One View of Truth

Pilate: You are a king then?
Jesus: King is your word. My task is to bear witness to the truth. For this I was born, for this I came into the world, and all that are not deaf to truth listen to my voice.

Pilate: What .... is truth ?

What follows was prompted by a number of things, but an invitation to take part in a discussion with the minister at the church I attend one Sunday evening, (substitute for the sermon), and the question of what to discuss, triggered off assembling this collection of ideas - which in the event were deemed to be a bit over-the-top for the normal Methodist congregation. If you read on, I think you will see why. Let us start with a list. A bit naive, perhaps, but one has to start from some initial premise.

Truth, initially, is what we are told as little children.

Truth is revealed in part by education. Truth is affected by only a partial knowledge of the facts.

Truth is modified by such influences as (a) the section of society in which we mix, (b) the attitude we take to life and (c) our individual financial and domestic circumstances. Truth varies for the subject matter (eg maths, science, culture, religion etc.) for which truth is sought. Truth is influenced by individual bias and varies with your point of view ; there are two or more sides to every question. Truth can depend upon the interpretation of myth/allegory/metaphor/ story. Truth is therefore sub/ea/lie as much, if not more so, 1/78/7 it is objective. Truth is, therefore, for us, what we want it to be. Indeed, you can take elements of a number of the preceding points and form an amalgam which will be true for one individual and him/her alone.

The religious debate is concerned with what is true about what stands for us as God. But it is impossible to come to a 'true' conclusion, if only by definition, because of the terms in which God is described. She is beyond knowledge. Some of us are reminded of the idea in the hymns of Christian worship. Attributes are ascribed to God, but those attributes are ascribed on the initial premise that a realist God exists, which in turn rests on traditional arguments for the existence of God. The conclusions drawn from those arguments are not verified. We are told to take it on trust. Have faith. Why should we ?

The traditional religious person will, (probably), claim revelation, in respect of knowledge of god, (we are now down to a small `g'), and in respect of scripture.

All sorts of wonders are claimed to support this idea.

But in the light of current understanding those wonders themselves raise serious questions. There are quite a number within the church's ranks who cannot take literally ideas like virgin birth and physical resurrection. These are true for those who wish to believe them ; they are not true for those who don't.

Nobody can resolve the matter absolutely one way or another which brings us back to the point about truth being subjective, not objective.

On the philosophical angle, we have much to thank Wittgenstein for, with regard to the philosophy of language ; and Cupitt leans fairly heavily on him in some respects. (I must ask at this point that you bear in mind that I am an engineer, not a philosophy student !) Cupitt would argue that there is nothing outside language. That is to say there is nothing of which we can have knowledge, or engage in the study of, that is outside language ; on the basis that we think in words. We are taught from the cradle to name things ; mummy, daddy, dog, cat, table, etc. and our thought processes develop using ideas forged by and described in words. We have to be able to match ideas to word patterns, which are recognisable, and therefore communicable, and it works because it is drawn from the culture of which we are a part.

In that sense we are creatures of our culture. Now in this context the word "god" conveys an abstract idea, of which we only have knowledge from the notions our own culture has ascribed to her/him. It is a one-sided picture, because we cannot get around the back to see what is on the other side, so to speak. It is an idea which sits on the periphery of language, rather than one which is surrounded by language.

Indeed, traditional theology would seek to put god outside language altogether, as being over and above it.

This, Cupitt would no doubt argue, is a direct child of Platonic philosophy where there was the Good and the Forms, which were over and against the created universe as understood. The only comprehensible argument for such a 'being' is to explain the unknown and inexplicable. Which brings us to the concept of the void. To those grounded and brought up upon the idea that god made everything and is the origin, purpose and end of all things, the thought that the universe as currently understood has no known origin, no known purpose, (and while its demise is a matter of some speculation), its demise to what and why is equally unknown, is very hard to accept. That, crudely, is the void. Which is where the non-realist steps in.

SOF Magazine 8, Winter 1991-92 15 Having taken the view that traditional ideas are subjective truth, masquerading as objectivity, and moreover a system which does not work for me, I now have to put something in its place ; it is often easier to knock things down than build new ones.

Don Cupitt believes that the New Testament story is capable of being bent sufficiently to accommodate a non-realist viewpoint. Perhaps one reason for this is the fact that the gospels contain a lot of material which critical study cannot attribute to Jesus, and a lot more which is dubious in origin. From what I know, I would suggest that the four gospels deal more with the kingdom of god on earth than in heaven. But Dennis Nineham (at SOF I ) expressed the view that the non-realist position requires a new story, and that indeed would be difficult.

Clearly, if one is to be a Christian non-realist the story has to stay. But it has to be interpreted and to a greater degree than currently undertaken by liberal theologians. It would retain all the gospel teaching as to how we should deal with our neighbour ; but not those writings which perpetuate sexual discrimination, particularly as found in the writings of the Pauline school, who were probably the best exponents of discrimination one could find, and not just in the matter of sex. But then one must concede that they were people of their day, which is very different to our day.

The view of truth as subjective and a non-realist attitude to god attracts various reactions - as seen in SOFs conferences - there are those who openly take that position, those who sympathise but take no active part, those who go part of the road but not all, those who disagree, those who violently disagree, and those who would have you hung, drawn and quartered. But the non-realist case, because it does not recognise one over-riding and absolute truth, is by nature tolerant. This is unlike the right wing of the traditional church, and to a lesser degree the balance of the traditional church, which believes it has an absolute truth to proclaim and will not have anything else. Two points come to mind here : (a) the foregoing is perhaps a harsh judgement in some respects and (b) the non-realist would see it right that those who believe the traditional faith should follow its tenets, even when it means that the non-realist comes under attack.

