QUOTE UNQUOTE We asked what you thought about SoF and the magazine - and you told us! Here is a selection of your comments I look forward to when the next SoFmag comes through my letterbox and I am truly grateful for the hours of effort that you and many others put into making it happen.
SoFmag is a good secondary source. Could it also be a primary source? If not, are there ways to stand closer to primary sources? Could there be brief extracts, summaries of argument, stories (parables?), taken from secondary sources?
I am curious about the selection process on the kind of thing being looked for. I wrote a piece some months ago now which has not seen the light of day...
Enlarge the magazine and increase the cost accordingly. Then arrange longer articles. Also a Provision for questions and answers.
The thing that continues to stick in my gullet is the conflict between seeing religion as a creation of man and man himself not being a human creation. I’m probably just stupid. The potter made the first pot, whatever clever skills the pot may develop. So I suppose what I would like to see is more examination of the basis of SoF.
Encourage lay people to express their views, maybe using a debating style to provoke greater input - using people who are able to articulate their views clearly and in relatively simple language, avoiding theological jargon.
Thanks for the excellent job you are doing and the high quality of the magazine.
I hope that the magazine will continue to include personal stories of experiences as well as more intellectual items as these are encouraging to new members. I’d like to see articles on the visual arts and sciences. Many thanks for your excellent work. When I see the magazine on the doormat I can’t wait to read it!
There is a place for the play of market forces in the Magazine, i.e. advertisements. What would the Church Times or The Friend be without. their adverts? So why not? 1 would like to see articles and suggestions concerning where we go from here - religious humanism, that is.
How do we show our beliefs collectively (other than by writing about them in the magazine)? How will we organise ourselves? Are we looking for an organisation or church? Should we form our own? Is it the right time yet? Do we have to be more sure of our ideas before we can commit ourselves in this way? I’d like to see articles which ask and tackle these fundamental questions.
I think the magazine does a pretty good job as it is but it doesn’t push the ‘‘cause’? much forwarder. The emphasis is understandably on Christian or Humanist SoFers, but what about Jewish, Hindu, even Muslim non-realists? I am a Buddhist non-realist. It would be nice to have a feeling for other traditions’ reactions to SoF principles.
Stimulate (how?) members to write about creative ideas for practising religious faith as a human creation inside and outside the churches.
Hearing Don Cupitt speak, | was disappointed to find that there was no emphasis on how practically we can begin to access the behaviours and attitudes that would make the human creation of spiritual fulfilment, insight and good living possible. He seemed still so steeped in Christianity, though admittedly a dilute form... | considered writing to you and asking for my subscription back, but then | thought that maybe | was being too hasty and there really was more to SoF that what Don Cupitt had put forward. | expected SoF to me much, much further along the line of really doing something about the reality and efficacy of human faith if carefully explored, nurtured and developed. So | will read your magazine and go to a few more meetings before making a decision.
Please keep it as simple as possible for very average IQ people like me.
The magazine is the only thing that is attempting to explore these issues. However, I read it as a Spectator having a look at what “‘you’’ are up to. I don’t read much that reminds me that I am a member too.
Perhaps we ought to produce some strategy for getting the magazine into some shops. I can think of three or four local shops which stock a huge collection of off-beat magazines.
I think the January 95 magazine is the best ever. ] particularly like the different lengths of articles so I can read a few bits over breakfast, snatch an odd article over lunch, have a good read at a longer article. It means that whatever mood I’m in, and whatever time I’ve got, there’s some reason to tempt me to pick it up.
Your approach is the only one I’ve met which “rings a bell’”’. I like your humour and straight-forward style. No need to jazz it up in format. Beware of glossy paper.
My impression is that SoF only exists at a very theoretical level. I miss ‘‘grass roots’’ impressions/ reports. One gets the feeling that there are no real ordinary members active in their professions and communities.
I do not like the phrase “‘religious faith as a human creation’’, nor the non-realist dogma. Faith is beyond such jargon for me. Nevertheless I enjoy most of the contents.
