Threading a Camel through the Eye of a Needle

Threading a Camel through the Eye of a Needle Stephanie Dowrick’s talk focused on happiness and attitude of mind.

It may not be immediately obvious what Tatler and Mike Apted’s movie, Amazing Grace, have in common. But reading one and viewing the other as I flew to The Good Life? conference I was struck by a couple of things. In Tatler I found a long complaint about how being rich and British is no longer enough.

All kinds of super-rich foreigners are apparently buying up what’s most desirable, driving the rest of ‘us’ – unselfconscious entitlement was quite evident here – to settle for second-best. Apted’s film, by contrast, is a bio-pic of William Wilberforce, the evangelical Christian who campaigned to end slave trading 200 years ago. The film dramatically shows what horrors emerge when human beings become mere economic units. It also shows how reluctant Wilberforce’s fellow MPs were to see the slaves as fully human because that would have a direct effect on the wealth of the British Empire – as well as their own personal spending power.

It is much easier to talk about theories of a good life or to deconstruct the idea of ‘goodness’ than to look bravely and simply at life itself. The reason for this is not sinister. We are conditioned to privilege ideas over personal experience. Discussing social or economic theories is often far less confronting than asking ourselves how we are ‘spending’ our own lives. Yet we can’t talk about the good life without also thinking about ourselves – living such a life (or not); without thinking about ‘good people’, good humour, good will and even a ‘good death’. Those categories are difficult to define. Nevertheless, we do know when life feels good, and that’s not always when things are going especially well.

We also know when someone is ‘good’. I don’t mean perfect and I am certainly not being moralistic.

Nevertheless, in the company of a good woman or man we are likely to feel expansive, accepted, trusting. We especially trust that the good person is capable of thinking about other people’s needs and interests. Unselfconsciously lifting our spirits, they are also lifting their own. ‘Goodness’ very quickly moves from the ‘goods’ that one can acquire to attitudes, behaviour and the sense of life’s meaning that they express.

Constant daily choices are creating the person we are becoming. Buddhists talk about ‘coming awake’, waking up to the freedom most of us have to make choices positively for the common good as well as our own. Acknowledging our interdependence with others is at the heart of a ‘good life’. So is utilising our power to affect other people’s lives positively. The quality of our everyday connections and communications will determine more than any other single factor whether or not we regard life as ‘good’.

Yet our choices are not made in a vacuum. Inner resources – like outer ones – are not shared equally.

Illness, hardship and especially mental and emotional suffering make the proverbial playing field very uneven indeed.

Structural changes towards a more just and humane outer world absolutely matter. In fact, the degree to which they matter becomes increasingly evident as people wake up to how their choices affect others as well as create the person they are becoming.

Acknowledging our interdependence with others is at the heart of a ‘good life’.

As long as we are on this Earth, each of us will need a sense of belonging; a sharing in the Earth’s wondrous beauty; aesthetic and sensual pleasures; work and social connections and the giving and receiving of love.

Quite correctly we are looking with urgency at environmental issues. Spiritual degradation, however, may be more fundamental still. The way we treat the planet starkly expresses how we treat or ‘use up’ one another. George Fox’s maxim is familiar: ‘Walk lightly on this earth, answering that of God in everyone.’ ‘That of God’ may be a loaded phrase for some (not for me!). Yet the meaning such an attitude gives to life is strikingly different from: ‘Use other people before you are used by them.’ Meaning, by the way, may not reveal purpose or ‘sense’. ‘The eye goes blind,’ said the Sufi poet Rumi, ‘when it only wants to see why.’ Retrieving meaning is often far more subtle. A story to demonstrate this comes from Viktor Frankl, not from the concentration camp experiences that he describes in Man’s Search for Meaning but from later in his life as an analyst:

An old man came to see Frankl crushed by the grief he felt following the death of his wife. Frankl gently asked how would it have been had he died first and his wife had been left alone. The old man burst out, ‘She would not have been able to bear it.’ And Frankl said, ‘You were able to spare her that.’ Frankl didn’t change the facts. The facts could not be changed. What he did change was the meaning the old man now gave to death, life and love. A compassionate view of suffering is also a choice. ‘Choice’ is restricted by our emotional health and wellbeing (one more reason to take them seriously) – but rather less by external circumstances than many of us might think. Choice is also conditioned by our habits, some so familiar we tell ourselves they are entirely natural. No matter how thoughtful we are, it may take a jolt to recognise how we are making choices and how they are shaping the way we see and especially respond to the world around us. A banal example. You are standing in a slow-moving queue and boiling with injustice. For all your fuming, the queue moves no faster. Or – you are standing in that same queue and you are not pleased, but you use the time to meditate or plan your holiday in Cumbria.

And the queue moves no more slowly.

As you progress in the queue, your emotions are leaking out, affecting those around you. And within yourself? Is your blood pressure rising dangerously?

Or are you refuelling? This is small example. But our lives are made up of countless small moments that don’t pass in a vacuum – which invites thoughts not only about choice but also about freedom.

