That Questionnaire

THAT QUESTIONNAIRE YOU'RE TELLING US! hen we first mooted the idea of a questionnaire to find out more about Sea of Faith magazine readers and Network members, old hands in marketing told us we’d be lucky to get more than a ten per cent response. ‘‘People hate filling in forms. They leave it till tomorrow, and tomorrow never comes’’. So we expected to get back perhaps 60 or 70 forms: enough to give us indications of what some of our keener members liked and disliked about what we are trying to do.

In the event, more than a hundred responses landed on our front door mat within a week of getting the questionnaire out with the January magazine. They rose to pass the 300 mark, and are still coming in six weeks later. So a sincere thankyou to everyone who responded.

You have provided us with a sample large and broad enough to turn an opinion pollster green with envy.

Indeed, not only have 300-plus readers answered our questions, but a great many of them used the extra space provided to comment in detail on the magazine, the Network, ‘‘religious faith as a human creation’’, and the meaning of life. Some enclosed fully worked articles, poems, letters. All this material, even more than the bare answers to questions, helps fill out in rich detail the varied colour and character of Sea of Faith in 1995. We have run excerpts elsewhere in this issue (always preserving the anonymity we promised, except where permission to by-line the writer has been expressly given).

The following analysis is based on the first 300 questionnaires returned. This round figure has the advantage that by dividing totals by three you arrive at a percentage, and by multiplying them by about twoand-a-half you get an approximate Network total. For instance, if 30 respondents are basket-makers, that’s about 10 per cent of the membership, and means you can expect to find about 75 basket-makers in the Network’s total membership of around 750. Totals often add up to more than 300 because more than one answer has been given to a particular question. Likewise, totals are often less than 300 because the respondent has chosen not to answer a question. Questionnaires received after this analysis will continue to be processed, and if they change the picture in any significant way this will be reported in our next issue.

How long have you been a member or subscriber?

The recent rapid growth of the Network is reflected in the answers. 54 answered under one year, 60 one year, 70 two years, 37 three, 27 four, 23 five and 27 six years or more.

How old are you?

No surprises here! We are a pretty middle-aged lot, if not positively elderly. Only 3 respondents are under thirty, 21 in their thirties, 39 in their forties, 71 in their fifties, 77 in their sixties, 65 in their seventies and 19 in their eighties or nineties. The greys have it! Not far short of half our readership is retired, and we have six times as many octogenarians and nonogenarians as under-thirties! What happened to the young people who came to last year’s Conference? Is it just that they have better things to do than fill in questionnaires? Where are the theology students? Or is it that young people find it so blindingly obvious that religious faith is a human creation that they don’t see the need for an organisation to labour the point?

Are you a member of, or are you closely associated with, a church/denomination, other religious tradition or Humanist group?

This is the first time we have systematically asked Network members about any denominational allegiance or background, perhaps because it was thought casier to surmount these historic barriers by ignoring them.

Interestingly, not a single respondent objected to the question. 99 respondents belong to or think of themselves as closely associated with the Church of England. The next largest denominational tradition is the Society of Friends with 57. Methodists have 14, United Reform 12 and Unitarians 12. Other protestant nonconformist churches together claim 21 (including 5 Baptists, 3 Presbyterians, 2 Congregational and 1 Salvation Army) and Roman Catholics 5. Thus 220 have a continuing church connection. (Some belong to more than one church). 61 describe themselves as ‘‘lapsed’’, 25 as ‘‘nothing’’. 16 are associated with a Humanist organisation. Thus a total of 92 have no religious allegiance. Of the non-Christian traditions, 5 are Jewish and 3 Buddhist, showing how weak we remain in this area. ‘ More than two out of three SoF subscribers have a continuing church connection. And one in three is a teacher or lecturer What is or was your main trade or profession?