An arts page would give added interest, especially if accompanied by illustrative material.
Some of us are recent joiners and it may be helpful to have a section outlining the basic arguments espoused by the SoF Network with arguments for and against...ls SoF seeking numbers or greater distribution across the country, or recognition as an alternative religious activity? Does the Steering Committee have any policy on this or is it left to individual members and local groups?
I’d love to see ‘‘conversations’’ between SoF members in their local groups transcribed and printed. Isolation is a huge problem for radical thinkers in a conservative church or conservative country (South Africa).
The general tone of the magazine is too academic for widespread appeal. Where is the humour?
Religion is a serious matter. Why are you always making fun of it? | dislike your jokey headlines, and your Post-script column in particular puts wit before witness. Whatever faith may or may not be, it’s no joke. Leave the humour to Private Eye.
If the magazine has a fault, it is that it sometimes carries too much trivial, superficial stuff, as if written by somebody thoroughly conditioned by the escapist media and the tabloid press... | would like to see it increase in size and then split into a regular newsletter and a more serious journal.
It would be helpful to have some articles on how to run a parish along radical lines, e.g. revamped confirmation classes, a reshaped style and content of preaching, giving pastoral help along theologically liberated lines. What do other clergy do?
The magazine should encourage more forthright, less mealy-mouthed contributions, using fewer obfuscating multisyllabic words.
Congratulations! I especially like your Post-script column.
I’d like more on the implications of creation theology and non-realist theology for each other.
More international focus. Be more open to exploring implications of threat of Islamic fundamentalism. More work on facing the arguments from conservative theologians for absolute moral principles. There seems to be very little space given to critique of non-realism and post-Christian views.
If promotion of ideas to a wider audience is required, then you must recruit some writers with some more practical, down-to-earth contributions to make.
I think it would help to have more reports from local groups about their activities. These could be quite brief and factual, not too demanding of time and energy for the person reporting, but could be useful to others.
I’m afraid I find the virulence and polemicism of Sea of Faith rather off-putting. The wider acceptance that SoF wants for its views can be either (a) more people holding a hard-line SoF viewpoint, or (b) more church-goers accepting people with the SoF viewpoint in their midst.
The magazine is too polemical and hard-line to achieve (b) and I have no interest in (a). If SoF wishes to achieve (b) it needs to woo those like myself (or the Archbishop of York) who take the view that much of religious faith is a human creation but that religious faith itself may not be. Otherwise the magazine will be no more than the journal of a sect alienated from secular society by virtue of its religiosity and from religious society by virtue of its self-confidence in non-realism.
Some lighter-hearted articles as well as the thoughtprovoking ones would make the magazine more user friendly. More photos and drawings would help.
Different sorts of type faces would perhaps break up the rather daunting look of the present magazine.
Personally I prefer to concentrate on religion as a form of human ‘‘expression’’ rather than ‘‘creation’’... For me the magazine eases the ‘“‘pain of loneliness’’, if one accepts that wrenching oneself from ‘‘the known way’’ is the only way forward.
I find the magazine somewhat daunting visually and in content. It feels rather negative, denigrating Christian tradition which remains very important to me and which I would prefer to see celebrated, despite the reinterpretation which is certainly necessary. I also feel that SoF is entirely inward-looking, preoccupied with its own navel!
Is there no room for social concern?
The only real dislike I have is the format. | would prefer smaller (AS?) size. It looks a bit old-fashioned (e.g. the logo and Postbag and Postscript headings) but I do realise that this area is a minefield! But many thanks for doing all this - I do look forward to it and enjoy it.
Thinner paper, ergo more articles. Same price. Too many of the same names cropping up. It mustn’t be too much Cupitt et al.
I deeply appreciate the insights we often have from contributors. Keep on doing what you’re doing!
Suggestion: draw upon the systematic literatures of sociology of knowledge and sociology of religion, which deal with social concomitants/determinants of religious faith.
