WINTER 1991 PAGE 9 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE RADICALS AND DIVORCE :
A PRACTICAL CHRISTIAN ETHIC by Elizabeth Burns Radicals frequently have something to say about ethics in general - about the implications of the traditional Christian view and why we should reject it, or about the principles radicals should use in forming their own ethical views. However, they don't very often talk about the way in which their beliefs relate to specific moral issues - things like abortion, euthanasia, divorce and so on. Of course, many of these issues have been discussed ad infinitum by both traditional Christians and secular moral philosophers, and some of the conclusions arrived at could be described as 'radical' ; but they are 'radical' only in the sense that they depart from the traditionally accepted view - if there is such a thing - and not because they have any connection with radical religious beliefs.
I'm not suggesting that we don't need to talk about ethics in general, but we must remember that theories and principles are only tools which enable us to decide how to act ; they are not valuable in their own right. Theories and principles without practical application are worse than useless. `RADICAL CHRISTIAN ETHICS' Thus, in addition to 'traditional Christian ethics' and 'secular ethics', we need 'radical Christian ethics'.
This is not to say that we can always place specific solutions to moral problems under particular headings - 'traditional Christian', 'secular' or 'radical'. Unfortunately, things are not so straightforward as this.
Traditional Christians, secular philosophers and radicals will all disagree amongst themselves about specific cases. All we can say is that, given certain accepted starting principles, there is likely to be a broad measure of agreement about moral problems, and that some possible solutions will consequently be ruled out. In other words, I'm not suggesting that all radicals with agree with abortion on demand, for example, but that, given their religious beliefs, their views on this subject are likely to lie within a certain area.
COUNSELLING AND DIVORCE Let's illustrate this by looking at a specific moral problem, that of divorce. A radical seeking advice about whether divorce is permissable in certain circumstances has two choices. She can consult a traditional Christian counsellor in the hope of attaining a religious and moral perspective on her problem and risk being told that her beliefs, since they are not of the traditional variety, cannot possibly be considered Christian and that a Christian perspective therefore cannot help her. Alternatively, she can consult a secular counsellor who is similarly unlikely to see the importance of her religious beliefs in deciding which course of action to take.
To the traditional Christian counsellor, the radical might reply that there are a number of reasons why she finds herself unable to believe in the traditional view (the problem of evil, or the difficulties associated with belief in life after death, for example). But she might also refuse to take the view of the secular counsellor, on the grounds that there are good reasons for retaining a non-supernatural version of Christianity. Secular morality does not place the same emphasis on respect for our fellow human beings or provide the means by which people can be encouraged and enabled to act accordingly. Thus, the radical may reject many doctrinal aspects of the traditional view but she is likely to accept that much of its ethical teaching must still be taken seriously.
JESUS' TEACHING ON DIVORCE On the question of divorce, such an acceptance presents problems since it would appear that divorce is usually prohibited in the New Testament. In the Gospels of Mark and Luke, Jesus does not permit divorce. In Matthew, Jesus allows divorce if adultery has taken place, but scholars are generally agreed that Matthew added this exception. In his first letter to the Corinthians, Paul, like Mark and Luke, records Jesus' prohibition of marital separation. However, he does say that, if this should occur, those involved must remain unmarried. And separation is permissible in cases in which one partner is not a Christian, although the Christian partner must not initiate it. But `no divorce' is clearly the ideal. Radicals must provide good reasons if they wish to question this teaching.
It has been suggested that Jesus' teaching on this matter was designed to protect women who would be destitute without a man to support them. If this is right, radicals could say that, since 20th century women are PAGE 10 WINTER 1991 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE no longer so dependent on men - the law makes provision for divorcees who are unable to support themselves - this teaching is no longer applicable.
However, there are other good reasons why Jesus may have taught that divorce is not permissible, besides the financial ones. For example, children often suffer in many ways if their parents' marriage breaks down, and most human beings require the emotional stability provided by enduring relationships.
