Hypothetical Questions

Our conference workshop on the "10 hypotheses” produced a robust debate on the merits and demerits of the propositions put forward by the editor as "a provisional statement of what we are for". First DAVID BOULTON responded to DUNCAN PARK‘s criticisms of the hypothesis in the July magazine, then Duncan re-presented his case. What follows are edited summaries of the two presentations to hypo or not to hypo?

When I first published the 10 hypotheses, I wrote that they "won't be a Sea of Faith creed, official or unofficial...

We're not going to put them to the vote or ask for any formal endorsement. What they will be is the editor's best effort at producing a provisional statement of what we are for, from which members can take what they find useful, leave what they find useless, and add what they think is missing... If anyone cites it as the definitive or ‘official’ summation of SoF thinking, they'll be misusing and misunderstanding it".

Despite this, Duncan insists that the 10 hypotheses are "a creed-in waiting... infected with the credal virus that could develop into full-blown dogma and big-time discussion stopper”. They are "a manifesto masquerading as a debate... If it looks like a creed, sounds like a creed and smells like a creed, then it is a creed".

Leave aside the angry, adversarial, rather unSoFish language: "infected with virus", "masquerading", "smells" (and, by the way, you should see some of the invective I persuaded Duncan to leave out!). I want to say the only reader who can genuinely mistake these propositions for a creed is the reader who has not grasped the difference Nobody need smuggle humanism into SoF through a side door: it's been there from the start between propositions put forward as dogma, and propositions put forward as hypotheses.

A hypothesis is defined by the OED as a proposition made "merely as a basis for reasoning and argument" or as ''a starting point for further discussion". A creed sets out those propositions regarded as essential truths to which all members of a credal institution are required under discipline to give assent. Unlike a credal statement, a proposition put forward as a hypothesis is a suggestion to be argued, tested, refined, or discarded. Only those who cannot understand or refuse to understand the difference will confuse them.

Duncan has another objection. It's that "there's nothing wrong with any of the 10 Hypos". They are "self-evident" and "supremely inoffensive". They are "blindingly THE CASE FOR THE DEFENCE BY DAVID BOULTO! obvious" and plain dull. To argue with them would be "like arguing with hygiene or justice or the twelve times table".

That being so, it's a bit of a mystery why he is so offended by what he finds "blindingly obvious" and "supremely inoffensive". Dull maybe. I cannot match Duncan's colourful prose. But there are good reasons why the hypos don't excite an orgasmic "Yes!" from readers.

While there is a proper place for shock tactics and uninhibited passion, I'm not sure that this is the best style for propositions setting out ideas for discussion, debate, and testing against experience. There's a time for linguistic inebriation and a time for restraint and reflection. My aim was clarity, not verbal pyrotechnics.

But we've yet to reach Duncan's biggest beef. The real crime of the 10 Hypos is their unabashed humanism: "Humanism campaigning to be the ‘inverted comma’ orthodoxy of Sea of Faith"... "this humanist relic infected with the credal virus"... and so on.

Let's get a grip. There is not a mention of "humanism" or even "religious humanism" in these "blindingly obvious" and "supremely inoffensive" hypos. To suggest that they represent an attempt to foist an alien ideology from outside, an entryist threat by Quaker Humanists or the BHA or whatever, is paranoid. Is Sea of Faith humanist? Of course it is! But nothing new there! Sea of Faith embraced a form of humanism, a religious humanism, when it chose to define itself as an association of people in sympathy with the aim of "exploring and promoting religious faith as a human creation".

Nobody need smuggle humanism into SoF through a side door: it's been there from the start. Listen to Don Cupitt exactly ten years ago at our 1991 conference: "We shall be religious humanists, making believe". And Cupitt again, at last year's conference: "We urgently need... a new this-worldly and democratic religious humanism", which he defined as "our human way of first imagining new values and a better world, and then actually working to bring them about". And again, at our conference on religious humanism: "Christianity is, and always was, religion that is trying to turn itself into radical humanism".

