EDUCATING THE SPIRIT Derek Chorley In 1988 the Archbishop of Westminster, Cardinal Basil Hume, wrote, in Towards a Civilisation of Love (Hodder & Stoughton): “ “Tt has seemed to many of us in the churches and elsewhere that the package of proposals included in the Education Reform Act was put together initially with undue haste and after inadequate consultation. Sometimes it seemed that political rather than educational considerations predominated.”’ One of Cardinal Hume’s main criticisms of the Act was that it lacked any sort of spiritual dimension. A succession of Secretaries of State have proceeded, in turn, to impose on schools the obligation to teach religion which is ‘‘broadly based’’ Christian. These obligations have been modified with each succeeding Minister. Now, people are beginning to see that, in view of the multiplicity of faiths (or total lack of any), these measures are fast becoming fruitless exercises.
Cardinal Hume seems to imply, rightly, that there is a distinction, which many religious writers fail to make, between religion and ‘‘spirituality’’. They are not necessarily equal sides of an equation. Spirituality is a much less superficial concept than religion. It has deeper and wider horizons. The Government believes that the teaching of religion will bring about a state of moral order in society, even perhaps a more spiritual milieu, but the question is, ‘‘Can one person elicit a spiritual response from another simply by teaching religion, or religions?’ The distinction betweem ‘“‘religiosity’’ and spirituality is critical. Religious behaviour is highly symbolic. There is, initially, a verbal assent to authority - it may be called divine authority but in practice it could be no more than assent to man-made ecclesiastical authority. It is ritualistic: bowing of the head, kneeling down, prayer formulae, hymn-singing, services involving bread and wine, etc.
These rituals may well be intended to signify something deeper but for many people they remain at the symbolic level only, comparable to magic tricks.
Spiritual response, on the other hand, can only come from within, and religion is not necessarily required to bring this about. Spirituality lies in the depth of the human psyche. It is extremely individual and unique. It is unpredictable, formless, without definition. Theological libraries are full of books on how to become spiritual. Not one of them would work for anyone except their authors.
I know, I’ve tried a few!
Spirituality is more to do with right brain than left. Left brain is down to earth, logical, reasonable, It gets us through the day to day business of living. It is right brain which ‘‘sees’’ through the trivia, the routine, the monotony of day to day existence. Spirituality is a state of growth in which people have reached such a level of maturity that they have lifted themselves above the humdrum, the trivia of everyday life, so that they have a deeper and more meaningful vision of themselves in relation to other people and the world.
Spirituality may come from within but it is outwardlooking. Religiosity comes from within and can become inward-looking. ‘‘Really, in the end, what we’re about is saving our own souls’’ declared a religious person in a discussion group on the subject ‘‘What is the point of religion?’’. This surely is the ultimate selfishness.
For centuries education operated under the influence of a belief that man is made up of a mixture of body and soul, and the educator’s task was to develop the ‘‘powers of the soul’’ with little regard for the education of the body, except to make it a pure and fitting place in which the soul could dwell. The aim was to make the body subservient to the soul. Once the soul’s powers were developed, spirituality followed in its wake. Religious beliefs, practices and rituals were the keys which would open the spiritual doors. But is this true? The whiskey priest in Graham Greene’s The Power and the Glory was really only superficially ‘‘religious’’. He was, however, a deeply spiritual man.
Religious education is not really a problem for a teacher.
Spiritual education is far more difficult. There never could be Guidelines or Key Stages. One thing is certain.
We are beginning to learn - or re-learn, for others have trodden these paths before us - that the human being is much more than a left-brained economic unit. S/he is a very complex, deep-thinking creature capable of much energetic creativity. Shouldn’t true education reflect this in some way? Shouldn’t it be about developing these deeper powers of the mind? Where is this reflected in the National Curriculum? Or are we content to settle for superficial glances at second-hand packages of knowledge so that in the end we discover what too many of our school-leavers have already discovered: that life, after all, is nothing more than one big yawn?