AUTUMN 1990 PAGE 13 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE WHAT IS THERE TO READ BESIDES CUPITT ? (2) by Basil Youdell My brief for this was that the cry was often heard 'What else is there to read besides Don Cupitt ?".
One easy answer to this question is that those who do read Cupitt will be aware that oftentimes Don supplies clear indications in the footnotes of his books regarding the works that have stimulated and influenced his thinking and readers would do well to follow those leads ; a number of the books and authors which follow are thus mentioned by Don and will (or should !) be familiar to religious radicals already.
The second caution I received was that this journal is intended for 'plain folks'. Whilst I am encouraged to think that such will be reading this publication, I feel that those who are capable of reading and appreciating DC should be able to take a crack at some serious philosophy - indeed, in order to find one's way around the postmodernist religious world it is hard to appreciate how one is to avoid facing the challenge to acquaint oneself with the thinking which has shaped and defined the (albeit somewhat fluid !) parameters of this world.
Metaphysics may be defunct, but it is hard to appreciate where we are now if we fail to appreciate where we have been, where we have come from. A 'reading list' for those who are not trained in the history of philosophy and ideas and the interpenetrative effect which they have had on religious thinking, Christian or otherwise, is perhaps something which could be provided for interested readers in a future issue. For the present then - a few books which provide a 'read around' Don Cupitt for those who are content to kick a few ideas around.
SEA OF FAITH NETWORK If you're interested in the kind of ideas expressed in this magazine and are not already associated with SOF, why not contact our Mailing List Secretary ?
Ronald Pearse 45 Middleton Place LOUGH BOROUGH Le ics LE11 2BY The influence of Ludwig Wittgenstein on modern theology has been rather more profound than many are prepared to admit. Actually reading Wittgenstein can be difficult not only because of the complexity of his thought but because of the rather idiosyncratic and disconnected medium in which he chose to present his ideas. The 'early' Wittgenstein is interesting, but it is perhaps the 'later' Wittgenstein whose absolute assault on the idea that language is describing any inherent reality, which really holds the attention of religious radicals. In the same way that artists do not, on the whole, regard their work as that of being mere copyists of nature, so Wittgenstein does not see language as merely a means of describing a fixed nature, whose perfect prototype exists in some neo-Platonist, metaphysical 'out there'.
Readers can, I'm sure, readily appreciate the implications of this on theology. I would therefore commend the following books by Wittgenstein : 1.Philosophical Investigations 2.On Certainty 3.Lectures_and Conversations on Aesthetics, Psychology_and Religious Belief These are all published by Basil Blackwell, Oxford, in paperback.
Another recent book which will prove of interest to readers is Theology_after Wittgenstein by Fergus Kerr (Blackwell) which not only provides an excellent introduction to Wittgenstein's thought but also traces the influence of Wittgenstein on modern theology.
Don Cupitt is given a critical assessment in this book together with other well known names such as Hans Kung.
The philosophical perspective known as 'deconstructionism' has by his own admission had a profound effect on DC's thinking. It is therefore appropriate that a few books relating to this area should be included, with especial reference to the best known name in the field, Jacques Derrida - though he is by no means the only writer in this area. An excellent introduction is available in the 'Continental Philosophy' series entitled Dercida_and _Deconstruction (Routledge) which considers Derrida's method in relation to some of the great architects of western thought including Plato, Meister Eckhart (of whom more later), Descartes, Hegel, Nietzsche, Freud and Foucault etc, edited by Hugh J Silverman. Derrida himself can be read in Deconstruction and Philosophy_L_The_T_exts of PAGE 14 AUTUMN 1990 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE Jacques_Derrida edited by John Sallis (Univ. of Chicago Press). Also helpful is Deconstruction • Theoryand Practice by Christopher Norris (Routledge) ; as is the 'Fontana Modern Masters' volume Derrida by the same author.
The writer and philosopher Iris Murdoch will no doubt be familiar to our readers - many of her novels present a profoundly humanistic religious view and her work has influenced Cupitt. Two of her philosophical works also deserve attention : Acastos Two Platonic Dialo_gu_e_s (Penguin) and IheSovereignty of Good (Routledge).
Moral Philosophy, Ethics and Aesthetics become of vital interest in thinking through a non-realist approach to religious faith - all reading lists are of their nature subjective, but the following books have certainly intrigued and stimulated the present writer Aw"- and are offered as mere suggestions :
IP" The View from Nowhere - Thomas Nagel - (OUP) Amythia; Crisisdatheilatural History_of Western Culture - Loyal D. Rue - (Univ. of Alabama) French Feminist Thought : A Reader - ed Torii Moi - (Blackwell) After Virtue - A Macintyre - (Duckworth) Reat_Eresences : Is there anything in what wesayi - George Steiner - (Faber) The Religious Significance of Atheism - Macintyre & Ricoeur - (Columbia Univ.
Press) Reflexivity • The Po_stmodern_predicament - Hilary Lawson - (Hutchinson) Reasons and_Parsons - Derek Parfit - (OUP) Structuralist Interpretations of_Biblicalllyth - Leach & Aycock - (CUP) Go_d is silence - Pierre Lacout - (Quaker Home Service) Beyond Existentialism and Zen - Rupp - (OUP) The whole area of Christian encounter with other religious traditions - the multi-faith and pluralistic perspective, so to say, has enormous ramifications for radical Christians. Any of the books by Bede Griffiths are excellent reading, especially his latest A New Visiort_o_f_Beality_LWestern Science, Eastem_Mysticism and Christian Faith (Collins). Also worth reading is Hans Kung's Christianity and World Religions (Fount).
Probably the most fruitful and productive dialogue in the field is that between Christians and Buddhists ; indeed the overall, long term effects of this may be as significant as that between neo-Platonism and Christianity in forging an altogether new philosophical vehicle for religious faith. The following are very significant and worthwhile books.
The silence of God:. The Answer of the Buddha - Raimundo Panikkar - (Orbis) The _Emplinessof Emptiness_LAn Introduction to Earlyindian_Madhyamika - C.W. Huntington - (Univ of Hawaii Press) Religion-and Nothingness - Keiji Nishitani - (Univ. of California Press) Absolute Nothingness foundations for a Buddhist:Christian Dialogue - Hans Waldenfels - (Paulist Press) Difficult though it is, how I wish readers might consider an original Buddhist text with commentary :
Nagarjuna's_Seventy Stanzas • A Buddhist_P_sychology of Emptiness - David Ross Komito (Snow Lion Books). This may open up a completely different philosophical perspective for many - do have a go at it !
To conclude ; Journey_into the_Eye of a Needle by Maurice Ash (Green Books) offers a magnificent study of the renaissance of religious consciousness which elevates the human spirit of creativity. The rediscovery of the thirteenth century theologian and mystic Meister Eckhart is my choice for 'spirituality' and offers a traditional, yet radical and apophatic, stream of spiritual life for many. DC's book Taking Leave of God takes its title from Sermon 57 of Eckhart and I commend the three volume collection of his Sermons and Treatises trans. and ed. by M. 0' C.
Walshe (Element Books).
I hope this brief survey of books will prove both rewarding and stimulating to readers.
BASIL YOU DELL is a Lutheran minister in London and is a book reviewer for a number of specialist periodicals. He takes a particular interest in Inter-Faith, especially Buddhism.