Maybe we need to emphasise religion less and spirituality more.
I consider the magazine to be of an excellenty standard already. But we hear little of the deliberations of the Steering Committee. Would not a brief paragraph in each magazine to give members some idea of what they are deliberating be welcome?
As | have only just joined SoF, | can’t see anything much wrong! In fact | think the magazine is wonderful - so much better than the magazine produced by the Humanists for instance! | felt a warm glow after reading the January issue. It gave me a feeling of belonging to a group of like-minded people to myself.
We must reject ecclesiastical jargon, hocus-pocus, gobbledegook. The ‘‘continuing importance of spiritual and social values’’ needs to be affirmed by the church, but the message will not be received unless it is offered in secular language, avoiding God-speak while openly attacking neo-barbarism.
I attended one local SoF group meeting but came away totally bemused and wondering whether my IQ was recordable on any known scale! Many people use feelings to relate to things spiritual, not intellect... We somehow need a means of validating the experience of ‘‘the bloke in the street’, The magazine is quite exceptional for what is still such a small organisation of limited means.
It seems that most of your contributors describe their present position in belief, but not how they got there - the arrival, not the journey. Why not a series on “how I became a non-realist’’?
I can’t see a mass market ever for SoFism or non-realism. There never has been one for earlier versions, e.g. mysticism or Quakerism. We can’t develop a popular non-realism to parallel popular realism, either the hell-fire sermon type or the smells, bells and plaster Statues variety. Perhaps we should pay more attention to creative writing (Knowledge of Angels by Jill Paton Walsh could have been written for SoF - it’s wonderful!). ! am frequently irritated by the negativity of some contributors. | have sympathy with the contributor who wrote about the rather superior and critical attitude that some writers take towards those who have the courage to stay within conventional religious boundaries and try to change things from within.
It is too easy to opt out and snipe from the sidelines.
Why not write for ordinary people? So many articles seem to me to be pseudo-academic. I have only received two issues and have spotted the following: Nietzsche, Plato, Dostoyevsky, Buber, Freud, Krishna, Jung, Wittgenstein, Housman, Arnold, Old Uncle Tom Cobbley and all - hardly of the greatest interest to the man on the Clapham omnibus or reader of the Independent (me).
The post brought January Modern Believing and SoF magazine at the same time - the latter vastly more readable and interesting. | have today written to say | no longer wish to be a member of the Network but wish to subscribe to the magazine which | find interesting, even though your certainty about non-realism reminds me of the fundamentalists’ certainty which | reject. | liked Michael Morris’s article. He is one of the few non-realists who seem prepared to “live with uncertainty and not treat it as a new kind of certainty”.
You lack a section on how to become more spiritual.
We all need to order extra copies for our local library, or whichever location seems suitable. Can an editorial urge what may seem obvious, for us to share our copies of the magazine? I am grateful for all the hard work done by everyone who helps get the magazine out. It is good to read, thought-provoking and sustaining.
I am sorry to see no articles by women in the January magazine. From the mailings of the NW SoF group I know that women members are active and articulate.
I often wish to follow up an article or read the source of an idea, and find it frustrating to begin the search anew when the contributor must have had it to hand. Thank you for collecting together so much excellent material and editing it, as well as for your own contributions.
I would resist any move to reduce the intellectual/ academic content, as some people seem to want.
SoF magazines are filed away carefully and when I have read them for information or research I have found them invaluable. So keep up the good work and intellectual level! | think it must be quite hard to edit this magazine! By definition there’s no creed to dissect, and the local groups | belong to just meet and talk, so there’s no news either. I'd like to hear a bit more about what people do with their lives once they've accepted SoF views. For most people I've met it seems to be enough that they have escaped from their previous positions. But what next? And how about the thousands of young people who never did belong to an “organised” religion, and take the SoF position as a perfectly natural starting point? We don’t seem to be very imaginative when it comes to turning SoF into a lifestyle.
