IRIS MURDOCH ON DON CUPITT his Murdoch is sometimes linked with Don Cupitt in the shared conviction that religion is a human creation rather than a supernatural phenomenon. But her philosophical approach is quite different from Cupitt's. The author of 24 novels and a Fellow of St Anne's College, Oxford, since 1948, where for many years she taught philosophy, she remains an unapologetic Platonist, wary of and hostile to modern assaults on her beloved Greek guru, particularly attacks in deconstructionist mode. Her new book, Metaphysics as a Guide to Morals, will nevertheless be of great interest to SoF members. Consider the questions raised in the publisher's blurb (which she surely wrote herself): "What is morality after all, is it important, is it true, can it be taught in schools, is it the very basis of our existence, or is it just one of many peripheral matters?...
Has not religion always meant intolerance and strife as well as false belief, can it now survive in the West without a personal God?... Can a mystical Christ stay with us without the many implications of God as a person?... It is time for a dialogue between moral philosophy and a demythologising theology... Is not our consciousness moral consciousness, and are not our lives moral lives?" Iris Murdoch admires Cupitt without yielding an inch of philosophical ground to him. Of his insistance that we should be "putting spirituality first and God second", and of his statement that "God is, quite simply, what the religious requirement comes to mean to us as we respond to it. A religion is a cluster of spiritual values" (Taking Leave of God p98, 1980), she comments: "These arc lucid and moving statements, I like and respect the 'high and orthodox emphasis' upon divine transcendence. And that the divine is above the gods (as in Buddhism and Platonism). Yet the point to which the speaker is driven seems unnecessarily extreme. We posit an unknown God; religion (and indeed God), which we have chosen as 'better' is our personal spiritual striving toward the ultimate goal of free spirit. A subjectivist non-cognitive philosophy of will separates spirituality from knowledge. No myths, no idols. The less we know of God the more spiritual we are made to become.
Religion is thus secluded and purified, separated from the world of fact and science, and from the old illusions. This may indeed be a possible form of personal theism.
Voluntarism seeks autonomy, human potential, freedom.
These arc good things; but..." And many buts follow. To Iris Murdoch, "the idea of choosing the spiritual or religious as (an item among others) better, seems oddly abstract". And what about "the difference between the sophisticated and the unsophisticated worshipper"? "The picture of Religion as a 'cluster of values' suggests a corner, a place among places, a thing among things," she continues. But "we have not been driven out of a brightly coloured mythical world which now belongs to a false illusioned past, leaving us with many facts, an imageless striving will and an expressive language. We still live in the old familiar mysterious world and explain and clarify and celebrate it in the old endlessly fertile and inventive modes of speech. We enjoy the freedom of a moral imagination. The idea of 'the world as full of images of God and hierarchies pointing to God' is, as I see it, fundamental in religion and (mutatis mutandis) in morality. I think this is what (if we put Good for God) the world is full of! The affirmative way, which can find the divine everywhere in all the desire-driven burrowings of cognition, relates spirituality to the whole of our being".
One would suppose that Cupitt's later books would seem even more "extreme" to Iris Murdoch, but she finds his "brave and ferocious" Radicals and the Future of the Church contains "many sayings which I like and respect". Some examples (as she summarises them): `We must learn to think of God in a new way, not as an object, not as a person' "Religion concerns everything in life, it is not just an occasional or special matter. We have to learn to think of God in a new way, not as an object, not as a person. That there is no God is also God... Cupitt, in this respect like Buber, insists upon the retention of the word 'God', while suggesting various ways in which it can be filled with sense". But, predictably, she is "not so happy with Cupitt's attitude to Plato and to philosophy generally", seeing in his reference to Plato's "wholly unjustified and superstitious supernaturalism" a misunderstanding of his philosophy. "However, in spite of these few contentious matters I think Cupitt is a very brave and valuable pioneer and a learned and accessible thinker, who stirs up thought where it is most needed. He speaks directly, as few do, about the necessity of new thinking about God and religion as something which concerns us all." The dialogue for which she calls, between moral philosophy and a demythologising theology, has begun. - D.B.
Metaphysics as a Guide to Morals, by Iris Murdoch. Chatto & Windus, £20.