I would counsel that, if the answer is yes, we do not rush unthinkingly into it. If we are not to make a mess of it (which might not be easy to clear up) we need some time to think out strategies appropriate both to our Network and to the religious bodies concerned. Perhaps our Steering Committee could do some work on this if the general idea seems right. [What do you think? Should we be networking within the institutions to which we are attached - and if not, where should we be promoting a view of religion as a human creation? If we do want to seek out others within our denominations or other institutions who may share our outlook, how do we find them and by what mechanism do we link up with them? How should such ‘‘special interest’’ mini-networks relate to the national SoF Network? Do let us have your views! - Ed.] SOF MEETS ROCK OF AGES Michael Morris Have you ever dropped a stone in a well and waited for what seems an eternity before hearing the distant splash?
And noted the uncanny silence afterwards?
A few months ago, I had an article about SoF published in my local parish magazine. St James is an average low church Anglican church with a committed nucleus of conservative evangelicals, which includes the vicar, George.
My article was basically a presentation of what I understand to be the main insights Don Cupitt has put forward over the years on the nature of truth, so I said that truths are culturally and historically conditioned and that the language we use to express our insights is itself a human invention. We cannot step outside it to describe how things ‘‘really are out there’’. The ‘‘world” is the sum of our perceptions, and these perceptions are subject to change. We have created our own values.
The article was published with a disclaimer by George, stating that he intended to reply to it, and inviting others to respond to it also.
His reply was in the form of an editorial of about four paragraphs, stating that he knew what was real and what was not, and proceeded to give three examples: his birth, his marriage and the crucifixion. He concluded with a broadside against philosophers who ‘‘tried to explain reality away’’. There were no other replies.
I must admit that I felt disappointeed by his reply, not that I expected him to agree with me but mainly because I felt he had somehow missed the point. He seemed to be attacking an idealism that I did not believe in.
I think that his misunderstanding may be partly my fault.
The article I wrote focused mainly on attempting to define non-realism in a rationalistic way, but George’s rationality works in one way and mine works in a different way. He read into the article an interpretation I never intended. C’est la vie, Derrida!
A friend of mine at St James is training for the priesthood, I have met with a similar response from her, after lending her my copy of Anthony Freeman’s book, and a booklet based on an interview with Don Cupitt. It was not so much that she disagreed with it, as simply failed to comprehend what was actually being said, as if it were written in another language - which, in a sense, I suppose it is.
Language is the servant of realism, which while it is an error (realism I mean) has been a necessary means to our survival as a species. So part of the difficulty of communicating our insights to others is that in order to do so we have to use language based on concepts that reinforce a commonsense view of the world, It is rather like trying to untie a shoelace, only to find that the knot is getting tighter all the time.
Two other factors that I think cointribute towards the difficulties people face when confronted with Sea of Faith ideas are fear of uncertainty, with the loss of secur:ty that it entails, and an undeveloped historical sense.
People take their world views for granted, but as Nietzsche said, one must have the courage for an attack on one’s own convictions. In SoF we must be aware of a subtle danger. We have found traditional beliefs and dogmas inadequate as a means of expressing our newly developed sense of the transience and wonder of life in all its forms. We may be tempted to think that we have taken the measure of how language and culture inform our perceptions and beliefs, that we have transcended all dualities. I don’t think we have, and I think we should not attempt to replace a monolithic world view based on realism by one based on non-realism. We must be agnostics who remain agnostic about our agnosticism. We have to live with uncertainty and not treat it as a new kind of certainty.
This is where historical sense comes in. My conservative evangelical friends are seemingly unaware that the tradition they belong to only emerged in the 19th century.
They appear to believe that it sprang fully formed from the footprints of St Paul, and has remained more or less unchanged for two thousand years. They read their distinctive beliefs back into the Bible. Because of their literalism, it is obvious in their case what they are doing; but it is a mental habit we are all guilty of to a degree.
We can easily read our SoF concerns back into the great thinkers of the past, and we can attempt to trace a coherent pattern of intellectual development into the present, which does not really exist, just like the realists who, in an analagous way, read the evolutionary story as We must be agnostics who remain agnostic about our agnosticism. We have to l.ve with uncertainty and not treat it as a new kind of certainty one of predetermined progress from simplicity to complexity, unfolding with all the smoothness of a summer rose.
These habits of mind are all ways of dealing with radical uncertainty and contingency. Perhaps it is inevitable, but we must always be aware of exactly what we are doing when we do it.
In a few weeks time my wife and I will be going on a parish weekend away, a time for ‘‘fun, fellowship and reflection’’. I anticipate that I shall be asked about my involvement with Sea of Faith and, frankly, I am not looking forward to it. I feel at a disadvantage. Not because I shall meet with hostility - most Anglicans are far too polite for that! I shall be up against the Rock of Ages - the hard granite face of commonsense religion, with its complacency and massive certainty, against which I shall be pitting my uncertainties and insights connected by nothing more than elusive intuitions.
All I can hope to do is to perhaps try and awaken a sense of the mystery surrounding our existence, put a question mark against the ‘‘rationality’’ of reason and draw attention to the deceitful transparency of language.
I'll drop my stone into the well, wait for the splash, and wait to sce what thought creatures stir in the depths.
Michael Morris is a civil servant, raised a Jehovah’s Witness, converted to evangelical Christianity and now a member of the North West SoF group.