THOSE LABELS Some respondents to our Questionnaire said they couldn’t be sure which of the suggested descriptions best suited them until they were provided with definitions. We do not presume to offer anything as firm as a “‘definition’’ of the terms used, as different readers evidently use them in different ways. But in an attempt to be helpful, we suggest something of what may lie behind the self-descriptions most commonly used in Sea of Faith.
Non-realist To new readers and to those of us with a lot of catching up to do on modern theology and philosophy, this is much the most baffling label of them all.
Don Cupitt began using non-realist and later anti-realist in the early 1980s to describe a philosophy which breaks with traditional realism, the doctrine of Plato and the classical philosophers. Plato and co saw Beauty, Goodness, Truth, as having a ‘‘real’’ existence independent of humankind. A ‘‘real’’ heaven was contrasted with a shadow and subservient earth, a ‘‘real’’? mind with a subservient body, ‘‘real’’ immortals with shadow mortals.
Cupitt argues that this model is no longer helpful, and in a series of books drawing on modern linguistic analysis he has developed an alternative called non-realism.
Thorough-going non-realists and anti-realists recognise implications beyond the fields of religion and theology.
Within SoF, non-realist is often used more narrowly as a shorthand term for the belief that God has no ‘‘real’’, objective or empirical existence, independent of human culture and language. To such non-realists, God is real enough as a potent symbol, metaphor or projection, but has no objective existence outside and beyond humanity.
The advantage of non-realist as a label is that it shorthands a philosophy sharply contrasted to traditional realism. Its disadvantage is that, outside the in-circle, you can’t use it without preceding it with a philosophy lesson (and probably a garbled one at that). Also, the popular confusion of non-realism with unrealism (a very different animal) makes the widespread adoption of the term non-realism a pretty unrealistic prospect!
Radical Christian Literally, a Christian who wants reform from the roots upwards. But unfortunately the term can be appropriated by ultra-conservatives as well as ‘‘progressives’’ (just as Maggie Thatcher pinched it from the Left and applied it to her own brand of reaction). So it is too ambiguous to be used without qualification and explanation.
To some, radical Christian applies to Christians whose faith finds expression in radical politics: direct action for peace, social justice, a greener world. Thus proponents of “liberation theology’? would call themselves radical Christians, as would many of the groups working in our inner cities, or Quakers withholding military taxes. Such radical Christians may or may not be non-realists; they may or may not believe in a ‘‘real’’ God.
But the term ‘“‘radical’’ may be applied not to the political or social expression of faith but to the theology itself.
Thus we may envisage a spectrum from conservative theology on the right (biblical literalism, fundamentalism), through liberal theology in the centre (a ‘‘modernist’? theology, but still centred on a ‘‘real’’ God), to radical theology on the left, centred on a non-realist view of God and religious faith. It is probably in the latter sense that some SoF members describe themselves as radical Christians. But don’t be surprised if a happyclappy charismatic tells you he’s a radical Christian too!
Post-Christian Just as we describe as a ‘‘post-industrial’’ society one which has passed through and gone beyond the process of industrialisation, so a post-Christian is one who has passed through and gone beyond Christianity. She may acknowledge that her roots are deeply embedded in traditional Christian culture and that her values have been shaped by Christian tradition; but she has cut loose or drifted free from Christian doctrine, dogma and beliefsystems, and perhaps from participation in any kind of church life and practice.
Christian or Religious Humanist Humanism is the doctrine that all values are the product of human culture and are not derived from some extra-terrestrial source; that this life is the only life we have; that religion, like the arts and the sciences, is made by the human community. Some forms of humanism are expressly anti-religious, others see religious language, ritual, art and practice as creative expressions of the human spirit.
So a Christian Humanist is a humanist whose humanism finds expression within some form of Christian tradition.
Similarly, a Religious Humanist gives her humanism expression within a religious tradition which may or may not be Christian.
Non-realist, Radical Christian, Post-Christian, Christian Humanist, Religious Humanist - each self-description or label has its own colour and emphasis. Non-realist, Christian Humanist and Religious Humanist all expressly indicate a view of religious faith as a human creation, while Radical Christian and perhaps Post-Christian are open to a wider variety of interpretations. The Sea of Faith Network promiscuously uses all (and others too), without attaching itself monogomously to any one of them. - DAVID BOULTON