Now at last we can nail the lie that we are primarily an organisation of godless vicars! No fewer than 97 respondents are teachers and lecturers. Clergy, including those training for the ministry, come a poor second with 48. 23 are in science/engineering, 18 in social services (including 3 probation officers) and local government, 18 in therapy/counselling/psychology, 18 in medicine/health, 18 in management/accountancy/business/administration, 14 in the diplomatic corps or civil service (including a non-realist inspector of taxes!), 12 in the media/ advertising/journalism, and 8 in law. Others include 5 in IT/computers, 5 secretaries, 8 archivist/librarian/printer/ booksellers, 4 students, 4 farmers/smallholders, 4 in retail/sales, 4 in the armed services, 2 musicians and 1 each of architect, brush manufacturer, building tradesman, RAC officer, plasterer, handweaver and painter. 13 respondents described themselves as ‘‘housewife’’ or ‘*mother’’.

Again, to middle age we can clearly add the label middle class. We have a very strong preponderance of members in the so-called caring professions. Our appeal to what the dear departed Clause 4 used to call ‘‘workers by hand’’ as distinct from ‘‘workers by brain’’ is clearly no stronger than our appeal to the young. What are we going to do about that?

Our average SoFer is beginning to take shape now: a late-fifties teacher/lecturer still fairly new to the Network.

So how does she see herself, and what is she looking for from the magazine?

Which of the following descriptions best suits you, if any?

As the careful wording of the question should make clear, we were not intending to devise tight, mutually exclusive categories. The intention was to find out which of the several labels SoF writers use are most commonly applied to themselves by members. Many respondents ticked more than one of the five descriptions offered, and some ticked them all. Some ticked none but responded to the invitation to write in their own favoured description.

Some said they couldn’t answer without definitions (see page 17). 6 refused to answer because they ‘‘don’t like labels’’. 88 ticked ‘‘Non-realist’’, 79 ‘‘Radical Christian’’, 63 “‘Christian Humanist’’, 34 ‘‘Religious Humanist’? and 41 ‘*Post-Christian’’. Of the written-in labels, 7 were various versions of ‘‘Undecided’’, 5 ‘‘Universalist’’, 6 various forms of ‘‘Atheist’’ (e.g. ‘‘Catholic Atheist’’, ‘‘Humanist Atheist’’, ‘‘Post-Atheist’’?), and 9 various forms of “‘Agnostic’’. 6 Humanists chose to describe themselves simply as ‘‘Humanist’’ and 3 Quakers were simply “‘Quaker’’. The rest were one-offs: ‘‘Jungian’’, ‘‘Chris- tian Socialist’’, ‘‘Logical Positivist’’, ‘‘Religious EcoHumanist’’, ‘‘Realist’’ and ‘‘Critical Realist’’, ‘‘Traditional but enquiring Christian’’, ‘‘Sceptical Theist’’, ‘Religious Freethinker’’, ‘‘Gnostic/Mystic’’, ‘‘Feminist and eclectic’’, ‘‘Quaker Gentile for Jesus’’. Wow.

It is perhaps significant that although ‘‘Non-realist’’ got more ticks than any other label, only 88 of the 300 respondents identified with the term popularised by Don Cupitt and often used by critics to describe SoF as a whole. The breakdown of those who described themselves as ‘‘Non-realist’’ was even more interesting. Only 22 of the 88 were Church of England, with 33 from the other churches (predominantly Quaker), 31 from those with no church allegiance at all, and 2 (one Buddhist, one Jewish) from other faith traditions.

What do you think of the magazine?

This was the primary purpose of the questionnaire: to find out what readers liked and disliked about the magazine, and what changes they. would like to see. Seven statements about the magazine were supplied, all of them the kind of informal opinion one hears routinely at Conferences and local group meetings, and readers were asked to tick those they agreed with and place a cross against those they strongly disagreed with. Some readers said they would have preferred to indicate their agreement/disagreement on a scale of one to ten. We did consider this, but felt it was too complicated, and not necessarily any more revealing than the stark tick/cross choice. Where readers had no strong opinion, of course, they were free to leave that particular statement unmarked.

I like the magazine much as it is, A gratifying 238 ticked this and 6 crossed it. We do not read much into this. It would indeed be surprising if a significant number were subscribing to a magazine they strongly disliked.

I find the magazine too intellectual/academic. 29 agreed, 108 strongly disagreed.

The magazine is often not Christian enough. 13 agreed, 119 styrongly disagreed.

The magazine is too humanist/atheist. 8 agreed, 97 strongly disagreed.

The magazine has too many long articles. 20 agreed, 99 strongly disagreed.

