David Paterson is a parish priest who has served for many years on the SoF UK Steering Group. He is currently a Trustee of the SoF Development Trust. ‘Muslim Women’ stereotypes and struggles Raheel Raza, a Muslim woman, reflects on Muslim women’s priorities, in contrast with Western media interests and Muslim men’s interpretations of the Quran Since September 11 Muslims, and especially Muslim women, have been under the microscope. Unfortunately, the media have been responsible for presenting a garbled image of Muslim women, providing negative portrayals and sensationalist propaganda based on limited evidence.
Living in almost 60 different countries of the world, Muslims form a rich and diverse cultural mosaic. There is great plurality with major differences in the traditions of African Arab, Asian and European Muslims, as well as differences in language, food and clothing from one region to another. Stereotypical assumptions about us as "Women in Black" are as inaccurate as the assumption that the bikiniclad cast of "Baywatch" personifies all American women.
The obsession of the Western press with Muslim women is not surprising, since the press in general tends to view Muslims simplistically. Headlines in the mainstream media have reduced Muslim female identity to an article of clothing, "the veil". It's rare to have a conversation about Muslim women without this four-letter word, "veil", yet it does not have a universal meaning. In some cultures, it refers to a face covering known as niqab; in others, to a simple headscarf, known as hijab. Other recent trip to Dubai in the Arabian Gulf. The majority of the women there wear long loose clothes and cover their hair, but they cover by choice and not by force. I also found them very confident, content and in some ways liberated on a spiritual and intellectual level. They work outside their homes, they are educators, politicians, leaders and also sit in a tent by the beach in the evening and smoke a flavoured hubbly bubbly!
This confirmed what I've always believed — that, despite numerous obstacles, Muslim women are active, assertive and engaged in society. In Qatar, women make up the majority of graduate-school students. The Iranian parliament has more women members than the US Senate and currently there is major discussion and debate taking place amongst the educated women of Iran. According to Islam and Gender, by Professor Ziba Mir Husseini, women are questioning the clergy about their rights and are looking for opportunities to show that the general message of the Quran is one of egalitarianism. The book reports that many the burka was not, and is not, manifestations include all-encompassing Afgh an women ’s m aj or fo cus of concern outer garments like the ankle-length abaya from the Persian Gulf states, the chador in Iran or the burka in Afghanistan.
The Western media suggest the burka means everything to Muslim women and routinely express bewilderment at the fact that Afghan women did not cast off their burkas when the Taliban were defeated. Western feminists want to liberate Afghan women by removing their burka, which to them has become a symbol of repression. But the burka was not, and is not, Afghan women’s major focus of concern.
Their priorities are more basic, like feeding their children, becoming literate and living free from violence.
This misrepresentation is a product of the exclusion of modern, successful Muslim women from mainstream media. It's unfortunate that the achievements of many Muslim women today are buried under an avalanche of misinformation by the media in projecting them as third class citizens or non-contributing members of society.
Let me share with you a personal anecdote from my Muslim women in Iran are highly educated and professionally trained; they participate in public debates, are often catalysts for reform and are champions for their own rights.
Professor Riffat Hassan, a trail blazer in the field of women's rights and founder of the International Network of Rights for Female Victims of Violence in Pakistan, says, "God who speaks through the Quran, is characterized by justice, and it is stated with the utmost clarity in the Quran that God can never be guilty of unfairness or tyranny...hence the Quran as God's word cannot be made the source of human injustice, and the injustice to which Muslim women have been subjected cannot be regarded as God-derived".
Exploitation of women in Islamic societies is not religious, but cultural. It springs from ignorance of Quranic injunctions and blatant misinterpretation of Islamic commands and has been routinely ignored by the Muslim community at large. If we were to construct a society on the true basis of Islam, men and women would be equal in the sight of God.
About 100 years after the message of Islam, women's rights were set in place under Sharia law, which means the path. According to this law, Muslim women possess the right to vote, to pre-nuptial agreements and to inheritance.
They can have an abortion up to the fourth month of pregnancy and birth control is permitted. Furthermore, while Muslim women may participate in battle, and keep their maiden name, they also have the right to keep their wages. I believe it was only in the 1900's that Canadian women were actually declared persons and women in Britain were not allowed to keep their earned wages till the twentieth century.
Judith Tucker's rewarding study of Islamic law in seventeenth and eighteenthcentury Syria and Palestine, In the House of the Law, talks about a period when Muslim legal thinkers gave considerable attention to women's roles in society, and Tucker shows how fatwas, or legal opinions, greatly influenced these roles. She challenges prevailing views on Islam and gender, revealing Islamic law to have been more flexible than previously thought.
