45 – Religious Humanism

Editorial

This issue of SOF is a special number containing all five papers prepared for our religious humanism conference last September.

Normal service will be resumed in March.

Don Cupitt on Faith down under 23 Miles Howarth outlines the aims of the Develpment Trust 22 Tate Britain's huge Blake exhibition has shown that the poet, painter, engraver, radical and heretic divides opinion no less than he did (for the few who then knew his work) two centuries ago.

Germaine Greer finds his illustrations "slimey". Don't his muscular men and angels, women and spirits, remind us of those Charles ] Atlas ads - "You too can have a body like mine, or your money back"? Even his tyger, tyger, burning bright, looks like a painful cross between a cat and a cow. Waldemar Januszczak thinks he was barking mad. Didn't the poor fellow imagine he saw a treeful of angels in Peckham Rye, and the When modern rationalists scoff things antinomian (against authority) tradition, helped inspire and envigorate postmodern counterculture. He coined "New Age" and "doors of perception". His imaginative insistence that the human and the divine are one did more than the academic liberal theologians ever did to light up a gospel of religious humanism.

Imagination, of course, is the key to Blake.

Reason enslaved, imagination liberated. Reason he took to be the bloodless scientist's insistence on reducing an infinitely wondrous, magical world to measurement, numbers, formulae - "unweaving the rainbow", as his admirer Keats put it. Imagination, on the other hand, was the creator of all things. In the beginning, and ever thereafter, the human imagination created the human that, in seeing his angels and talking to Biblical prophets, Blake was clearly imagining world. Imagination was divine.

When modern rationalists scoff that, in seeing his angels and talking to Biblical prophets, Blake what Blake was doing. face of God peering through his kitchen window?

Didn't he converse with Ezekiel on a ramble through Soho?

But it seems that two hundred years of mockery have failed to dent a widespread intuitive sense of the man's extraordinary genius. The present comprehensive exhibition was preceded by a smaller one devoted to artists influenced by Blake - an astonishing number, from his own times to our own. His poetry has inspired modern poets and delighted children discovering poetry for the first time. (Poet Adrian Mitchell says he loves Blake "more than any other person I've never met"). His rage at the nastiness, brutishness and shortness of the lives of the poor, and at what the new industrial capitalism was doing to mark their faces with weakness and woe, inspired the school of humanist marxism which lives on in the work of Christopher Hill and E P Thompson. His celebration of passionate love and the body, coupled with his robust reassertion of the | | things, they unwittingly hit the nail on the head. That is exactly was clearly imagining things, they unwittingly hit the nail on the head. That is exactly what Blake was doing, and it is exactly what Blake knew he was doing. Asked where his visions came from, he tapped his head: they were his eee own imaginings. Did he believe in the God who peered through his kitchen window?

Of course he did. How could he deny his own imagination? But "all deities reside in the human breast", and his God was no exception. When Blake died, his friend George Richmond closed his eyes “to keep the vision in". Richmond too knew that our visions are the products of our own subjectivity - and all the more magnificent and mysterious for that.

Blake said that when he looked at the moon he saw not just a round thing shaped like a guinea but "a company of the heavenly host... singing Holy!

Holy! Holy!". He despaired of those who failed to see beyond the material, outward appearance. He saw a world in a grain of sand, heaven in a wild flower, and the glory of God in the human form divine.

Like Gerrard Winstanley a century-and-a-half before him, Blake refused to bow down to the God of the Bible and the churches, who was to hima "thou-shalt-not" tyrant, and therefore the very devil. editorial Hobsons Farm, Dent, Cumbria LA10 5RF Fs ty cera SK EERIE i In 1809 Blake staged his only one-man exhibition. It attracted no buyers and one reviewer, who dismissed it as "a farrago of nonsense".

Blake died in poverty.

Nearly two centuries later, Tate Britain 1 proclaims that Blake lives. | Hi u An etching of Samuel Colling’s “May Day in London”, made by Blake in 1784 His was a God of "thou shalt". This affirming God was not separate from humankind but was incarnated in humanity. Blake's God simply was "Mercy, Pity, Peace and Love", the divine virtues which were inescapably and wholly human: “For Mercy has a human heart, Pity a human face, And Love the human form divine, And Peace a human dress.” So that: "Where Mercy, Peace and Pity dwell There God is dwelling too.” For Blake this was not a philosophical proposition offered for analytical debate by academics and cerebral sophisticates. It was an imaginative leap which both fuelled his anger that the world was as it was and motivated him to do what he could through his art and imagination to mend it. Hence, he vowed that he would not cease from mental fight, nor would his sword sleep in his hand, till he had played his part in building Jerusalem in England's green and pleasant land.

In 1809 Blake staged his only one-man exhibition. It attracted no buyers and one reviewer, who dismissed it as "a farrago of nonsense". Blake died in poverty. Nearly two centuries later, Tate Britain proclaims that Blake lives.

William Blake continues at Tate Britain, London until February 11. q eee SPECIAL FEATURE religious and! & 3 * What happens when religion and humanism = — ™. meet in postmodernity? When "religion as a ii human creation" catches the eye of humanism as a religious enterprise?

For over a year now I have followed the Sea of Faith movement with great interest, reading Don Cupitt's books, and subscribing to the magazine. I have come to realise that nonrealism is a force of great revelation, the most significant response possible to the postmodern human condition. However, to lead a religious life endowed with these insights seems to pose two sets of problems.

