The Role of Illusion in the Creation of Religious Beliefs

The Role of Illusion in the Creation of Religious Beliefs by Jeremy Young Sigmund Freud regarded religion as an illusion. His fundamental hypothesis about religion was that God is a projection of an idealised image of the personal father, that "at bottom God is nothing other than an exalted father." (Freud, 1955, p. 147) According to him, this projection takes place in order to fulfil the believer’s wish for protection in a dangerous world. An illusion is a wish-fulfilment. However, a belief that fulfils a wish is an illusion whether or not an object that corresponds to the wish actually exists in the external world. It should be distinguished from a delusion, which is the idea that something is real when it is not. Freud viewed religious illusions negatively because he believed that they were all objectively untrue, and that the illusions upon which religion is based would eventually disappear as humanity advanced towards a more conscious and rational conception of reality (Freud, 1961).

However, one of Freud’s successors, Donald Winnicott, a paediatrician and child psychoanalyst, regarded illusions much more positively. His ideas about illusions were developed as theories concerning the manner in which children gradually grow from dependence upon their mothers to separation from them. At first infants are totally a person’s image of God functions psychologically in the same way as the transitional object functions for the child them in the form of a substitute object, such as a teddy bear or a piece of blanket or cloth. This object Winnicott called a transitional object (Winnicott, 1992) because it enables a transition to take place from dependence on, to independence from, the mother. At the same time that this change occurs, there develops within each child a psychological realm which is neither the inner world nor outer reality. This is the realm Winnicott called potential space.

Other terms for it are transitional or illusory space. It is this realm in which play and creative fantasy take place.

Most people find the concept of potential or illusory space quite difficult to grasp. One way of making sense of it is to make a clear distinction between the world of physical objects, which we experience as outside ourselves, and the internal world of the imagination. Potential space exists, as it were, in between them. It is neither fantasy nor fact, and yet it is both fantasy and fact. It is that mental place in which our imaginations clothe the external world with possibilities and meanings that do not inhere in physical objects as themselves. Thus, the choice of a teddy bear as an object representative of what mother means to the child is a combination of a physical reality (the teddy bear) with a meaning (the comforting presence of mother) that is connected to it by the imaginative activity of the child. For the child, the teddy bear really has the same emotional value as the mother — to lose it will result in extreme and inconsolable distress, as innumerable parents have witnessed. dependent upon their mothers or mother-substitutes for all their physical and emotional needs. If all goes well, in the course of the first few years of life they accumulate sufficient positive experiences of mothering to internalise a sense of self-confidence and value. If this is strong enough they are able to risk moving away from their mothers in order to engage with the outside world. However, children still need reassurance. In order to fulfil this need, they create the illusion of having the mother still present with The teddy bear is, however, not in reality the mother. Such fantasies enable the child, through internalising the feelings of safety and comfort associated with the presence of mother, to engage positively with the outer environment. This is the foundation of the adult’s inner sense of security and self-belief.

As children grow, the imaginative use of potential space enables them to overcome repeated experiences of disillusionment, whenever their previously held conceptions prove to be untrue. Play is the activity in which these fantasies are elaborated and tried out for size (Winnicott, 1971). From this perspective, the creative fantasies that take place in potential space are not pure fictions; they are the origins of the beliefs through which we each endow the physical world with meaning and hope.

We all have conceptions about what reality is like which transcend what we are able to observe. Even though these ideas may be supported by scientific investigation or by social tradition, they go je '| beyond the evidence. They include i metaphysical, ideological, moral and religious beliefs. In terms of Winnicott’s theory, they are all illusions. This does not mean that they are false, but neither can they be demonstrated to be true.

Building on Winnicott’s work, AnaMaria Rizzuto (1979) describes God as a special type of object representation or transitional object. This means that a person’s image of God functions psychologically in the same way as the transitional object functions for the child: it enables the adult to engage with reality and have some sense of control, meaning and value whilst doing so. Rizzuto examined empirically the personal religious imagery of several individuals and related it to their psychological development. According to her, individuals may give collective religious symbols a wide variety of meanings that may have little to do with the official interpretations by ecclesiastical authorities. She makes a distinction between "the God of official religion” and "the personal God;” in other words and in Christian terms, between the God proclaimed by the teachings of the Church and the God experienced as a reality in the inner life of the believer. The latter is “the living God,” the one who is the true object of belief and worship. Rizzuto’s work is very suggestive because it provides an empirical account of how the socially constructed forms of religion, “the God of official religion,” function in the inner worlds of both children and adults.

