On Silence

ON SILENCE by Klaus Heinrich I'm entering into the Sea of Faith debate with some trepidation, coming to problems of faith, meaning and ethics, not as a theologian but with my roots in another discipline : analytical psychotherapy. It's there that my comments on silence have their beginnings, since what we do in therapy (and in counselling) is to learn the imperfectible art of listening : an 'active stillness' : silent for the other.

Radical theology seems to have little time for silence.

To an extent this is absolutely right. Cupitt's agenda (Radicals and the Future of The Church) is active, extrovert, anti-authoritarian, debunking above all the use of silence as a tool of power. And the agenda can be gregarious without being simply garrulous. Clive Richards takes the discussion a bit further in the first SOF magazine (Spring 1990) : "Radicals should be suspicious of overvaluing silence in the context of prayer.

Non-verbal stillness be relaxing but smacks of the expectation of the transcendent, of waiting for the absent God to speak." I think we come close here to the archetypal problem of any new movement : that of throwing the baby (or is it the Baby ?) out with the bathwater. The driving intellectualism of theological debate is in danger of undervaluing experience - in this case, what happens in silent prayer. The experience must be given due weight, but is not of course some sort of pure, unanalysable giveness : what happens in the silence depends on the tradition of prayer, or on the culture, which embraces you in that moment. I would argue, however, that this is more worthy of radical scrutiny than of dismissal.

Take for instance the experience which St. Theresa invites us to : notice Christ looking at you, lovingly and humbly. To rest in the contemplation of that look is a profoundly transformational experience. I feel differently as a result of it ; I feel a shift in my being, strengthened by repetition. 'Deconstruct' this bit of holy ground. Fantasy ? Well, yes : with a whole tapestry of culture and myth to tap into and enrich the experience. And perhaps this is how we might interpret Christ's words, "I am with you always".

Is the experience 'just imagination' ? Well, yes ... but why 'just' ? Psychotherapy (amongst other disciplines) has a great deal to say about how powerful 'imagination' is - how we construct our personal realities from past experience, and find them obdurately unyielding to change until the right word or symbol or insight at the right moment has its transformational effect. And perhaps there's a cornSUMMER 1990 PAGE 15 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE rnentary here on the experience of forgiveness as transformational. And on the power of faith. Faith is as strong as your construction of 'reality' with it.

In a completely different tradition of silent prayer, Buddhist Vipissana, meditation works you towards another kind of 'deconstruction' of consciousness. By disciplined concentration on the flow of awareness 'here and now', the notion of 'self' as experiencing subject, coherent, in time, begins to dissolve. This detachment from 'self' as a useful construct is perhaps an experiential counterpart to the current philosophical debate on 'self(e.g. Don Cupitt at SOF II).

Again nearer to home, David Paterson, in "Talking to a Lizard" (SOF Magazine, Spring 1990), breaks a silence about an experience where, whatever else he might have said, he had "a powerful sense of being filled with something far greater than myself". Significantly, both he and the lizard say no more about it ; some experiences best do their work in silence. The article is however a testimony to the effect of the experience : "when considering why I think, feel or act the way I do, this experience is what comes to mind".

And perhaps it's the ethical outcome which is crucial in each of these situations : the difference it makes to my relationship with you. Radical theology, like any other vigorous myth-making, or demythologising activity, is looking for 'right relationship' with life, the Universe and all that. Part of any such right relationship, it seems to me, is silent awe in the Void.

Radical theology (like any other) has to take me to that emptiness - construed with St.Theresa or deconstructed with the Buddha - to leave me open to creative, new, untrammelled response, in the emptiness to you.

KLAUS HEINRICH is student counsellor at Loughborough College.