MOVING ON AND FINDING A PLACE by Adrian Worsfold. Here is just a history of how my radical ideas developed, where they came from, and how they related to religious institutions I met. I was always opposed to the way my Hull school (ordinary comprehensive, but with a self-image made by its grammar school past) used religion as a tool of social discipline and official ideology. I had no home church background and saw churches as like architectural museums. I was aware of an Anglican vicar in our area who acted, I thought, like a squire. Yuck.
In 1980 I did however, through some school friends, come into contact with a Methodist young person's Fellowship Group and I was the atheist-agnostic there. I quite liked the subject but could never understand their official beliefs. But in 1982 I began a (terminated) MA away from home and warmed to a priest who seemed to have a different and tolerant approach. (Incidentally, I always say my ministry seeking began in 1982 and not later.) In 1984, now back in Hull, I read some liberal theology for my sociology of religion thesis and got back in contact with him. He had its kind of viewpoint. So did I, or at least I thought, and after the Methodist church barred me for creating too many doubts among its teenagers - and thus lost my potential membership - I soon was confirmed into the Church of England at university where they did not cover up theology. (That night I attended a Bahai group I) Soon Tillich, Robinson and all the rest seemed to be an enclosed system of circular doctrinal arguments, using existential and secular material as translation devices and no more. My priest guru, who described Cupitt as "subjective", turned out to be quite conservative and when eventually I moved to the Unitarians (the Bahais, about whom I began to discover a secret history, once used their building) he fell out. Thank you.
It was in 1982 when away that I went to a retreat at a convent. I really absorbed its worship of personal reflections, readings, poems and the silence that followed each contribution. Followed by a simple eucharist which I avoided but still liked. The Roman Catholics held their own, and disqualified all but their own, and they lacked imagination. Later, in 1984, it was one Methodist membership service with its silence as people went to communion that again was moving. A Quaker service had a similar effect, but only once.
So there were two forces at work - one was the personal intellectual pursuit of theology, put into sociological context for my eventual Ph.D., and the other was from silence and basic ritual in some form. I came to identify myself with a moderate Catholic approach and moved to a rural Anglican church where I reinterpreted the liturgies as they went along and saw the eucharist as a central drama of affirming the material and not dividing off the spiritual.
My theism always bobbed along the bottom and when it went the whole pack of cards was unsupported - such as Jesus' definitiveness. One day in 1985 I went to church and not unlike a bolt from heaven it was meaningless. Then followed about two years of transferring to Hull Unitarians, where full pluralism of belief was encouraged but where the front was mainly theist (my services were not) and its wordy spirituality was most unsatisfactory. But I still identified with ministry and I was accepted for training.
As I approached training we moved to Derbyshire and experienced more set and musical worship with a humanist minister in Sheffield. At this time a pointlessness dawned in terms of pursuing specific postChristian arguments. The Unitarian College in Manchester is pluralist but inside a Federation of Christians. I do not attend Federation worship (Unitarian students are the only ones who need not) and courses have been Unitarian. I am not happy with the fact that Manchester is the most conservative Unitarian area, and it creates something of a battle.
Much of it is ridiculously ancient in style.
Now my past is seen in the light of the present. I reckon I always was and still am a humanist Christianity was always a mirage. Playing with Christian arguments is a sheer waste of time, like dealing with museum artifacts. Its language is one of internalised superiority and macho-ness and I do not think I am the only one to see it this way.
I just cannot seem to get into Eastern religions (like my College principal has) and when I do they are too linked to reincarnation belief. Occasionally Buddhist and Hindu insights are useful for readings and meditations in church. I have found some, but not all, Pagan language useful for visual ritualistic elements when I take services. It seems to be a deep polytheistic language and style open to non-realism (because it is so obviously mythical), ecology and feminism, and is culturally home grown.
SUMMER 19t)() PAGE 14 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE Unitarianism has its contradictions between its stated freedom to believe and worship as conscience dictates and the traditions of churches and individual ministers who speak in them, and between the national level which has to be fully pluralist and the local level which may specialise. I affirm it, though, because I may not think in the future as I do now and because I believe the human process of religious thought and experience is more important than any particular position held. I also think non-subscription is more honest. So I will not subscribe, even to a Sea of Faith position, nor exclude any others hoping to genuinely search. Thus I stay where I am despite the frustrations of so doing, and hope to build my corner amongst all the other corners, along models set by some British and American churches.
Freedom is important. For example, within the Federation, my Unitarianism has allowed me to be completely open. Others who share radical views told me in time, and a small grouping developed. I have also found students with doubts talking to me in private because, I have been told, I will not reply in theological code words that disguise where the person is who is talking to them. That freedom is solely due to my denominational allegiance.
Unitarians are about to be marginalised in the new ecumenical instruments. I say let them do it. The Sea of Faith Network is an alternative and wider 'ecumenical' gathering that can help non-realism develop intellectually and I also see it as a way of boosting people's preparedness to be open. For me, whilst I must say that Christianity is a crippled, closed, authoritarian language, general non-realism is the base for religion in the future, as it is for understanding social sciences and science. I promote these views in the Unitarians in co-operation and competition with other views, and support their spread elsewhere.
So here I am, and here I've come. That is all so far, but there is bound to be more.
ADRIAN WORSFOLD is training for the Unitarian ministry in Manchester.