The Future of the Judeo-Christian Tradition in the Second Axial Age A Conference Report by SOF chair, Patti Whaley, 8 March 2004 Christians don’t need to be born again; they need to grow up. (Jack Spong) The Westar Institute’s recent conference was entitled The Future of the Judeo-Christian Tradition in the Second Axial Age. Westar Institute scholars and others describe the era of rapid growth in religious maturity between 800-400BCE, as the ‘first Axial Age’. At this time monotheism, Confucianism, Buddhism, Jainism and Taoism all crystallised. They regard this present time of revolutionary technological change as a ‘second Axial Age’, and reflect on the religious changes taking place. The conference met in New York with an international line-up of major liberal / radical theologians in an attempt to gain a broader audience.
I had three purposes in attending: to ‘catch up’ on any new theological trends; to raise the profile of the Sea of Faith in the US; and to see what possibilities there might be for links between recent theological thinking and sustainability. This report reflects briefly on those three aims and closes with a brief reflection on Westar. 1. New theological trends I was pleased to find that I was more up to date than I thought, as much of what was presented seemed to be in the way of consolidation than new exploration, and almost everything that was presented had already been published by Polebridge, the publishing arm of the Westar Institute. The core of the conference (talks by Robert Funk, John Spong, Don Cupitt, Lloyd Geering, Marcus Borg) dealt with the need to abandon traditional ‘theistic’ talk about God, though with differing views on whether a ‘real’ God exists (Spong, Borg) or not (Cupitt, Geering). The non-realist philosophical approach of Don Cupitt is less well known in the US than in the UK, and the US audience is clearly interested, if not yet quite convinced. Views on the future of the churches are mixed. Cupitt clearly believes that the Judeo-Christian tradition is in terminal decline, and that spirituality will evolve into a much more personal approach to creating | | cinoe’s =YWeStar value and meaning in one’s Dw es rtre te own life. Spong and Borg hope that the liberal fringe and what Spong calls ‘the church in exile’ may outlast the prevailing fundamentalism, which they see as insecure, reactionary and fated to die out. Much as I might hope they are correct, I think they fail to take into account the strength of the churches in the southern hemisphere.
Surrounding this central core were a number of other topics. Anne Primavesi gave a disappointingly thin and general talk on Gaia philosophy. Richard Holloway called for a new moral paradigm closer to the creativity of the jazz pianist as compared to the more formulaic approach of the church organist (which does grave injustice to church organists!); but both he and the follow-up seminar of shorter papers on ‘the moral imperative’ failed to identify any urgent need ‘or action beyond endorsing gay marriage and homosexual rights generally. While these are certainly important and very current in the US generally and the Episcopalian Church specifically, they are not the top of my list in terms of life-and-death matters. Karen Armstrong gave a very endearing talk based on her recent autobiography, The Spiral Staircase; given the bestseller status of her History of God and the success of her later books, it was disarming to hear her describe herself as ‘a complete failure at three separate careers’ before she started writing.
The most interesting talks for me were those by Karen King and Elaine Pagels dealing with gnostic or “pre-orthodox” gospels, drawn from King’s book The Gospel of Mary of Magdala and Pagel’s Beyond Belief. Both regard the gnostic gospels as a way of understanding the struggles over doctrine and power that characterised the early centuries of Christendom. Their explanations were interesting both in terms of the specific texts referred to and in terms of critical method more generally. King noted the difficulty of reading Biblical texts without subconsciously adding the gloss of later church teaching. Mary of Magdala, for example, is never referred to in the Bible as a prostitute although we commonly think of her in this way. This characterisation may have been promulgated by the early Church fathers in order to discredit the more favoured and powerful position she holds in the non-canonical Gospel of Mary of Magdala. If we assume that the distinction between canonical and non-canonical texts is a political choice (rather than a divinely guided choice), we then have the option of accepting the political choices made by the early church fathers, or viewing the non-canonical texts as potentially of equal authority. overall the conference seemed very far away from any sense of moral urgency focus on extracting an historically ‘accurate’ Jesus from the Gospel texts is somewhat at odds with SoF’s more postmodern stance which questions whether any single historical view of Jesus can be ultimately authoritative.