Freedom is at the heart of a good life and a happy one. It offers a priceless sense of inner spaciousness and it cannot depend solely on external circumstances. It must depend largely on what we make of those circumstances. The familiar story of the second mile in Matthew’s gospel gives an example. Jews couldn’t refuse to carry the bags of a Roman soldier for a mile. But in Matthew 5:41 we see them urged to do this for two miles not one – a psychological exercise in personal power: one mile because you must, the second mile because you can.

In the West, life is often seen to be something that happens to us, good or bad, lucky or unlucky. We are often uneasy about our inner world and quick to belittle it. But that makes us less powerful and resilient than we could be, and certainly less effective in the world of affairs outside ourselves. Our inner levels of development are shaping not just how we see the world, but what we are literally responding to and also causing.

None of this is new. Epictetus, as just one example, had this to say: ‘Human beings are not disturbed by events (or things), but by the view they take of them.’ Which leads me rather neatly to the camel and the needle. Without your glasses, can you take your camel and thread it gently through the eye of a needle, thinking about heaven or the riches of life as you do so? Even imagining this can delight the mind, and delighting the mind is also part of a good life.

The human mind is a blazing mix of the conscious, the barely conscious, and the unconscious. It loves tricks and challenges. Boredom, staleness and a lack of creativity and freshness harm the mind and spirit.

They are literally depressing. So even if you cannot quite visualise a camel and needle you already know that your mind can take you places. And more. Each of us has about 50,000 thoughts a day. On a bad day, we may feel that we have the same thought 50,000 times. What we pay attention to matters.

By 2020 depression will be the greatest cause of illness globally. ‘With our thoughts,’ the Dhammapada tells us, ‘we create the world. What we are today comes from our thoughts of yesterday… our life is the creation of our mind… Even as rain breaks through a poorly thatched house, dangerous emotions will break through a poorly guarded mind.’ A ‘poorly guarded mind’ is not awake to its freedom to make choices.

The camel and needle story demonstrates the power of thought and imagination (and also humour – surely part of a good life?). But the second gift the story offers is no less valuable. It is about ‘clinging’ and especially what we choose to cling to.

We live in a world of things. We imbue things with magical powers and ‘cling’ not so much to them but to the emotions we associate with them. Experience tells us otherwise, but don’t we at least sometimes tell ourselves that one more ‘something’ will finally land us in the land of happiness? The envy that surrounds the cult of celebrity is not about talent; often there is no talent. It is about the purchasing power that makes a ‘no one’ into ‘some one’. Yet we live in times that are curiously anhedonic.

In 1996 the World Health Organisation identified clinical depression as among the top five conditions affecting disability and reduced life expectancy. Now it is predicted that by 2020 depression will be the greatest cause of illness globally. We have never been richer. Yet gratitude, satisfaction and contentment continue to be precarious. Don’t get me wrong.

Money can buy some necessary and marvellous things. Poverty is crushing. But after even significant leaps in purchasing power, alarmingly quickly your happiness ‘set-point’ will drift to its customary level.

Your happiness set point, by the way, depends about 50% on genes, and about 15% on social circumstances.

That leaves lots of room for your own attitudes and behaviour. And it is attitude that you can most significantly change, sometimes in a single moment.

A reliable sense that life is good – despite the suffering that is also part of transient existence – can be achieved only through a change of heart as well as mind. That shift may reflect the kind of religious expression which Don Cupitt describes as a ‘universal, non-fixated… love for life, for our world, and for one’s fellow human’ so passionate that one should, to use Don’s word, ‘burn’. (The Way to Happiness, p24) This calls for change from the inside out, in how we value life itself – not our status, marketability or possessions. Which takes us back to the camel and needle.

That familiar story is not saying that rich people’s lives are intrinsically of less value.

It pushes all of us to notice what we value life for. In a world where external wealth is worshipped and spiritual wealth is often belittled, it is all too easy to fix our gaze in the wrong direction. In 21st-century life money matters every bit as much as it did when Wilberforce was seeking to end slavery. So it’s a nice irony that the key ingredients of a good life cannot be bought or sold and that a genuinely good life is likely also to be happy. Treating other people well whether or not they are ‘useful’, believing in something greater than yourself, cultivating good humour, doing some things for joy rather than profit, shielding the vulnerable, cherishing connections and tolerating differences, resolving conflict rather than accelerating it, recognising your interdependence with all life forms: these small daily choices can seem ludicrously unimportant. Yet they are among the key factors that determine life as ‘good’.

They will lift your spirits and those of everyone around you. They will positively affect the society we are collectively creating.

Two tiny stories to finish:

A few years ago I was in Ahmedabad visiting the ashram of Mahatma Gandhi and found in a large blow-up in Gandhi’s own handwriting this truth:

My life is my message.

The other story is from my book Forgiveness and Other Acts of Love. It’s about three stonecutters employed on the building of a cathedral in medieval times. When the first was asked what he was doing he said, angrily, ‘As you see, I am cutting stones.’ The second man was asked the same question. His reply was, ‘I am earning a living for my family.’ The third man took time before answering the same question, then, humbly and with deep gratitude, he said, ‘I am building a great cathedral.’ Stephanie Dowrick is an interfaith minister in Sydney, Australia.Her most recent book ChoosingHappiness:

A complete version of this article will be available at www.stephaniedowrick.com