The magazine doesn’t seem'to be written for people like me. 17 agreed, 88 strongly disagreed.

The magazine doesn’t do enough to promote SoF ideas. 21 agreed, 65 strongly disagreed - but see more on ‘*promotion’’ below.

What do you think about our regular features?

Readers were asked to tick features they liked and cross those they disliked.

Theological articles were liked by 246, disliked by 11.

Creativelimaginative articles were liked by 218, disliked by 18.

Conference reports were liked by 186, disliked by 27.

Several of those who disliked them in the magazine said they preferred them made available separately.

Book reviews were liked by 256 (the highest-scoring feature of all: the loud, clear voice of all those teachers!), disliked by 6.

Letters were liked by 235, disliked by 8.

The Postscript column was liked by 212, disliked by 2.

Editorials were liked by 223, disliked by 2.

What features would you like to see more of?

Here we wanted to test reaction to the requests we get from time to time for more poetry, or cartoons, or art-work. Although we only asked for positive votes (ticks) here, several readers had such strong negative reactions that they planted their crosses uninvited!

Poetry. 68 wanted more (one poet added ‘‘especially mine’’), but 21 disagreed.

Cartoons. 62 wanted more, 15 disagreed.

Photos and art-work. 53 wanted more, 18 disagreed.

Several readers added, reasonably enough, ‘‘of what?”’ A significant number suggested that photos of contributors would make them less anonymous, and we shall try to respond to this suggestion.

We invited readers to write in their own suggestions of what they would like to see more of. Their answers are so diverse that they are not easy to break down, but include reports of local group activities, adverts, interfaith articles, contributions on environmental concerns, and, most popular of all, accounts of ‘‘personal religious journeys’’, Since you, the readers, write the magazine, you know what you have to do to get published!

Is the magazine doing a good or a bad job at exploring religious faith as a human creation? 191 say a good job, 10 say a bad job.

Is the magazine doing a good or a bad job at promoting wider acceptance of the view that all religious faith is a human creation?

This was the one that put the cat among the pigeons.

Although 168 said a good job and only 18 a bad job, a very significant 53 thought we shouldn’t be doing any promoting at all. Some of these suggested that the Network should explore through the magazine but promote through books and publications aimed at a wider audience. Some thought the Network and its magazine shouldn’t be promoting its view at all, or shouldn’t have a view to promote, Since the Network’s aims and objects are, and have been from the start, to ‘‘explore and promote religious faith as a human creation’’, promotion must be part of our brief.

But there needs to be a continuing debate about what promotion means, and what role the magazine plays in it.

The magazine has always been primarily for members, and therefore an internal house-magazine for exploration and information rather than a tract for those in outer darkness. But the recent decision of the Steering Committee to open subscription to non-members implies a responsibility to explain SoF’s distinctive stance (and the Network does have a distinctive stance) to those non-members, who may or may not choose to join us in our explorations.

Finally, we asked:

What suggestions can you make for doing a better job at either exploration or promotion?

For exploration, most of the suggestions have been incorporated in the above analysis. For promotion, suggestions ranged from ‘‘don’t’’ to ‘‘stop preaching to the converted and get out onto the bookstalls’’. One respondent asked for a second, more popular magazine to look after the promoting, another wants the Steering Committee to offer a panel of speakers to address local public meetings. Other suggestions are included in the excerpts in our extended feature beginning on page 13.

You have given us a lot to think about - and a lot more work to do. If we had any tendency to complacency, you have wiped it clean away! Above all, you have impressed upon us that you are not content merely to read, to consume, our quarterly offerings, but you want to be involved in the Network and will seize the opportunity for involvement when it is presented to you.

But don’t stop there! Write for us! Don’t leave it to others! Tell us about your own spiritual journey, your own experiences in church and similar groups, your own explorations, your own thoughts on the implications of non-realism/Christian humanism (here we go again).

Argue with other contributors! Tell us what we are doing wrong! Above all, tell the rest of us something from your own viewpoint of how a reasonable, modern or postmodern faith, anchored in this world and grounded in human experience, can help feed the hungry and empower the dispossessed - which, after, all, is what it’s all about.

The editor regrets that he cannot respond individually to the comments included with questionnaires.