New Humanist, 47 Theobalds Rd, London, WC1X 8SP email: shirley.dent@rationalist.org.uk As the trenches were fed with carcasses and smoke filled our skies and TV screens, ALISON WEBSTER offered this meditative reflection for Maundy Thursday and Good Friday It is the Passover of the Lord. For I will pass through the land of Egypt that night, and I will strike down every firstborn in the land of Egypt, both human beings and animals; on all the gods of Egypt I will execute judgements:
I am the Lord. The blood shall be a sign for you on the houses where you live: when I see the blood I will pass over you, and no plague shall destroy you when I strike the land of Egypt (Exodus 12).
There have been lots of disgusting scenes in our national life lately. Who will forget in a hurry the black smoke of burning carcasses as sheep and cattle, diseased and healthy, smoulder in trenches? Or the pictures of the cadavers of cattle before they are burned: stiff yet bloated, legs in the air in a gesture of utter victimhood. Ungainly. Undignified. Ugly. These are the once-living beings which, though most of us avoided it most of the time, we could have related to, now dead and objectified by the media and by us as consumers of it. Their sorry end a direct result of desperate human policies which seem most of the time to be based on little more than guesswork: shots, literally, in the dark as we attempt to burn our way out of this foot and mouth plague; slaughter our way beyond this curse. Life feels medieval as we resort to near superstition: ring church bells at midday, wade through disinfectant. Set up border-crossings of straw.
He had no form or majesty that we should look at him, nothing in his appearance that we should desire him. He was despised and rejected by others; a man of suffering and acquainted with infirmity; and as one from whom others hide their faces he was despised, and we held him of no account. Like a lamb that is led to the slaughter, and like a sheep that before its shearers is silent, so he did not open his mouth. By a perversion of justice he was taken away. Who could have imagined his future? (Isaiah 52).
As if that were not enough, the TV camera lens has roved more widely, exploring the underlying causes of the spread of this disease. Suddenly we are inside an abattoir, watching carcasses being sliced deftly by well-practiced hands, the meat now almost black in colour, the commentary repeating words which themselves create images of horror: spinal chord, offal. Then finally, worst of all, we are back in that hell-hole warehouse in Leicestershire with those piles of chicken body-parts, yellow and decomposing and apparently, before the scam was foiled, on their way back into the human food chain.
Sorry to go on like this, but I think you'll see that this is not gratuitous. But let’s change the subject for a moment.
When I was 16 I joined in with Student Community Action at my school. This involved volunteering each week to join half a dozen others to help run the local Gateway Club for adults with learning disabilities. At first this felt to me like a strange and alien world. I struggled with strong emotional and physical reactions to this world which I never spoke of at the time for fear of censure, but which I have come to appreciate as extremely important.
I began to notice that however hungry I was when I left school in the minibus, once I arrived at the club, my appetite evaporated, only to be replaced by a mild, barely perceptible, nausea. OK, the whole place smelt very strongly of tea, which I hate, and we had to distribute this to the club-members from huge teapots. And “tea” was cheese-and-salad-cream sandwiches and angel cake, neither of which is my favourite. But my physical reactions were about more than that, though I never analysed at the time exactly what was going on.
About five years later, the feeling returned. This time it stayed with me for several months. The cause? Falling in love with another woman, and embarking on a lesbian relationship. The inability to eat properly lasted the best part of a year, and when I forget that this ever happened, I need only flip back the pages of the photo-album to see a 7-stone me. This was not an eating disorder. It was shame.
It was entirely unexpected and, worse, inexplicable for one who had never had an intellectual, moral or theological problem with same-sex relationships. Coupled with that, of course, was the realisation that suddenly I had become one of a category of people who cause in others feelings of revulsion and disgust. I cannot explain to anyone who hasn’t experienced it what that feels like.
And so I learned how congealed social values write themselves on and in our own individual bodies in a very powerful way. And that this is the case, crucially, whatever we believe about the rights or wrongs of those social values. Our assent or dissent is irrelevant, at least at first, in the face of the power of the body politic.
My God, my God, why have you forsaken me? And are so far from my cry and from the words of my distress? O my God, I cry in the daytime, but you do not answer; by night as well, but I find no rest. 1am a worm and no man, scorned by all and despised by the people (Psalm 22).
So when survivors of abuse talk about the physical effects of that abuse, the inexplicable feelings of shame for that which was not their fault, I know what level this is working at. The corporate body says that this is defilement, this is impurity. Just as the corporate body politic says that those with a learning disability are somehow beyond the boundary of what it means to be human, and lesbians and gay men muck up male/female dualities, so need to be expunged. This is all part of the same picture.