Firstly, is it possible to remain a close member of a religious group which believes primarily in realist doctrines? Although I can remain friendly with evangelical, literalist Christians, I find true dialogue uncomfortable because of their rigid acceptance of notions such as heaven and hell, or divine intervention in prayer. There is a strong temptation not to offend, and I suspect that most followers of the movement find difficulty in proselytising. Should the Sea of Faith act like a spiritual yeast, fermenting the inertness of all categories of belief, or will it be forced, by its own radical nature, into a sectarian corner?

The second problem is that of action in the world.

Realist religious belief has often been associated with certitude and vehemence, often violently imposing its own particular form of meaning in those cultures where it has flourished. Nevertheless, the conviction with which realist believers have asserted their values has often radically transformed the lives of individuals and societies - think of Methodism, or the Salvation Army. Is there not a danger that the Sea of Faith might become an oasis for quietism, a meditation on the cloud of unknowingness? Living and responding to others in this world of signs will require a great spiritual discipline.

— Tony Knight, Beverley

Patti Whaley Letters Editor SOF 145 Petherton Road London N5 2RS email 101335.3561 @compuserve.com No tree-huggers I very much approve in theory of the idea of SoF getting more involved in some sort of activity , but I fear SoF might end up another venue for veggie tree-huggers who want a world all pink fluffy bunnies and that wouldn't suit old Telegraph-reading me. So my SoF days may be numbered.

The Daily Express recently reported that "All Europeans are similar genetically... Most differences are cultural" ("Our European Blood Brothers", 10 November 2000). Can I suggest that SoF could look deeper at the great significance of cultural differences to human society? If it is true that scientifically and rationally there is no difference between a Serb or a Bosnian, a Christian and a Jew, or an Orangeman and a Republican, this suggests that far from cultural differences being a superficial layer that can easily be wiped off by a bit of education and folk singing, in fact the culture we are born to or choose to adopt goes very deep and may be of more significance than mere genetics.

— Jane Baker, Fishponds, Bristol

Save the planet I am delighted by the editorial suggestion that the Network should extend its essential writing and talking activities to embrace action on important issues of common interest ("Let a Hundred Flowers Bloom", SOF, November 2000). It would be good to see the Network cooperating with others in support of measures to save the planet from human depredation. That really is a vital issue!

— D. Ross Maddocks, Crawley

D. Ross MADDOcKSs 25 Lambourne Close, Crawley RH10 6JW Fall and redemption Don Cupitt's reference to the invention of the Grand Narrative myth of history as Fall and Redemption rang bells ("Christianity after the Church", SOF, November 2000). In The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind, Julian Jaynes dates the development of consciousness and the beginning of the death of the gods to the same period, three millennia ago. Jayne's thesis leads to religion as "our communal way of reimagining and reinventing ourselves, and projecting our values", in Cupitt's words.

This can be developed. In The Chalice and the Blade, Riane Eisler develops the dominator and partnership models of culture and traces the latter back six or seven millennia to the early civilisation of Old Europe in Italy, Greece and Turkey. This was generally non-violent and gender-holistic. It began to crumble five millennia ago with the invasions of patriarchal, pastoral peoples from the Russian steppes. The results are with us now in patriarchy, dominance and control, the rape of the earth and global capitalism. We look for redemption, not only in a post-Christian, post-Marxist culture but also, remembering the parable of the seven devils, in a postglobal, post-capitalist culture in which there is true equality.

— John MacDonald Smith, Evesham, Worcs

REv. JOHN MACDONALD SMITH 38 Main Road, Norton, Evesham, Worcs WR11 4T God and the nonrealist T should like to respond to statements two and four of David Boulton’'s hypotheses ("Ten Hypotheses, SOF, November 2000). The assertion that all deities, even "the divine, the transcendent and the ultimate" are human creations and do not exist in any way as independent entities is in accord with many statements which I have read elsewhere in SoF publications, which suggest that Sea of Faith members, almost by definition, do not believe in God.

Now the aim of the Sea of Faith network is "to explore and promote religious faith as a human creation". I want to stress the difference between "God" and "religious faith". Ram Prasad, in his talk at the 1999 Leicester conference, separated non-realism from antirealism. In Prasad's understanding, antirealism represents the position that both God and religious faith are human constructs, whereas non-realism allows that there may be a God, but that religious faith and practice are human creations.

Iam a non-realist in Prasad's sense; religious dogmas are man-made, our ideas about God as loving, just etc. are what we think he/she/it ought to be - our ideas, not divine revelation. I do not believe in God because I have been told to, or been brought up to, or because my reason demands it; I believe that God exists because I have experienced something which I cannot explain, but which seems to be beyond the human and physical. As Tagore puts it: "What I have seen is unsurpassable...here have I caught sight of him that is formless." Maybe the supernatural is simply that which is not yet explained in natural terms.

Religious experiences may indeed prove to be aspects of our psychological make-up. But until then I am justified in believing that they are experiences of the divine. And I feel that there must be other members in SoF who have experienced something which, for want of a better word, they call "the Divine" or "the Transcendent" or "God".

If it is true that the Network is "a safe place for exploration" then those who do believe in some aspect of divinity must feel able to express their feelings and share them, without any implication that they do not belong. There is a danger that, because the anti-realist position is being proclaimed so loud and clear, people like myself will be progressively marginalised and made to feel unwelcome in the Network; I sincerely hope that does not happen.

— Rosemary Arthur, Wakefield