ENJOYING THE NIGHTMARE Aileen La Tourette Writer Aileen La Tourette was Chair of the SoF Steering Committee until last year, when the demands of her prison commitments forced her to stand down. We asked her to write about her new work behind bars.
Reading the transcripts of the 1992 SoF Conference is - what? A wash of affection and impatience. The affection part is obvious, it has to do with people, recognisable voices. This has become, in five years, something of a family reunion. But family reunions also mean rage - in my experience; and a pressure to grow up and go away.
What changes? Mostly, one's language. One no longer speaks the same language as the tribe left behind. All those windy abstractions are no use, and not even beautiful. One begins to mutter to oneself, sotto voce: But I never did speak their language, I was always an outsider.
And, and... Look how the patriarchs hold forth. It begins to seem that anything, anywhere, of a vaguely churchy designation will be, by definition, male supremacist, regardless of how ill- or undefined it may be, otherwise. The rest of us are sort of there for entertainment, clowns, a sideshow. The centre remains the same, untouched and untouchable.
Harsh words. And this isn't meant to be a diatribe about SoF, but a piece about the work I am presently engaged in as Playwright in Residence at Ford Prison. I am controlling my tendency to play to the gallery here, to be as comical as I can be about the absurdity of prison and prison life and writer-in-residency. But I am beginning to see that sometimes it's a mistake to encourage people not to take you seriously. It's a way of deflecting criticism, a way of creating space for oneself, and it's fun. But it can be cowardice, too.
So, OK, this is serious; like my criticism of SoF, from which I have stood back since the Conference, due to this troubling job at Ford. The Conference, the holiday that followed it, seem very, very far away. I need another holiday. Instead I have the tender nightmare of the Christmas Panto to look forward to, in which I am appearing as Mary (Mary, Quite Contrary). Can I really write about this seriously?
My life is a fascinating nightmare. Quite by "accident", out of dire poverty and seeing an ad in a local paper, I taught creative writing and drama at Belmarsh Prison in Woolwich, South London, last year. Belmarsh is Cat. B: closed, fairly high security. It also has an A wing for top-security prisoners, which is a separate, sealed world. I taught men who had robbed, raped, battered and killed. I learned that a man who has raped women up and down the country can still hold forth about the evils of homosexuality, and how all "them" should be done away with. I learned that my casual assumptions and assessments of people from appearance and speech were wildly inaccurate, that the angel-faced man with high cheekbones like wings and the charm of an unspoilt child could turn out to be an axe murderer.
Ford is an open prison. It's where the Guiness mob went, where white-collar criminals usually end up after a hitch in Wandsworth or Brixton just to put the fear of god into them. Many of the men I work with are white, middle-class, well-educated, articulate. They are immediately closer to me, culturally, than the majority of the men at Belmarsh.
This creates an immediate problem. I am not distant enough from them. I am not distant at all. The role of writer in residence is a far more open-ended one than tutor. I can be myself, whatever that may be on any given day (or in any given minute).
There isn't any firm role to hold me in place like a corset. And I swear to Playtex, I often wish there were. Because it's much, much harder, being so close. I fall in and out of love with individual men.
Prison is a very romantic situation, and I am nothing if not romantic. Which means, to me, kind of stupid, moronic even, in a rather lyrical way. Here they are, all these men, with their lives in ruins, cut off from their wives and families and jobs. And here am I, staying at my little bed and breakfast for two nights, three days, cut off from mine. What a disaster.
So, yes, it has to be funny. But even as I undercut myself, I feel the underlying sadness, and I hope that comes across. Prison is a sad waste of human energy and potential. For me, because I try to reach and rescue some sense of possibility, self-worth and self-esteem, and often, oftener than I want to know, the results are all too much like working with the elderly in advanced dementia, which I have also done. That is, the results you get are fleeting and momentary and you must simply believe that a few minutes of lucid living, connected to other people, are worthwhile, that those few minutes justify the effort you make. Because you're not going to get anything else, anything lasting.
Saddest, maybe - and very germane to what I do at Ford - is the way that people form hierarchies. This is the main lesson of the last two years. Three people together will be a class system in ten minutes. Sort them out. The fraudsters look down on the burglars, drug dealers and street criminals. They complain that these days a worse class of con ends up at Ford, and they mean it. It sounds funny, and it is; but it is also serious, because it is so entrenched, so deeply rooted.
Drama, which I teach, is all about status. Any play can be analysed in terms of status changes.
Someone always falls from high to lower, someone always rises.
Comedy, likewise, starting with the banana-skin. The Christian myth, I suppose, could be interpreted as a series of falls and rises, ending with the triumph of the Ascension.
These men have all fallen and are constantly trying to rise, to assert an ascendancy over someone else. Obviously I am one kind of target and there is great delight when I fall, as I frequently do. So what do I do there? I run workshop after workshop. I try to coax out what's there, try and get tidbits of creativity, moments which surprise people, moments in which they surprise themselves. And yes, that's worth it. A twenty-year-old kid, a lifer who shot someone dead, because he was drunk, stands back, says he can't act, then finds himself acting without noticing; that face is astonishingly alive and astonishingly lovely. I did a workshop, years ago now, with a woman I didn't appreciate at the time, due to appearances.
But one thing she said (and was roundly mocked for) remains with me. "I believe," said Ruby, "we all have infinite potential". I agree, and that is what infinity has become for me: the infinity of human potential, infinite in quality rather than quantity.
Bottomless seconds.
I have been churlish about the men, I note, probably because I am so involved with them. They are warm and funny and sexy; and one of the things I try to do is acknowledge sexuality, which in prison is so denied. It isn't easy to find a way, the situation is delicate and fraught. But it is better than pretending.
I have my heart broken every week. Not romantically, though sometimes it comes close. But personally, for the odds against these guys... for the way they wait and wait while a filthy system makes them sweat out their parole date, often going past it and then releasing them, just like that, always keeping them on tenterhooks - a provocation for the most volatile to explode and so lose their chance of freedom... for the jobs they won't get now... for the stigma that won't go away... for the shocking, offhand remarks the screws make about them... for the shocking attitude of everyone in the system, from the governors down.
I felt for a long time as if I were in a hall of mirrors, unable to distinguish reality from reflection, or, more particularly, from projection. The staff - without exception - described the men to me as sly, manipulative conmen, on the make, out to "get" me - and everybody. The men were just men. I have come down on their side, heavily.
It is necessary to decide. My decision is that in this hall of mirrors it is a mirror-game that people - and societies - play. "They" become a projection of everything we disown about ourselves. It sounds terribly simple, and it is. Terribly. Not that they are incapable of slyness, manipulation, etc., of course. Are you? Am I? That's all there is to it. Of course they have, at least once in their lives, taken it one step further, gone over a boundary - and got caught. That's the sole difference. And their attempt was a failure - a fact people forget in demonising them. They don't forget.
There is no conclusion here. More and more, I feel all I can do is describe as accurately and originally as possible. Never prescribe. That comes very hard to me. I'm not saying these endless hierarchies are "good" or "bad". I'm saying they exist, they form and re-form, and we need to look at them, to see who they help and who they hinder. It seems to be the same mob, somehow, who always end up in charge, wherever you (I) go. And so we play the fool, we subvert and send up and chip away, knowing all the time, if we're smart, that this may be all there is, so we'd better enjoy the fascinating nightmare while it lasts.
A momentary and you must simply believe that a few minutes of lucid living, connected to other people, are worthwhile, that those few minutes justify the effort you make. Because you're not going to get anything else, anything lasting.