To pursue (b) a bit further. If you believe that you hold a truth, and moreover a religious truth about the life hereafter, that is not something that you stick under a bushel. And if you are a caring soul you will not want to see others damned in hell. Now that is a rather stark scenario ; it supposes that the whole church rushes round rather like the more extreme of the `evangelical' groups, and clearly it does not. Most adherents of the church would seek to attract others to the church by being the kind of people they are.

They do not attempt to drag others to worship by dangling them over hell, and I would stick my neck out and suggest that this is because the idea of hell does not figure very large in the thinking of the majority. So we can therefore detect a shift away from the basic tenets of the early Christian fathers. The impression is gained that for the majority of those who attend church the idea of hell is no longer true.

However, if the idea of a real devil is being lost to sight, then its counterpart is still alive and well. Most adherents to church still hope for heaven and the thing that gives them that hope is the belief in a realist god. The situation can now be seen to be out of balance ; for it would appear that only one side of the argument is being considered. Perhaps universalist ideas are in part to blame for this state of affairs.

There is a streak of universalism, so I'm told, in Wesley's 44 Sermons. Allegedly compulsory reading for all trainee local preachers in the Methodist Connexion. For if god is eventually to save all his children, by a means not yet clear, why should they worry about hell ? So we forget hell and try to encourage people to be good, so that they will go to heaven.

Here we have a paradox. Originally the whole object of the exercise was to save people from hell ; let's qualify that - the whole object according to the early fathers was to save people from hell. They gave us the myth of god incarnate, whose death and resurrection on our behalf, by faith, saves us from our sins for eternal life. Yet James comes along and tells us that faith without works is dead ; and a dead faith will save nobody so we busy ourselves with good works, to the degree at which it appears to be in contravention of Paul's words to the Ephesians. Now that line of argument is a bit specious, but the point is to illustrate that the first principles on which the early church set out to conquer the world are gradually receding in the intensity in which they are held ; or to put it another way, theyare not as true as they used to be.

For all the fact that, particularly at communion/ mass/eucharist, the traditional words are used, their meaning is being interpreted ; they are seen as symbolic ; they are being softened to the point at which it is the lifestyle that is adopted which is more important than what the individual holds as a particular set of doctrines above all else. One should love one's neighbour, even if one's god is not what she used to be. And those of a non-realist or radical persuasion, and have got there through or despite church and Christian influence, wish that those in the church for whom they hold such an affection would cut the umbilical cord, and as they see it, stand on their own feet. However, as stated at the outset, the non-realist has to take a tolerant view, on principle, not having claim to an absolute truth with which to beat people about the ears. Hence she/he can only quietly put a point of view and wait and watch.

Earlier it was suggested that to say that the church has an absolute truth to proclaim and that it will not have anything else is a bit harsh. It is a bit harsh when you consider those of the calibre of say, John 16 SOF Magazine 8, Winter 1991-92 Robinson or David Jenkins. Liberal theology has unhooked itself from a lot of the things that push people in the non-realist/radical direction. But it has not yet trusted itself to the void. God still retains his otherworldliness, and is real. The debate between the liberal and the radical hangs, to some degree, on how the evidence is interpreted.

Both agree that some things can be treated as myth ; and largely both would support the work done by critical biblical scholarship in helping to sort out what is reliable and what is not, as far as the Christian story is concerned. For the Christian non-realist still draws on that story for a lot of the material with which he/she will work, even though the choice is selective and is not exclusively biblical. In fact the more scholarly of the radicals will pull ideas from a wide range of sources. Perhaps this is why some of them distance themselves from the liberals, as they see the liberal taking too narrow a view, constrained by the limits of scripture ; whereas radicals will survey the human state and trace the march of human thought, drawing from the great thinkers of every age. It is not without significance that the leading figure of radical/ non-realist thought in this country earns his daily crust lecturing in the Philosophy of Religion, while still being a Church of England priest.

For where the traditional Christian teaching draws on the ideas of Plato and Aristotle, and has not really shifted for nigh on 2000 years, the radical will take account, as far as she/he is able to keep up with it, of current philosophical and religious thought. And the question comes, which is true ? I would argue that the balance must come down on the side of the radical if for no other reason than the current state of knowledge is far greater than in the day of Plato and Aristotle. What would they have been saying if they had been able to study in the equivalent of a modern day Cambridge ? And we must not think that we have got to the final truth for one thing is certain and that is that the more we learn the more we realise that we know comparatively little. Hence the idea of achieving knowledge of absolute truth becomes a will o' the wisp.

In a sense truth is like a snap-shot of the moment. It is true at that point in time and often at that point in time only. An obvious example would be if I were to say that I am 55 years, 3 months, 28 days, 7 hours, 3 minutes and 57 seconds old ; by the time the typewriter keys have hit the paper it is no longer true.

Clearly it is a matter of degree. The world was thought to be flat for a long time before it was thought of as round, and even that term is relative, for it is no sphere. But even at such an extended time scale there is movement. You can see that yet again we are moving back to the discussion on how we use words and language. And truth is only what is understood to be true in that culture, at that time, and in that place. Things are always on the march. The only thing that seems to display any degree of permanence is mathematics and even that I would treat with caution.

So Jesus stands before Pilate, and claims to be bearing witness to the truth. Pilate, on the other hand, stands out as a man before his time, and asks what truth is. Perhaps he was wiser than he was given credit for.

HAROLD STEEL is an engineer in Suffolk.