There are also extremely important social factors influencing the creation of religious beliefs, but there is no space to describe them in this article.

According to Rizzuto, "the living God" comes into existence as a result of the interaction of each individual’s psychological processes with the teachings, rituals and communal practices of a religious community. Very often the official or orthodox interpretations of religious images are not the same as the meanings that are attributed to them by believers. For example, the loving father God of official teaching may be experienced by someone who has been physically abused in childhood as an abusive and controlling monster, or as powerless or absent by one who suffered childhood neglect. Ordinarily believers create their own unique internal depiction of God, which may have more or less in common with orthodox teaching or iconography. These pictures are, in one way or another, the products of their own individual psychological organisation as it has developed over the course of their lives. There may be a subtle and complex relationship between past and present experience and the manner in which God is perceived by any particular Christian. Even though they are constructed in large part from images which are present in their social contexts, the “Gods” people actually believe in turn out to be creations of their own minds and hearts, their own interpretations for their own use.

Furthermore, individual ways of believing are not static or achieved once and for all, but are constantly subject to modification in reaction to experience throughout the whole lifespan. There is very strong evidence to support the idea that the personal Gods that individuals believe in are related to their stages of personal development, and will normally change as they mature (Fowler, 1981; Fowler et al.,1991). This is why many of those who believed that God was a paternal and protective figure when they were young, have since come to have a different image of what he is like, perhaps a friend or lover, perhaps an impersonal force for good, perhaps an amoral power running the universe, perhaps a goddess who is the source of life. Religious doubts and, possibly, a loss of faith are likely to arise if the God of official religion is not sufficiently adaptable to accommodate individuals’ psychological growth, or if individuals are not able to modify their earlier images of God into ones appropriate to their present levels of emotional development.

Viewing religious beliefs as illusions, in this sense, makes clear the role of individual psychology in creating them whilst leaving open the question of whether or not the God to whom those beliefs refer has an objective existence or not. The non-realist may regard the various "Gods" in whom Christians or others believe as expressions of their own inner emotional lives which help them to handle the pressures of existence. The realist may concede that the forms in which we declare a belief in God are in many respects human creations, but argue that God is intimately connected with and inspires the processes through which individuals form their beliefs. In either case, it is clear that individuals’ conceptions of their religious beliefs need to change throughout the lifecycle if religious practice is to be a source of emotional strength and maturity rather than an inhibiting and restrictive influence on psychological growth. Even if the official forms of religion stay the same, the ways in which individuals understand them must be continuously revised. A healthy religion is one that is always developing.

References Fowler, J.W. (1981). Stages of Faith: The Psychology of Human Development and the Quest for Meaning.

San Francisco: Harper & Row.

Fowler, J.W., Nipkow, K.E. & Schweitzer, F. (eds.) (1991 ).

Stages of Faith Development: Implications for Church, Education and Society. London: SCM Press.

Freud, S. (1955). Totem and Taboo. In J. Strachey (ed. and trans.), The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud Vol. 13, (pp. 1-162).

London: Hogarth. (Original work published 1913) Freud, S. (1961). The Future of an Illusion. In J. Strachey (ed. and trans.), The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud Vol. 21, (pp. 3-56).

London: Hogarth. (Original work published 1927) Rizzuto, A-M. (1979) The Birth of the Living God.

Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Winnicott, D.W. (1971). Playing and Reality.

Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.

Winnicott, D.W. (1992). Transitional Objects and Transitional Phenomena. In D.W. Winnicott, Through Paediatrics to Psychoanalysis: Collected Papers. London: Karnac Books and the Institute of Psycho-analysis. (Original work published in 1951).

Jeremy Young is an Anglican priest who is now working as a systemic family therapist.