Most importantly, Westar has been primarily a scholarly endeavour with a clearly ‘top-down’ approach, to an extent which I had not fully realised before this conference. For example, the conference consisted entirely of plenary talks, and following some of the talks questions were invited only from the other scholars rather than from the audience at large, which generated quite a bit of muttering in the galleries. Ironically, the emphasis on experts telling This approach does raise more general questions about authority which the conference didn’t really have time to explore. For example, Marcus Borg outlined ‘Five New Fundamentals’ one of which was ‘the primacy of Jesus in the Christian tradition, including in conflicts between Jesus and the Bible.’ Given that most of what we know of Jesus is based on the Bible, it isn’t clear how Borg would defend any extra-Biblical view of Jesus as something other than a projection of his own moral and social preferences. A different picture of Jesus might emerge from the noncanonical gospels, although again it’s not clear how we could say authoritatively that this picture is ‘more accurate’ than the one in the canonical gospels, although we might subjectively prefer it or it might be of more use in underpinning our current ethical stance.
A number of background papers had been distributed before the conference, by lesser-known American scholars.
Although they received little or no attention at the conference, some of these were more interesting than the plenary talks. It’s an understandable but somewhat regrettable feature of conferences that they need ‘Big Names’ to attract attendees and press interest, but the Big Names simply repeat what is in their latest book. The lesserknown scholars who were asked to write background papers appeared to write something specifically for the conference, so there were actually more new ideas in the background papers than in the plenary talks. 2. Promoting Sea of Faith in the US and Canada The Sea of Faith has quite a number of individual members in North America, but has not had sufficient critical mass in any one place to start any active groups.
Most people in search of radical theology join the Westar and Snowstar Institutes (www.snowstar.org) or the Center for Progressive Christianity TCPC (www.tcpc.org). Several SoF theologians (Cupitt, Geering and others) have been appointed Fellows of the Westar Institute in the past few years. Cupitt and Geering were both awarded their John A.
T. Robinson medal at the closing banquet of the conference. All of this gives Sea of Faith increasing profile at Westar events, and SoF is generally recognized as perhaps the main ally and counterpart to Westar in the UK arena.
There are however very important differences between the Westar approach and the SoF approach. Westar is radical but not explicitly nonrealist, as SoF generally is; SoF is not exclusively Christian, as Westar is. Westar’s the lay people what to think seems to replicate the authoritarian church habits that Westar ought to be resisting. SoF is much more clearly concerned with empowering parish clergy and lay people to explore radical theology, although that empowerment clearly relies on the sort of modern critical scholarship that Westar is promoting. 3. Links between radical theology and sustainability In spite of the references to ‘the ecological imperative’ and ‘the moral imperative’ in the conference programme, I could see little evidence of much engagement in current issues among the Westar speakers outside of questions about gay rights. Anne Primavesi’s talk on Gaia and Richard Holloway’s talk on moral jazz were too general and theoretical to provide practical leverage, and the follow-up discussion on ‘the moral imperative’ wandered off into ivory-tower questions about ‘whether conversation is the ideal locum for ethical exploration’. Sustainability was not mentioned at all, and overall the conference seemed very far away from any sense of moral urgency; perhaps the main impact of it was to make me aware of my own growing impatience with scholarly discussion no matter how theoretically interesting it might be. 4. Overall reflections I enjoyed the conference and made useful connections with a number of people. However, although the conference was interesting and a number of the speakers were excellent, I doubt very much whether it achieved its aim of bringing radical theology toa larger audience. About 300 people attended, and the response to each speaker was very warm, but the conference did not produce much in the way of either a programme for change at the local church level, or a moral stance on any broader social or ethical issues other than gay rights and condemnation of Mel Gibson’s latest film. Westar certainly have a stable full of wellknown theologians, but there was very little press attention and I’m not convinced they have found the right formula for using them in a way that would bring about substantial change in the American religious landscape.
More about Westar can be found at www.westarinstitute.org ADVERTISMENT DO YOU HAVE A "PSYCHE-ANIMA"?