibid) To protest against powerful evil is regarded as a virtue by many. There are those for whom it is an expression of virtue to "go boldly into the lions' den".

STEPHEN WARNES is a parish priest in Kent and formerly lectured in African Studies at the University of Natal. He is a member of the SOF Steering Committee.