And it’s a picture which I subsequently got sociological and philosophical help with. I learned from Julia Kristeva’s Powers of Horror: An Essay on Abjection that there is a category of stuff which is considered neither subject nor object, but abject. “It is not”, she says, “lack of cleanliness or health that causes abjection but what disturbs identity, system, order. What does not respect borders, positions, rules. The in-between, the ambiguous, the composite.” The loathsome, she says, is that which disobeys classification and does not respect boundaries. So the aspects of human physicality which we traditionally find repulsive - blood, saliva, excreta, urine, semen, are deemed to be “marginal stuff”, because in issuing forth they have traversed the boundary of the body.
In Purity and Danger, Mary Douglas puts forward her now famous definition of “dirt” as “matter out of place”.
That which is constructed by society as ‘dirty’ or “polluted” is not so because of any intrinsic qualities of its own: it is a relative concept. Shoes are not dirty in themselves, but they are if you put them on the kitchen table. If the chicken parts were on their way to the incinerator, we wouldn’t have had so much of a problem with them. What was repulsive was the fact that we were told they were on their way into chicken pies that we might . just eat. Little different, in fact, from eating shit. They were meant for waste, but were becoming “food” again.
Peter said to [Jesus] “You will never wash my feet.” Jesus answered, “Unless I wash you, you have no share with me”. Simon Peter said to him, “Lord, not my feet only but also my hands and my head!”. Jesus said to him, “One who has bathed does not need to wash, except for the feet, but is entirely clean.” (John 13).
The other key thing I learn from Mary Douglas is this: “The quest for purity is pursued by rejection. It is part of our condition that the purity for which we strive and sacrifice so much turns out to be hard and dead as a stone when we get it. Purity is the enemy of change, of ambiguity, of compromise [yet] the yearning for rigidity is in us all. It is part of our human condition to long for hard lines and clear concepts.” So we recognise as neurotic those who have an excessive interest in cleanliness and tidiness. We recognise as obsessive those with an over-the-top concern for maintaining rigid boundaries around Christianity. We know that, paradoxically, this undermines faith. The comment that such people need to “get a life” is not merely idiomatic.
He does not despise nor abhor the poor in their poverty; neither does he hide his face from them (Psalm 22).
The Lord Jesus, on the night when he was betrayed, took a loaf of bread, and when he had given thanks, he broke it and said, “This is my body that is for you. Do this in remembrance of me”. In the same way he took the cup also, after supper, saying, “This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink it, in remembrance of me.” (1 Corinthians 11).
It is the function of religious ritual, apparently, to take that which is abomination and turn it into a force for good. So pollutions are often used in renewal rites. Blood afforded protection during the original Passover. The broken body of Christ is that which saves us, symbolised in the Eucharist by the eating of it, and the drinking of his blood.
Looked at sociologically, there is much in the passion narratives across the gospels to ponder on. It’s all about physicality and body fluids. Jesus, at various points in the story, is anointed with perfume; offered a kiss in the wrong context. He weeps over Jerusalem and sweats in Gethsemane. He shares food and wine and washes feet.
He is spat upon by soldiers, beaten til he bleeds, slapped round the face and crowned with thorns. He is taken outside the city boundary to be crucified, is given sour wine on a hyssop stem to drink at the point of death, and after death his side is pierced so that blood and water can flow. All this is brutally embodied and underlines the humanity of Christ. “The Passion narrative...is all about physicality and body fluids” Sticking with sociology for a minute - although disciplinary boundaries are blurring - is this not the story of the greatest creative and life-changing boundarytransgression that ever happened: that between the divine and human? Hardly surprising, if that’s the case, that the Good Friday story is the repulsive bit which we find hard to tell and hard to hear. As many have said, we find it easier to skip to Easter day, when all is washed and clean again. Better still, skip straight to the ascension so we can forget about bodies altogether - and forget that this disgusting boundary-transgression ever happened. God’s back in his heaven, and we're still down here, and the incarnation is just a bit of theological abstraction.
But we are told by the psalmist that God does not hide his face from those despised and abhorred by others. And of the suffering servant, repulsive as he was, Isaiah asks us, who could have imagined his future? According to the Easter story, then, it is in facing up to that which repels us, and living in the creative space which is that of boundary transgression, that - to coin a phrase - we get a life.
Alison Webster is social responsibility officer in the diocese of Worcester. These reflections were written for a diocesan Easter event. Alison will resume her Beachcomber column next issue.