In her book Tucker studies court records from Ottoman-Syria and concludes that: 1. the sharia courts were accessible and popular with women; 2. the courts took upon themselves the task of defending women's Islamic rights against the vagaries of custom. For example they would insist on her right to a share of the inheritance or her right to refuse a marriage proposal against her family's or community’s desires; and 3. obtaining a divorce was easy for women who could prove one of the following: physical abuse; mental abuse; sexual incompatibility; the mistreatment of her family; or abandonment for one year. However, divorce by these criteria I no longer possible as the conditions are no longer applied in the modern shari’a family courts.
Ironically, discrimination and victimization of women began with colonization because western institutions would not allow women to open bank accounts without a male counter-signature so their assets were frozen and they experienced the book, Quran and Woman, is the daughter of a Baptist preacher and an African American convert to Islam. She explains that as a Western woman, she would never have accepted a faith that is unfair to women. Quran and Woman is a unique look at the status of women in Islam — a more equal and just status. For fourteen centuries the Quran as the guiding book for Muslims was interpreted solely by men. Everything was filtered through male intellect - even women's issues. So, for a long time, men have told Muslim women about being women.
This has led to Western misconceptions about the roles and status of women in Islam, and also set a poor record of human rights abuse in many Muslim countries.
Some Islamic practices have continuously troubled feminists, both outside observers and Muslims. Issues relating to polygamy, inheritance, women's rights, unequal witness laws and other injunctions seem to discriminate against women.
However, a new and deeper look at the verses in the Quran pertaining to these injunctions, the context in which they were revealed, the spirit in which they were intended plus grammar and language variances, does much to clear up these doubts and misunderstandings.
Social and cultural traditions as well as economic circumstances are the cause of distortion and misinterpretation of the Quran, which has hurt Muslim women a great deal.
Many female Muslim scholars like Wadud have initiated groundbreaking steps towards setting the record straight and their work is referred to as Gender Jihad (Jihad, a struggle to overcome injustice).
Having discussed women in Islam from a political, social, economic and intellectual perspective, let me now touch upon the religious and spiritual perspective. The Quran says: "I shall not lose sight of the labour of any of you who labours in My way, be it man or woman; each of you is equal to the other (3:195)". Spiritual equality, responsibility and accountability for both men and women is a well-developed theme in the Quran. Spiritual equality For fourteen centuries the Quran as the guiding book for Muslims, was interpreted solely by men. deprivation of their rights. Also, Western ways of life and modes of modernity were not compatible with the Islamic system. Social, political and economic factors also added to the cause, but religion became the raison d'etre that men used to legitimize their prejudices. What is truly at fault is a misguided, narrow interpretation of Islam designed to serve a rigid patriarchal system.
Professor Amina Wadud, the author of a controversial between men and women in the sight of God is not limited to purely religious issues, but is the basis for equality in all temporal aspects of human endeavour. The concept of gender equality is best exemplified in the Quranic rendition of Adam and Eve in which both sexes were deliberate and independent. There is no mention of Eve being created out of Adam's rib. The Prophet of Islam remained concerned all his life about the status and treatment of women, because at the time of the revelation of the message of Islam, women were buried alive, treated as chattels and at one point considered to be inhuman without a soul. In his last sermon, the Prophet clearly asked men to treat women with kindness because due to economic conditions, men were responsible for the wellbeing of their women.
The Quran says in 2:228: "and they (women) have rights similar to those of men over them...treat them in a just manner." Some early Muslim women have also become positive role models for us. The Prophet's first wife, Khadijah was a successful businesswoman who was 22 years older than the Prophet and sent a proposal of marriage to him. His second wife, Lady Ayesha actually led a war and rode into combat on a camel. It has been narrated that when the Prophet's daughter Fatema entered the room, the Prophet stood up in respect. Fatema was a mesmerizing public speaker and her sermons have been recorded.
Also noteworthy is Rabia of Basra - the first mystic of Islam.
Given the opportunity, Muslim women, like women everywhere, will become educated, pursue careers, strive to do what is best for their families and contribute positively according to their abilities.
It should be obvious that the critical element Muslim women need is freedom, especially the freedom to make choices that enable them to be independent agents of positive change. How they dress is irrelevant. Choosing to dress modestly, including wearing a head scarf, should be as respected as choosing not to cover.
With regard to what needs to be done in areas of helping Muslim women, especially in Afghanistan, I quote from a paper written by Dr. Layla al Mariati. She says "Traditional Muslim populations will be more receptive to change that is based on Islamic principles of justice, as expressed in the Quran, than they will be to change that abandons religion altogether or confines it to private life.
Muslim scholars and leaders who emphasize Islamic principles that support women's rights to education, health care, marriage and divorce, equal pay for equal work and participation in public life could fill the place now occupied by those who impose a vision of Islam that infringes the rights of women.