Looking through the lecture transcripts of the two 'Sea of Faith' conferences there seemed to be something missing.
The contents of the lectures may be divided up into three areas. The most frequently mentioned topic is what radical Christianity is against. This is quite easy to list: supernaturalism, literalism, realism, fundamentalism etc. A less frequently mentioned subject is what radical Christianity is for. This is a little more difficult to summarise but generally it is ethical, non-hierarchical, individual, post-liberal, creative, celebratory, heretical etc. Finally, the subject barely mentioned is what radical Christianity is There is no detailed explanation of how radical Christianity re-interprets the Bible or how radical Christians practise religion ; what would perhaps be the most interesting topic is missing.
I shall look at the few hints and comments made in the lectures on how radical Christianity could be practised and then discuss why this area has been excluded. There are a number of general comments made about what radical Christianity should be like.
For example : * "we need to be developing a religion that finds equality and spontaneity exciting ... a way of celebrating human emancipation" (Don Cupitt) * "generate radically new conventions of meaning, new images, new metaphors, new ways of seeing that might have the power to disclose to us a cosmos that is infused with ethos" (Loyal Rue) * "in the figure of Christ we have a powerful manifestation of the truth about our existence" (Loyal Rue) * "a blissful yielding to all life's joys and sorrows" (Scott Cowdell) * "life can be accepted as gratuitous ... death can be embraced as friendly" (Scott Cowdell) * "the song of the crucified is a better one than 'Always look on the bright side of life— (Scott Cowdell) * "the modern Christian is free to be mythical ...
Christians live in myth as they live towards truth" (Douglas Davis) This is all very interesting but we aren't told what Scott Cowdell actually thinks "the song of the crucified" is, or how we are supposed to embrace death as friendly, while Cupitt and Rue sound as if radical Christianity is still in the design stage and no one has actually tried it yet I In all the lectures there were only four attempts to relate radical Christianity to traditional doctrines or teachings : * In "Inequalities" Don Cupitt equates the postmodern age with the eschatological age. * Cupitt interprets the Sermon on the Mount "as teaching that eternal life is to be completely and self-lessly absorbed in the present finite moment. Creative love and creative work are a kind of ecstasy in which we can forget ourselves and escape the fear of clock-time". * He interprets Jesus' death for us as "we die before death, and we are thereby liberated for eternal, non-egotistic life now". * Scott Cowdell says "following Christ to Golgotha is the image 'par excellence' of this scattering and dispersal of the self".
Worst of all, I was only able to find just two examples of how radical Christianity might actually function : * In "Inequalities", Cupitt speaks of the "postmodern Eucharist as a ceremonial enactment of the death and dispersal of God". * Graham Shaw describes "being creative in your prayers, forming images of God, refining those images, dwelling on them".
So although Cupitt says that Jesus' death for us means we "die before death", he never explains how this is to be effected, or how we are supposed to experience it. (I love the Gospel of Nicodemus with Christ smashing the gates of Hell and conquering Death, but since this only operates on a symbolic level there must be a process whereby it enters me/ marks my sou I / becomes real for me.) Similarly, Cowdell never explains how we are to embrace death as friendly. Douglas Davis does not say how we may "live in myth" etc.
I believe there are three reasons why the topic that most radical Christians want to hear about, the practicalities of living as a radical Christian, is missing from the 'Sea of Faith' lectures. ■ Theologians and philosophers enjoy theory and theorising. I suspect most of the lecturers would prefer to analyse how much Cupitt has been influenced by Derrida and Baudrillard than try to work out how to put into practice what he says. Trying to develop new spiritual practices isn't on the 'agenda' of anyone. ■ Much of the 'practice' of radical Christianity is seen as ethical - fighting for equality, against injustice etc and this fits easily into the theoretical practice of radical theology. Some lecturers saw artists as possible innovators of religion but interestingly Cupitt denied artists a leading role on the grounds that they are not morally better than anyone else, thus reducing all spiritual practices to ethical actions. ■ It is genuinely very difficult to identify what benefit spiritual practices bring. Being religious doesn't mean you are morally any better than a secular person, or that you are theoretically better able to ground your moral beliefs, or that you are a more mature and serious person, or that you are better able to accept your finitude.
If any claim is made at all about what benefit radical Christianity can bring, it often hinges on nihilism and finitude. However, I suspect that for most radical Christians neither of these issues holds much interest.
Questions of ecology, human and animal rights, sexism, racism, fighting oppression etc are important to many radical Christians and thus the problem of nihilism appears as an indulgence of the affluent.
Similarly the attitude a person has to death in general, and to one's own death and the death and friends and loved ones in particular, depends not on whether a person holds to a set of beliefs (radical Christian or traditional) but to how strong a person's spirit is, what sort of strength of character they have etc.
Cupitt's warnings against making artists and writers into new leaders is based on his seeing radical Christianity in purely ethical terms. While secular morality is effective against superstitious immorality (e.g. sexism), we should not see religion solely in terms of ethics. The religious code is operating in art whether we like it or not, and radical Christianity could integrate such an aesthetic into a wider religious flow.
In rock music, for example, the Christian code frequently appears (and I'm not referring to the evangelical punk bands of the early 80s). U2 and Bob Dylan are ready examples, but there are a lot more : individual songs such as Lou Reed's "Dime Store Mystery", Depeche Mode's "Personal Jesus" and Queen's "Jesus" ; groups such as The Jesus and Mary Chain, Jesus Jones, The Christians, Christian Death, The Bible, The Fall, The Sisters of Mercy etc - even Madonna.
While art could widen the Christian narrative and interrelate it with other codes and meanings, religion can't be practised vicariously. Radical Christian practices need to be developed and disseminated to show that it is a realistic option for thinking Christians and not just the highbrow indulgence of a few intellectuals.
Thus the problem remains that radical theology and 'Sea of Faith' have generally not given radical Christians any practical information on how they may develop spiritually. Unless it is able to come up with this sort of advice, the 'Sea of Faith' group will probably only function in organising already existing anti-conservative forces rather than developing into a mass movement.