Patti Whaley reviews Jesus for the Non-Religious: Recovering the Divine at the Heart of the Human by John Shelby Spong HarperCollins (San Francisco). 2007. 336 pages. £14.99. ISBN: 978-0-06-076207-0 reviews It was with some trepidation that I set about reading this book. How would I, as a renegade Anglican layperson turned BHA member – albeit having spent the first 5 years of my life in S.E. London – relate to a scholarly account of urban ministry in Whitechapel?
I need not have worried. Kenneth Leech held my attention from the first with well-chosen quotations, good writing and a full appreciation of the historical context in and about which he was writing. The book is, I am persuaded, not only an exceptionally honest, open and self-critical account of his work based at St.
Botolph’s between 1990 and 2004 but also a particularly fine example of modern contextual theology.
The team ministry described happened in ‘a small inner city area, yet an area which is profoundly global, housing both the financial centre of the city, and the largest Bengali community in the world outside of the Indian subcontinent.’ The work followed very much in the Anglo-Catholic Socialist tradition and it seems to have been effective to a point, especially in the early years. Leech portrays a project whose underlying passion was the furtherance of political and social justice in the East End. Using the invaluable resource of a meticulously kept diary during the period, Leech details his progress and setbacks along the way. This man is thoroughly steeped in liberal Anglican theology and one is left in no doubt that this is the lens through which Leech views the world. From my personal angle I was surprised to find so much with which to identify. It was only with parts of chapters 7 and 9 that I felt particularly at variance with Leech when he stresses the paramount importance of a strong sacramental and prayer life.
During the period described Leech was genuinely living and working at the heart of the communities to which he was ministering. His accommodation was provided rent-free by the Diocese of London, but otherwise the St. Botolph’s Project and the Jubilee Group with which he was involved received no funding from either the C.of E. or the Government.
Leech thus enjoyed an enviable freedom and flexibility to respond to diverse and changing social needs. Leech comes across variously as a sensitive, caring and deeply reflective social observer who also enjoys meeting people and learning from them. He portrays himself as a good listener who is widely read and well-informed. His approach to inter-faith dialogue seems to display the same practicality as his approach to mental health problems and matters of bureaucracy, social, economic and political injustice.
He states (pp.126-7): …understanding between one faith and another depends on the ability to make an ‘analogy’ between something in one’s own tradition and something in that of ‘the other’. If this cannot occur, mutual understanding fails. It follows that rootedness in and fidelity to, one’s own tradition is a necessary prelude to, not per se an obstacle to, ‘dialogue with the other’. It may well be that the future of Christian-Muslim dialogue lies in the willingness of ‘conservative’ Christians to engage in it. ‘The other’ may be a person of different faith, or a person of no faith, a secular person. We need to engage with the saeculum but sub specie aeternitatis, to engage with this age according to the perspective of the eternal. For Christian theology is not a ‘religious dimension’ or a ‘department’ but a way of looking at the world as a whole.
Although there is little evidence in the book to show that Leech ever stepped outside the ‘safe zone’ and dared to talk theology with his contacts from other faiths and it is clear that Leech would not regard his Christianity as a wholly ‘human creation’, I admit that by the time I finished the book I had come to admire the author for his committed and sustained work at St. Botolph’s – without, it seems, having displayed undue and overt missionary zeal.
Indeed, I found myself wondering how a theologically radical attempt to work for social justice in such circumstances would differ in practice from the liberal one such as Kenneth Leech so effectively describes.
Penny Mawdsley was SoF Chair for 2006-7.
Reviewed by Penny Mawdsley. Published by Darton, Longman and Todd (London), 2006, 288 pages, £19.95, ISBN: 978-0232525717.