, | the and the many DAVID PATERSON’s talk reported David began by asking "What is religion?", offering two defining quotations. The first was from an article by Guy Browning in the Guardian: "If religion is the opium of the masses, then it's the one drug-related issue that is clearing up fast... Finding religion is a way of giving your problems to someone else... Religions are all human creations, but they all hold out promises - mostly of the sort that can't be tested in a court of law... All good religions insist that other religions are mistaken - and of course they are absolutely right’.
And Mohandas Gandhi: "True religion is the greatest thing in life and in the world.
And therefore it has been exploited the most. And those who have seen the exploiters and the exploitation and missed the reality naturally get disgusted with the thing itself." So, David asked, is religion the greatest thing in life and in the world, or is it a pernicious drug which promises impossible things and delivers only hatred and unpleasantness? Or is it somehow both? "All of these great, wonderful human activities, the crown of human achievement, lead us to truth and beauty, love and wisdom - and to hatred, exploitation, cruelty and destruction. Human beings, individually and corporately, are both immensely creative and beautifying and also self-destructive and polluting”.
The key is the complex thing called consciousness. David quoted from Julian Jaynes’ The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind, where Jaynes argued that consciousness springs from the two-chamber nature of our brains, giving us a built-in dialogue with ourselves. "As civilisation is born and cities grow," said David, "leadership and the internal voices are vested in divine beings, first on earth and then in heaven. "Language is the mechanism for this amazing development. If you need internalised instructions about what to do in a new and unexpected situation when your leader is not at hand, you need to hear your leader's voice in your head - or, later in the development, the voice of your god. Religion, indeed, is a product of language. Don Cupitt and Julian Jaynes both think so, so it must be true! This language-dependent facility for internal dialogue develops, and that's what consciousness is.” We do many things un-consciously. But the wonder is that we can watch our consciousness at work. We can stand outside ourselves and look at it. "One of the first explorations of what that implies is found in the Odyssey.
Odysseus is a liar, with a deep aversion to telling the story straight. Why tell the truth when a figment of your imagination is better? The ability to lie is a function of consciousness. "The Odyssey is a story of adventure and violence.
Odysseus is bloodthirsty and vindictive, a real macho man: a liar like Jeffrey Archer, licensed to kill like James Bond.
And the world of the Odyssey gives rise many years later to the world of Socrates and Plato. The basis of Western thought has all the glory that was Greece, and the limitations too. The last 2500 years have been a great voyage, full of incident, full of danger, full of beauty, full of profound insights, immense leaps in technical ability, full of cruelty and destruction. "Last month I went to an event put on by Tara, a British drama and dance group whose members are of Indian origin. They imagined a meeting between Odysseus and Rama, and told each story, the Odyssey and the Ramayana, in music, dramatic action and dance. "Two journeys... But the greatest contrast the company portrayed was that the Ramayana is not merely or mainly about adventures. It's a journey of the heart. There are gods and demons, but the divine character is primarily in Rama himself. This is a spiritual battle between good and evil." Written at roughly the same time, probably based on earlier oral tradition, the two stories occupy very different thought-worlds. The Ramayans depicts "a world not of fierce and bitter struggle to survive and excel, to win and to dominate, but ‘everything that is beautiful and sad, the very atmosphere is purifying.’ "The predominant emotion is pain - ennobling, purifying, satisfying. The Ramayana is inward, spiritual, mysterious, full of word-pictures which reveal the sufferings of the various characters." In the advertisements for 2001: A Ramayan Odyssey, the Tara company asked: "When Rama speaks, will Odysseus hear? And finally, when all the battles are fought and done, what is the true meaning of love, and loss, and home?" David asked: "Are we able to value the deep diversity of what it means to be human? Can we preserve the integrity of the vast variety of cultures the world has developed? Can we learn from them all, respect them all? There are vast philosophical questions here, but for some it's stark and bleak. What does it mean to be British Asian? How will the insights of the Indian subcontinent - Hinduism, the Sanatan Dharma - develop in a Western country? Buddhism in the West is already reinventing itself. Perhaps most important of all, what is the future for British Muslims? "To study the human condition is to open up our understanding of the religious traditions which have brought us, individually and collectively, to where we are. To explore religious faith as a human creation is to explore what humanity is, what we have made ourselves. What I am." David gave us his own story: undergraduate rejection of the religion he had been brought up in, flirtation with the Evangelicals and the Jesuits, and a resolve to "remain open to as wide a variety of influences as possible... Already I had decided that 'existence' was not a valid predicate for God.