The quality of the magazine depends on the quality of the articles it receives... Perhaps short stories or other fictionalised accounts of what it means to try to live as a non-realist could help put flesh on the bones of beautiful ideas.
Religious truth has to be reinterpreted in every generation.
The main body of the Christian churches have no desire to do this. They are like the old ladies who, faced with Darwinian theory, fell on their knees and prayed ‘‘O God, please don’t let it be true. But if it is, please help us to hush it up’’.
How does one expose ideas for debate yet avoid a missionary attitude? | have no desire to preach or to convert, but discussion with other groups is a philosophically formative process.
Perhaps we could have more reviews of secular films such as The Colour Red/White/Blue by the Polish director with an unpronouncable name? These would help with the non-realist interpretation of contemporary spirituality. Members of the Network could be commisssioned to write these reviews on a regular basis.
The magazine needs to be more human! What gives SoF people joy, a reason for living? Give an example (perhaps a poem, a picture, sex, a play). This could be a new form of prayer, something that connects us more clearly with the spirit of life (same as worship, really). Also brief feedback from local groups. How are you all doing out there? Am I alone?
Making contact with the magazine is the best intellectual encounter I have had for a long time.
The debate as presented in SoF literature tends to confine itself to the interface with philosophy. Too little attention is given to the interface between belief systems and the physical world of cosmology and science.
Bring the magazine out of the “head” and more into experience and feeling, more into how we can relate it to daily life. It needs to be more inspiring!
I very much enjoy the magazine. It gives a robust feeling that SoF is not merely a pleasant pastime for middle-class intellectuals. 1 especially like the editorials. They are very refreshing.
Am still in rather a heady state at reading so much material which makes me say Hooray! I have particularly enjoyed articles by Frank Walker, Adam Thomson and the Repent! editorial. I would welcome seeing the magazine as a forum for developing SoF ideas for action, through special-interest groups, publications, working parties, etc.
I find Don Cupitt a bit rarified but enjoy Lloyd Geering, so I want articles in the latter’s style.
It is the only religious mag | read from start to finish.
How odd to find in your magazine an article about the Quakers which tells me more about Quakerism, in fewer and clearer words, than anything the Society of Friends has produced, Can you do the same for Humanism, Unitarianism and so on?
More poetry? No! No! No! Magazine poetry is the pits - and I write as a practising poet.
We would get a lot more members if the aim was ‘‘to promote the exploration of religious faith as a human creation’’.
Promotion is a matter of reaching the general public, people who may feel uncomfortable with the totally uncritical realism adopted by so many clergy yet be unaware of the tremendous support to be found in SoF.
Making the magazine available on general sale is a tremendous step in the right direction. Perhaps if SoF can afford it, regular advertisements in the religious and humanist press would be a further help.
Do we need more exploration into non-verbal symbols, ‘‘sacraments’’, which do not require an intellectual base but an artistic or emotional one?
How is it that every issue seems the best one yet?
Congratulations!
Great publication! Been a help to me. Thanks.
I suggest complimentary copies are sent to leading churchmen, religious organisations, humanists and atheists.
You reassure me that | am not going mad: what | have come to discover and feel to be true is no more nor less than countless others also believe.
Inspire one of our members to write a_ best-seller block-buster novel with plenty of sex (and violence?) but in which SoF ideas are explored by the characters!
The January issue was my first copy. I knew it was going to be a good thing once I had pulled it about three inches out of the envelope... Clear, good layout, eye-friendly, and breathing gently the spirit of the Sea of Faith.
My husband is registered blind. I do read it to him but if it could be in very large print or on tape it would help.
As we cannot afford to attend conferences, the reports and news are vital to us. | have enjoyed the magazine more in the last two years.
Promotion? This is a touch ironic! I’m reminded of the jibe about Tony Benn ‘“‘going around whipping up apathy’’! Can one proselytise disbelief?
Please keep it coming. I need a lifeline from time to time.
A selection of reader comments from the questionnaire responses.