St Joan at the National Theatre in London

Penny Mawdsley reviews Doing Theology in Altab Ali Park byKenneth Leech Darton, Longman and Todd (London). 2006. 288 pages. £19.95. ISBN: 978-0232525717 reviews A great ash tree stands in my garden and for more than 40 years I’ve watched it through the changing seasons. Each summer squirrels chase around its trunk; foxes build dens under the tree’s shelter and sally forth to stalk the more vulnerable creatures; whilst their cubs, a new generation year by year, emerge from somewhere beneath the ground to play in the dawn light. Pale young leaves unfurl, to give renewed shelter or shade from the summer’s heat.

Occasionally, during a storm, a great branch will crash down from the tree, causing mayhem in the garden. Seeds spin to earth to be reborn as saplings. Leaf-mould enriches the soil. And so our shared memory of those who have lived before us will provide enrichment for future generations.

We know much of what our predecessors thought, about their fears, hopes and ambitions, through reading their letters, from family stories, war diaries and reminiscences, and there are some people whose lives were so extraordinary that we seem to know them, almost instinctively, through the legends held in our collective memory. Such a person was Jehanne D’Arc, born in 1412, who led the French to defeat the English army in 1429, was tied to a stake and burned to death as a heretic in 1431, declared innocent in 1456 and canonised as a saint as recently as 1920.

George Bernard Shaw’s greatest play, St. Joan, written when he was in his sixties, is revived this summer at the National Theatre in London. These performances at the National are, quite simply, theatre at its most thrilling. My own, somewhat waning, faith in the power of actors to move and excite an audience, has been restored after some years of increasing doubt and disappointment. The play’s young director, Marianne Elliott, seems to have an innate sense of what risks to take, and of what will work on stage. Her production is perfectly paced, from the high comedy of the scenes with the Dauphin, to moments of thrilling skill and excitement, where actors tumble, scenery swirls, and the music, by Joss Pook, insinuates or pounds out, with the beautiful voice of Melanie Pappenheim contributing an unearthly quality to the drama. There are scenes of almost unbearable poignancy, as when Joan realises that, even after her recantation, she will not be set free, but, instead, is condemned to ‘eat the bread of sorrow and drink the water of affliction’ to the end of her earthly days ‘in perpetual imprisonment.’ This was one of those rare but wonderful moments in a theatre when the audience becomes as one, united by the powerful emotion engendered by events on stage. The role of Joan is taken by Anne-Marie Duff, and I cannot imagine anyone better in the role. The various representatives of church and state are played by the members of the National Theatre Company with complete conviction and all are, praise be, audibly spoken.

Oliver Ford Davies, fine here as the Grand Inquisitor, seems to make a career of portraying religious heavies, having played the Cardinal Inquisitor in the recent National Theatre production of Galileo. Paul Ready is very funny as a neurotic and petulant Dauphin, whilst Angus Wright, as the Earl of Warwick, reminded me of one of those ex-public school army officers one sometimes hears being interviewed by John Humphrys on Radio 4’s Today Programme, confident men of war, who must attempt to justify the British presence in Iraq.

Joan, of course, recanted her earlier ‘confession’ and rather than suffer life-long imprisonment, chose, instead, to be burned at the stake as a heretic. The human struggle to achieve a state of grace continues, but whatever our religious, agnostic or humanist belief, we can only acknowledge that we are still, five hundred years later, far from achieving that goal.

Cicely Herbert is one of the trio who founded and continue to run PoemsontheUnderground.

Theatre review. Director: Marianne Elliott. Cast includes Anne-Marie Duff as Joan, Oliver Ford Davies, Paul Ready, Angus Wright.