Hither you meant that God was the source of existence or you didn't use the term God at all - except to describe how other people use language. What encapsulates your joys, sorrows, hopes, fears, ideals and regrets, you can personify and call God, or not. The distinction between theist and atheist is false, or at best trivial." Ordained, and appointed vicar of St Peter's, Loughborough, "I watched the arrival of people from Panjab and Gujurat. Hindus and Sikhs became our neighbours... It was completely natural to extend the ecumenical breadth I had enjoyed to opening up understanding across the faiths." One result was a monthly inter-faith discussion which has been going on since 1980. David has also made time to work with Muslims and Hindus in Gujarat. "In Britain, it is possible to treat inter-faith relationships as a sideline. In India, good relationships between the faiths can be a matter of life or death." David treated us to a selection of readings from the Vedas and the Upanishads: ‘That is perfect. This is perfect Perfect comes from perfect Take perfect from perfect, the remainder is perfect May peace and peace and peace be everywhere.’ "If Sea of Faith is serious about exploring and promoting religion as a human creation, it needs to widen its horizons.
Most of the time we are still arguing about things we've inherited from Greece and Palestine. They need to be put in context. There's a whole load of stuff from the past we haven't even looked at... Religion is a human creation because it is a consequence of our genetic make-up. We should be glad and rejoice in it. "And our task is to take responsibility for it. It's a wonderful achievement in which every culture on earth has been involved. It has liberated and inspired millions. And it has ruined people's lives, enslaved them, crippled them with guilt, exploited their gullibility, reduced them to idiots with its false promises and shallow dogmatism. But it's ours. No-one else is responsible for it. And if we want to survive as a living species we've got to take that responsibility seriously. As Hans Kung wrote, 'No survival without world peace. No world peace without peace within and between the religions. No peace between the religions without dialogue.’ "Criticism of SoF often points to the damage that human arrogance is doing to the world. 'And what you're doing’, they say to us, 'is to go along with this. Not only do we think that the minerals, plants and animals, the earth, the water and the air are ours for the taking, but you even deny the restraining hand of God en our activities. The earth is no longer the Lord's but ours, and even the Lord is our own invention. All you are doing is colluding with the spirit of the age, which we can clearly see is destroying us all.’ "But I believe that to realise that God is a human creation can - indeed must - liberate us from our delusions of grandeur. We have created the God who puts all things under our feet. We have no-one to blame but ourselves...
What Sea of Faith asks, I think, is that we should realise the wonder and the fragility of the universe, and take responsibility for it.” More stories, more insights, more quotations... Then David finished with this: "I don't think there are many common factors among the religions. Some version of the Golden Rule perhaps, but even then the assumptions are very different... But we're not looking for common factors, we're building up common multiples - what you find when you pool your resources of insight, and the picture is illuminated with more and more different colours of light. There is no irreducible minimum.
No self-existing God, no Grand Narrative, no objective Truth. "I think the future lies with those who can set out on a voyage of exploration which finishes, with a wealth of new respect for life, at the place we started - in our own lives. I would like to think that Sea of Faith will play a significant part in this”. "..eand the rest’ Conference wasn't, and never is, just the plenary sessions and principal talks. Some workshop titles: "The Wider Sea:
SoF and World Religions", "Modern Pagans and SoF", "The Eucharist and Eschatology", "Close Encounters of the Arty Kind", "If Religion is the Answer, What's the Problem?”, "Seeing the Invisible", "Sacred Ritual", "The Poetry of Earth", "Being Good: Ethics and Morals", "Jesus the Teacher: Was He One of Us?", "Problems of being an Atheist", "Our Environmental Response’, "Exploring and Expressing our Religious Nature", "Castles and Creeds"...
There were 13 base groups, circle dancing, an experimental eucharist and a Quaker quiet time, a "Zeusfree Zone" perambulation of the Botanic Gardens, a slide show and a "Creation Celebration". After a stimulating panel session chaired by Alison Webster, the conference ended with an extended epilogue which included songs by the conference choir, readings (including one by novelist Wendy Perriam, which she introduced by saying "I'm best known for writing explicit sex scenes, but...") and a sketch called Brief Encounter in which God and the Devil met up accidentally and discussed nonrealism.
The SPCK ran a splendid bookshop, Ronald Pearse ran the SoF stall, and John Pearson administered quietly and effectively behind the scenes. The Canadian SnowStar Institute hosted a lively reception at which Del Stewart, director, and David Galston, president, spoke of their affinity with Sea of Faith. The bar did good business - two barrels of real ale were soon emptied, and a wine lake was disposed of. Altogether, the fellowship of the wholly human spirit was wonderfully in evidence. Here's to the next time!