Humanism has long been seen by the traditional churches as the arch-enemy of faith, the very spawn of embedded in the myths, stories, and lived experience of Satan. But I do find it puzzling that the same fear and the great religious traditions. dread of religious humanism is so marked even among They want to explore together what this means in some members of Sea of Faith. "Religious humanism" is of modern, secular society; how it relates to religious course only one way of describing the set of ideas which practice, personal relationships, and political, social and define us: "nonrealism" is another, and Duncan's own economic organisation. They know their faith is wholly "post-realism" yet another. There's a place for all of them, human, and although they are inherently suspicious of and the 10 hypos actually steer clear of all of them! proselytising, they want to promote a human faith which Sea of Faith has no position, says Duncan: "as long as they themselves have found a glorious liberation. Most of we have no position we can inhabit (and subvert) all them do know a creed from a hypothesis, avoiding the positions and our enemies can fire their bullets into the one like the plague, and using the other as one tool fog...". But I don't want to spend my time and energy among many to focus their explorations. defending an undefined fog of assorted misfits who So, Icommend and defend the hypotheses - or, more march only to mark the spot, lest they actually get precisely, I defend and commend the use of hypothetical anywhere, and speak out only to assert loudly and clearly propositions as a tool for exploring, debating and that they have absolutely nothing to say. experimenting with ideas. For heaven's sake let's not be I don't think our Network is like that at all. I think it's a afraid to think things through, arrive at provisional group of thinking women and men who know that the jig conclusions, and test them by experience, reason and is up so far as supernatural religion and objective gods imagination. That doesn't preclude exploration , it is and spirits are concerned, but who want to find ways of exploration. No-one is telling anyone what to think or being good, living compassionately and building a better believe. "Come, let us reason together", said the Lord, world, knowing they have only human resources to draw who knew a thing or two about exploring the way, the on, but that those human resources include the wisdom truth and the life.

THE CASE FOR THE PROSECUTIOI While I heartily support any initiative to extend and would be less. Unfortunately, the Hypos attempt much improve the effectiveness of this Network, I believe the 10 more. I believe this will create a barrier to many people.

Hypotheses are a serious step in the wrong direction. I Only those inclined towards the philosophical position believe the Hypos are wrong in principle for the (religious humanism) the Hypos adopt will feel inclined following reasons: to take up membership and the Network will become They are unnecessary. As far as I know, no angst- self-selecting and sterile. ridden cry "who are we?" has gone up from among us. They are presumptuous. Like any set of principles, On the contrary the cry "don't tell us who we are!" still articles or doctrines, the Hypos must have a perspective. echoes through the Network as its most defining If we are going for a theological colour scheme, the characteristic. Sofers do not have a collective identity question is which one? Why not Christian Buddhism, problem because we don't have a collective identity. On Charismatic Atheism, Radical Paganism, Solar the principle of "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" we should Salvationism or any other common denominator that leave well alone. I believe the Hypos are a contrived could emerge from any strand of the membership. It response to a non-existent crisis foisted on us from "out there". No matter how many inverted 5 ‘i a 4 . commas we use, the "real" world will take them A hierarchy of orthodox Soferism will un-nuanced and tabloid and give our happily emerge that will use the Hypos as a tool to anarchic membership a walloping great label to control "her esy" and le gitimi se its own carry around.

They are misleading. If they are offered asan agenda aid to identification for those who want to EE know what we are about, I say, they don't.

They are tools of control. A hierarchy of "orthodox" Soferism will emerge that will use the Hypos as a tool to control "heresy" and legitimise its own agenda. True believers will eventually hold up the Hypos to justify ever more extreme interpretations and create a "one-ofus" elitism within the Network. This will make insiders of outsiders and intimidate those who are proceeding at their own pace to whatever self-realisation may occur.

The Hypos will become a means of political control over the Network. The publications, conferences, committees et al will reflect their "truth" and those who promote them most vehemently will be our glorious leaders.

The Hypos are wrong in principle because they locate the cheerfully lost. They bring us back to a sheepfold particular iterest ie a edice where, after the dubious joy of being found we prepare webmaster (and new SoF St to get herded, fleeced and finally slaughtered like every Overend. sheep that isn't able to outwit some interfering shepherd. | Since I believe the Hypos are wrong in principle their ae ii Pecan Sor content is obviously a priori immaterial. However it nz features SoF articles nd does reveal what I consider to be a disturbing ideological : members, a complete arch current in the tide of Sea of Faith that runs counter to the files of speakers such as Jack Spong. vision that first inspired many of us.

The contrast between the Hypos Heritage view of The SoF Australia (SoFia) home page, www www.sof-in- religion and Don Cupitt's re-launch of "Kingdom faith" as incandescent "solar living" is hard to exaggerate (indeed, they could be its solar opposite). Instead of a laboratory for "Solar Faith" the Hypos make the Network sound like a faculty for the sociology of religion or an application for an Arts Council grant - exploring religion as a cultural artefact. It is a view of religion, rather than a view from religion. A description of a living faith by someone who hasn't been there for people who aren't going there. If Sea of Faith has any "function" (or mission) it is to show how creatively real post-realist Don Cupie and David Han religion can be "done" in the post-modern world.

Sofers are the first solar-folk to survive the scary outsidelessness of spiritual space - where there is no "right" way up. This makes Soferism very exciting stuff.

However, in my view, the Hypos, in principle and in content, reduce Don's solar bang to a rather sad whimper.