Perhaps Jesus was aware of these possibilities and, since they undoubtedly apply today, his prohibition of divorce still stands.
But marital breakdown does not inevitably involve children. In Jesus' time there was no contraception and thus it would have been rare for a couple to be childless and common for them to have many children. If the effect on the children was Jesus' reason for prohibiting divorce, it surely cannot apply to couples who have no children.
Howeve r, whether or not children are involved, there may be circumstances in which it is unreasonable to expect a couple to remain married. Many scholars think that although Jesus does not seem to permit divorce, he did not intend his words to be taken legalistically. He realised that Moses allowed divorce because of men's hard-heartedness and that, while hard-heartedness remains, such a strict command cannot always be kept. And both Matthew and Paul seem to have translated Jesus' statement of God's will for an ideal world into instructions for behaviour in an imperfect society.
Thus, to suggest, on the basis of the Biblical account, that a woman (or man) who is repeatedly beaten up by her (or his) spouse is immoral in seeking a divorce is supremely unethical and certainly incompatible with Jesus' command to "Love your neighbour". It is surely not loving to expect someone to live in circumstances in which their well-being and possibly even life is threatened. Of course there are less dramatic adverse circumstances than these and it isn't always easy to draw the line. But although acceptance of an absolute rule such as `no divorce' might have the advantage of clarity, this advantage is gained at the price of much suffering.
DIVORCE AND REMARRIAGE It might be argued that most traditional Christians don't hold such a view. But this is not the case. We have seen, in the last eighteen months or so, the great reluctance with which the House of Commons accepted the Clergy (Ordination) Measure. When the Measure receives Royal Assent, those who are divorced and remarried will be able to become Anglican priests. The House of Commons rejected the Measure on an earlier occasion and its eventual acceptance was contested only a few months ago by four members of the General Synod.
You might be thinking that this only affects divorced and remarried would-be priests. On the contrary.
Rejection of the measure implies a criticism of all divorced people. The solicitor employed by the aforementioned members of the General Synod said that, "Priests should have unblemished credentials. If a man goes into the priesthood, he should set high standards." So, to reject the Measure is to say that all those who are divorced and remarried do not have sufficiently high moral standards to become members of the clergy. They may have no desire to be ordained, but they are deprived of the opportunity because they are thought to be morally second class.
More recently, the "Church Times" of 21 December, 1990, records that Roman Catholic Church authorities have sacked four governors of a Roman Catholic aided primary school in London for trying to appoint a divorced and remarried man as headteacher. Even the sacked governors thought that the Church was, in principle, right, but said that since they had so few candidates from which to make their selection they had chosen "the lesser of two evils". A representative of the diocese justified the authorities' action by saying that someone whose behaviour conflicts with Church teaching could not be appointed to such a post.
RADICALS AND DIVORCE Undoubtedly, some divorced people are morally culpable ; I am not trying to justify a case such as that in which Mrs X becomes disenchanted with Mr X and thinks that perhaps Mr Y would be a better bet. But it is unfair to tar all divorcees with the same brush. It has become unfortunately fashionable to say that it takes two to create a marital problem so that even those who are grossly mistreated are obliged to believe that they must have provoked or deserved such behaviour.
It is also unfair to tar all traditional Christians with the same brush by suggesting that they all take the view of divorce against which I have tried to argue. But, as is shown by my two examples, many do. I have attempted to show that it is less likely that radicals will take such a view. Because the Bible and the person of Christ do not have the same kind of authority for them as they do for some traditional Christians, they are likely to be more critical of Jesus' teaching and the Biblical record. They therefore have a job to do in campaigning against the immoral attitudes to this problem taken by some traditional believers.
ELIZABETH BURNS is researching a PhD at Cambridge concerning realist and anti-realist versions of radical Christianity and is a member of the SOF IV Planning Group on the Steering Committee.