Resurrection

SOF MAGAZINE 6, SUMMER 1991 RESURRECTION Stuart Jenkins Two articles about the Resurrection in SOF Magazine's Spring issue betray a more than seasonal interest in this most challenging of Christian stories.

The Resurrection is something of a test case for radicals and liberals. There are many lesser miracles one may feel free to doubt. The doctrine of the Incarnation can survive our disbelief in the Virgin Birth, and water into wine is no more than an illustrative device, but it is often felt that the whole of the Christian faith hangs on the Resurrection. it is curious to notice that in fact the Resurrection is strangely redundant, in that without it most of Christianity can remain intact. Certainly a traditional evangelical faith has little need of it. Think of the Good Friday hymns which set out a full salvation based entirely on the death of Christ. Without Resurrection you can still have forgiveness, faith, redemption and a new relationship with God. No specific doctrine appears to depend on it, yet it seems to underwrite the whole of faith.

The Resurrection is probably too big an event to be described as a miracle. It belongs with two other divine actions that are not merely local in effect but are constitutive of the nature of reality.

The first of these is Creation itself. Interestingly, Genesis does not describe creation out of nothing in the normal sense of the phrase. God is described as tidying up, separating the water to reveal the land already waiting beneath it, and putting light and dark in separate sections of the clock, though, since God achieves this through speech-acts it would count as creation out of nothing for Don Cupitt. The formless (because un-named) matter only exists in a meaningful sense when God has addressed and ordered it.

The second constitutive divine action is the covenant after the Flood. Childhood's boat full of animals has probably led us to downgrade this story, but it is important enough to occupy four chapters in Genesis and is referred to several times in the New Testament. It is God's great global intervention in the world, and it is immediately regretted. God vows to adopt a hands-off approach in future, guaranteeing the laws of nature, and symbolizing his covenant with the rainbow, an appropriately straightforward reminder of the dependability of physical properties.

Third is the Resurrection. Resurrection, even Mark's minimalist version, speaks above all of an end to all finality and certainty. The dead Jesus continues to speak new words to his disciples. On the Emmaus road, it is shown that even the final judgement on his life is open to reinterpretation. Death itself, the epitome of finality, is punctured. The tomb, death's symbol, is not merely empty but open. Resurrection is like a tear in the fabric of the world, a breach in the natural order. Nothing again can be completely finished. Even "dead and buried" has become a relative term.

To apply the categories of natural and supernatural to the Resurrection is to find them impossibly blended in a way that fatally compromises both. The Risen Christ passes triumphantly through the grave clothes yet pauses to carefully fold the napkin. He enters locked rooms and snacks on fish. By the lake he is unrecognized by his disciples who dare not ask who he is "because they all knew it was the Lord".

The Resurrection makes the Gospels impossible books to finish - they cannot tolerate a last page.

Matthew ends with a watch-this-space "Lo, I am with you ...". John neatly rounds off in Chapter 20 but can't resist adding a few more pages. Mark stops in mid-flow and makes us wonder if there's a bit missing. Luke leads straight on to his inconclusive sequel, Acts of the Apostles, where he has another go at wrapping up the story of Jesus and leaves us with a ridiculous final view of Jesus literally ascending to the metaphorical heights.

Resurrection also paves the way for Pentecost, which Don Cupitt has described as the dispersal of God.

The Spirit, previously reserved for use at God's discretion, now becomes a universal benefit given to each and every disciple.

We shouldn't worry about the Resurrection as if it were the one bitter literalist pill Christianity requires us to swallow. It is in fact foundational for the open-textured world in which we wish to live. It is the third great constitutive act of God. Having made the world and given it autonomy he now relinquishes his hold on final truth and authority, not by giving it into our control, but by setting it free. Truth now has its own history. Faith leads not to obedience to God, nor to us becoming God, but to a partnership with him, called by Paul, the fellowship of the Holy Spirit.

STUART JENKINS is a Baptist minister in London.